The Government, faced with dwindling local gas reserves, first announced plans for an LNG terminal at Port Taranaki in August 2024.
The National-led Government had planned an announcement on the project before the November 7 election, but it has now kicked that into touch until after the poll.
However, the Ministry for Business, Innovation and Employment (MBIE) said it was continuing to manage the procurement process for an LNG import facility, with the proposed solution at Port Taranaki.
The Government had instructed MBIE to progress discussions with a preferred provider, with a view to making a decision after the election.
It looks like a Floating Storage and Regasification Unit (FSRU) – a ship that stores liquefied natural gas (LNG), converts it back into gas, and sends it into a pipeline – is on the cards.
A statement from, MBIE issued on October 15 said it was considering:
A moored vessel that can store LNG and is capable of regasifying and distributing natural gas into the transmission pipeline when required.
Another vessel that carries LNG from suppliers and delivers the LNG to the moored vessel.
The opposition Labour Party has said it would put a stop to the project if it got back into power, while up-and-coming minor party Opportunity also opposes a terminal.
Paul Chapman, manager of energy and risk management services at consultants Energy Link, said much had changed since the National-led coalition announced its plans.
“The LNG market is now so volatile as a result of the Middle East that it is getting people worried in terms of what exposure to an international market might actually look like,” Chapman told the Herald.
“When this was first mooted, it looked like there was going to be an oversupply of energy and it looked like it was going to be relatively cheap, but confidence has now been dented.”
In New Zealand, there was an energy case and a capacity case.
“You can only generate so much and if you haven’t got it, then you need some stored energy, and gas is what has been relied on to do that.”
Once NZ’s largest gas field, Māui is coming to the end of its life.
Chapman noted the Māui gas field is expected to cease production before the end of this year.
“LNG could very well still be an attractive option for those who think that total thermal capacity isn’t high enough to get us through those winter peaks, so there is a case there,” he said.
“But the case for it is nowhere near as rosy as it once was before the Middle East blew up,” he said.
Chapman acknowledged the new power-generation capacity that has come on stream in recent years.
“All of that is very good – absolutely – but it’s not going to get us through a dry, cold winter,” he said.
Still, the electricity system has changed significantly since August 2024, when calm weather and tight gas supply drove wholesale power prices up to an average $820 per megawatt hour (MWh) from a winter average price of around $160/MWh.
This week, power traded at about $75MWh at Ōtāhuhu, while the grid was running on 99% renewable sources thanks to favourable hydro conditions.
In terms of security of supply, one of the most consequential developments was this year’s fast-track panel decision to relax access restrictions on Lake Pūkaki water storage for three years, but there have been others.
Since winter 2024, 20 generation and battery projects with a combined installed capacity of 1209MW – enough to power Auckland on an average day – have been commissioned by Transpower and are now contributing to the grid.
Dozens more projects, worth several billions of dollars, are either under construction or are in the pipeline.
Last year’s ground-breaking Huntly Firming Option deal between Genesis and the other big three generators sees all four share the burden of Huntly’s one-million-tonne coal stockpile, which is kept on hand to cover dry-year risk.
Meanwhile, solar power builds are going ahead at pace, helped in no small part by cheaper solar panels – most of which are made in China.
In another development for renewables, grid-scale batteries – also made in China – are also coming down in price.
The sheer weight of new and planned projects is putting downward pressure on power prices in the influential ASX futures market three years ahead.
That decline will provide some offset for power distribution charges, which are rising and which are officially mandated to go higher still in order to facilitate more investment in the network.
Will LNG become part of New Zealand’s energy mix?
Gas, at least for the purposes of generation, has become less significant.
Two big gas-burning turbines are already out of action – one for good (Contact’s Taranaki Combined Cycle) while a question hangs over Genesis Energy’s Unit 5.
Genesis chief executive Malcolm Johns told the Herald after last week’s annual meeting that the extra energy coming on stream meant Unit 5 usage would go from 12 months a year to probably three to four months a year.
Running Unit 5 for, say, three months a year would make it difficult for it to earn its keep, he said.
The machine – which is of a type that is in hot demand by overseas data centres for on-site power generation – is due for a major refurbishing in 2029, which will cost tens of millions of dollars.
There is a chance Unit 5 will be packed up and sold overseas.
Johns said Huntly’s ageing Rankine turbines, which can run on gas or coal, are a flexible option for when the hydro- and wind-dominated grid needs back-up.
New Zealand’s energy landscape changed when methanol producer Methanex announced the planned closure next year of its plant at Motunui – which at one point consumed about 37% of New Zealand’s gas production.
Methanex has struck a deal to sell substantially all of its gas to Genesis, starting in the first quarter of 2027 and continuing through to the end of the decade.
Forsyth Barr analyst Andrew Harvey-Green said the market is in the dark as to what the most likely outcome would be for LNG in New Zealand.
He said that in terms of meeting dry-year risk, losing Unit 5 would make introducing LNG more challenging.
“In reality, I think Unit 5 will probably have to stay open if LNG does take place, so there would have to be some sort of arrangement to ensure that it does remain.
“LNG, in our view, has always been a backup of a backup.
“Coal provides us with our first line of defence, and if there are issues with the coal and it’s a dry year, then gas is the second line of defence.”
Additional operating expenditure from Genesis would be required to keep Unit 5 up and running, if it decided to retain it.
Harvey-Green said New Zealand’s energy situation is clearer now than it was in 2024.
“Methanex [the closure of Motunui] probably just buys a little bit more time in reality in terms of the gas they were consuming now being available for wider consumption, and for electricity if necessary,” he said.
Basil Sharp, emeritus professor of energy economics at the University of Auckland Business School.
Basil Sharp, emeritus professor of energy economics at the University of Auckland Business School, said the Contact and Genesis Energy moves to pension off their big gas turbines was “obviously a signal”.
“I mean, those guys that are generating electricity, they’ve got a sense of where things are at.
“But I think more importantly, we’ve moved on.
“It would almost be a step back to the days of gas-to-gasoline plant [a Muldoon era Think Big project built in the 1980s] when we wanted to become independent, and it just strikes me that it’s just not a wise move,” he said.
Sharp noted the extra capacity coming on to the market from solar and wind.
“It gives the politicians – you would hope – an opportunity to think more strategically and more long-term and to facilitate this transition away from fossil fuels,” he said.
“It just doesn’t make sense to try and substitute our way around it by importing gas.
For Sharp, the issue is not simply the cost of an LNG terminal but whether New Zealand is solving yesterday’s problem.
“The writing’s on the wall for fossil fuels,” he said.
“We just have to get smarter and transition away from gas into electricity.”
Jamie Gray is an Auckland-based journalist, covering the financial markets, the primary sector and energy. He joined the Herald in 2011.
Stay ahead with the latest market moves, corporate updates, and economic insights by subscribing to our Business newsletter – your essential weekly round-up of all the business news you need.