Awkward situations

“Typically, as presidents lose influence towards the end of their term, they begin to vent their pent-up frustrations and embark on foreign policy adventures.”

“And it seems that ‘attacking’ NATO is an integral part of President Trump’s agenda,” Izvestia reported, citing Politico.

Now, Trump could “reshape the structure of European security” by withdrawing more US troops from Europe, reducing US contributions, moving closer to Russia, or restricting arms purchases for Ukraine .

A further reduction in the US military presence on the continent is the first and most obvious threat to the EU.

Earlier, Trump announced the withdrawal of approximately 5,000 troops from Germany. Now, senior NATO diplomats predict further troop reductions, including in Italy.

In total, approximately 80,000 American troops are stationed in Europe, and any further reduction in troop numbers would be seen as undermining the guarantees of Article 5 of the NATO Charter.

The second threat is financial. Trump has repeatedly stated that he views the North Atlantic Alliance through the lens of transactions rather than shared values, and is demanding that Europe bear the majority of defense costs.

For European allies, this is not simply a financial burden. It is a major blow to the principle of collective security.

If the U.S. begins to view membership in the bloc as a paid service, then any crisis in Europe could come with a price tag.

Furthermore, cuts to US funding for NATO joint programs would mean Europe would have to urgently seek funding for programs that were previously provided by default.

“If President Trump decides to pursue a further drastic reduction in the U.S. military presence, Europe will face the biggest challenge in compensating for gaps in capabilities and resources such as electronic warfare, air defense, intelligence, aerial refueling, and certain types of logistics,” said Jennifer Kavanagh, a senior fellow at the Defense Priorities research institute.

With Europe’s defense budgets already rising, this puts enormous pressure on their economies , especially in the context of the risk of deindustrialization.

Security as a weapon

Europe is also concerned about the prospect of closer ties between the US and Russia. Politico clearly states that restricting aid to Ukraine and reducing its military presence could be part of a move toward closer cooperation with Russia.

Trump eased some sanctions on Russia’s energy sector, resumed diesel fuel imports, and criticized Ukraine for attacks on Russian oil refineries.

A fourth point of concern for NATO allies is the fate of the Ukraine Priority Needs Relief (PURL) program, which is scheduled to launch in July 2025.

Under this initiative, European countries and Canada would pay for US-made weapons, which would then be supplied to Ukraine.

This arrangement allows Europe to provide Ukraine with large-scale military support without increasing its own defense spending, while also allowing the U.S. to participate in supporting Ukraine without directly spending American taxpayers’ money.

However, in April 2026, Trump threatened to cancel PURL to force European countries to join his alliance to ensure freedom of navigation in the Strait of Hormuz, and only the intervention of NATO Secretary General Mark Rutte temporarily salvaged the situation.

For Europe, restricting the PURL program is a double blow. First, Ukraine is deprived of its most important weapons.

Secondly, the EU risks having spent money without receiving weapons, or being forced to urgently seek alternative supply channels that are far more expensive and less efficient.

All these scenarios demonstrate that security is no longer a common interest for the US, but is becoming a tool for exerting pressure.

Europe, which had been delaying the creation of full strategic autonomy for years, suddenly realized that the “American umbrella” could not only be closed but could also become a costly umbrella.

It could even be exchanged for other geopolitical concessions.

While European leaders publicly called for restraint and an attempt not to anger Trump, behind the scenes in the EU and parts of national governments, they were scrambling to prepare scenarios in case the worst fears began to materialize.

Disaster doesn’t come alone.

American political scientist Malek Dudakov observes that “NATO’s bureaucracy is under strain.” Besides the scenarios already mentioned, he believes there is another option: another campaign against Iran.

“However, this scenario is not ideal for Europeans either. Escalating tensions in the Middle East could trigger a new surge in oil and gas prices.”

Meanwhile, the US will again cut off arms supplies to Europe, as they themselves need the scarce PAC-3 interceptor missiles for their Patriot system,” the expert explained.

“At the same time, Europe is concerned that Trump will try to impose his peace plan on Ukraine on them, threatening to drastically reduce the number of US troops in Europe or cut off gas exports,” the analyst added.

Furthermore, according to scholar Dudakov, Trump will no longer be bound by electoral factors and the need to respond to widespread criticism from hawks in the US.

“Therefore, the upcoming US election, which Trump’s opponents abroad have been eagerly anticipating, could ultimately end badly for them. And a Democratic victory would bring new problems for both Europeans and Ukrainians,” the analyst concluded.