Democrats swept the US Congress on November 3, leaving Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth facing an impeachment push and opening questions over Donald Trump’s approach to Iran, Ukraine and China.

Democrats hold at least 54 Senate seats, with Alaska and Mississippi uncalled, and had won at least 228 House seats by the morning of November 4, Bloomberg reported, with NBC News projecting a final 258-177 split. The projected 13-point Democratic margin in the House popular vote would be the widest by either party since 1974, Yahoo News calculated. Early exit polls put Trump’s approval at 38%, CBS News said.

The new Congress does not sit until January 3, Trump keeps his veto and overriding it takes two-thirds of both chambers. Any shift in foreign policy therefore has to come from a weakened president changing his own mind, or from Democrats squeezing the money. “Remember that this election changes the Congress; it does not change the president,” J.C. Lintzenich of the German Marshall Fund told CNBC. Bronwen Maddox of Chatham House called Trump “extraordinarily hard to predict” before the vote.

Vice-President JD Vance wrote the bluntest post-mortem himself, in a long post on X on November 4. “The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night,” he said. An unnamed pollster had asked Trump voters who defected what would bring them back, and the top four answers, “accounting for nearly all of the responses”, were: “End the war”, “Focus on cost of living/inflation”, “Put America First” and “Change our relationship to Israel”. The fourth came a day after Trump said he and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had agreed to stop $4bn in annual military funding.

About nine in 10 voters called the cost of living a crucial or major factor in their vote, well ahead of the war: 88% on the election-night numbers from CNN, 49% crucial and 39% major. The Iran war scored 74%, with 34% crucial and 40% major. Government corruption matched the cost of living, according to the CBS News exit poll, which puts the war behind both. In the AP Voter Poll, the same SSRS survey, about four in 10 named the economy as the country’s top issue and few chose foreign policy, although about six in 10 called the attack on Iran the wrong decision.

The war’s main route to voters looks to be the pump. US regular gasoline averaged below $3 a gallon before the fighting began on February 28, ABC News reported, and was still $4.153 on November 2, up $1.134 y/y, with diesel at $6.292, up $2.539, according to the US Energy Information Administration. House Democratic leader Hakeem Jeffries blamed the “reckless and costly war of choice in Iran” for dearer fuel and fertiliser, after the near-closure of Hormuz, one of the world’s chokepoints, set off a fertiliser shock. “I think it’s largely true because it drove the gasoline up a little bit short term,” Trump said of Vance’s verdict.

TRUMP: No retreat in public. “If I had it to do again, I’d have to do it again,” he said of the war on November 4, while accepting the results and promising, in a New York Times interview, to “work with the Democrats”. Time reported aides bracing for staff turnover and a senior official predicting more focus on the Western Hemisphere.

Three paths are open – humility, legacy-building abroad or revenge – and the third is the likeliest, according to Ukraine Business News, which expects him to be “erratic but ultimately constrained” on Russia and Ukraine. “Every time Trump has been backed into a corner, he has shouted more and come out fighting,” Peter Loge of George Washington University told AFP. Speaking before the vote, German diplomat Wolfgang Ischinger told Politico that a president boxed in at home is “bound to gravitate to where Congress is weak – on foreign and trade policies”.

VANCE: His post “launched the 2028 presidential campaign”, in the reading of CNN analyst Stephen Collinson, and it dares colleagues to defend the war: “If you’d like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so.” Donald Trump Jr reposted it approvingly, Fox News reported, though the president does not know for sure that Vance will run, according to the Washington Examiner.

Vance led the US delegation at the April talks with Iran in Islamabad, AP reported in July, and could now take more control of the file, according to Esfandyar Batmanghelidj of the Bourse & Bazaar Foundation think-tank. “His only pathway to a viable run in 2028 is to fix the disaster Trump waltzed into,” he wrote on X. The weak point: he stayed in office throughout and was noticeably quiet when the war began, AP has noted.

HEGSETH: First in line, by most accounts. Republicans are privately pinning the defeat on the defence secretary as the man who oversold a quick win, and Kentucky Republican Thomas Massie plans to force an impeachment vote when the House returns in the week of November 9, CNN reported, with multiple Republican sources expecting it to pass. Massie has drafted eight articles, including alleged breaches of the War Powers Resolution, and puts the chance of passage at better than 50%, Roll Call reported in October. Removal would need two-thirds of the Senate, where Republicans keep control until January.

Trump says Hegseth is “doing a very good job” and denies any plan to fire him, and a Senate under Democrats would make any successor harder to confirm. A Pentagon spokesman said he is “100% committed” to serving out the term. “I think he probably knows he’s dead,” one unnamed administration official told CNN. Mitchell Reiss of RUSI expects Trump to replace him, and Batmanghelidj expects him to resign before Democrats impeach him next year.

RUBIO: The secretary of state is tied to the war too, and CNN’s Collinson asks whether anyone so tied could defend it in a 2028 race. Batmanghelidj expects him to drop the White House for now and devote himself to Cuba. Rubio may yet count as a brake on Moscow: Republicans such as him are warier of Russian President Vladimir Putin, which “can help to contain the risk of Trump trying to impose an unacceptable deal on Ukraine”, Holger Schmieding of Berenberg told CNBC.

BESSENT: Trump has signalled no plans to fire any top officials yet, CNN reported. The Treasury secretary threatened Iran’s trading partners with isolation in August, and will now try to rescue his reputation by distancing himself from the war, according to Batmanghelidj. He also announced the truce extension with China that runs to January 10, so his fate bears on that file too.

WITKOFF AND KUSHNER: The two envoys are expected in Abu Dhabi next week, The Moscow Times reported, with subpoenas possibly to follow. Democrats holding committee gavels could target them over peace terms seen as favourable to Moscow, the Kyiv Independent reported before the vote, and The Wall Street Journal has reported that they promoted a plan for Russia to resume gas sales to Europe through a US intermediary. Batmanghelidj expects them to “want to tie things up and step back from mediation”.

RUSSIA AND UKRAINE: The first test comes at the trilateral talks in Abu Dhabi on November 10-11. Moscow will seek further sanctions relief and argue that business can come before peace, a person close to the Kremlin told Bloomberg in an exclusive on November 3, before the vote. Few expect a weakened Trump to be friendlier to Kyiv, the agency reported, though he may have less power to force a deal on Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy, which could encourage Putin to step up his drive to freeze Ukraine into submission. After the result, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told state media that “we sincerely count on him continuing his peacemaking efforts”.

Gregory Meeks, the senior Democrat on the House Foreign Affairs Committee, has pledged to “fix” the Graham sanctions act, which Trump largely waived on October 16, and Ukraine measures could ride on must-pass defence bills, according to Daniel Hamilton of Brookings. Money can still be slow-walked, as with the $400mn in aid the Pentagon delayed this year, the Kyiv Independent reported. The $2.1bn Patriot sale, meant to ease Kyiv’s interceptor shortage, may not deliver until 2030. Ukraine ranks below living costs and the Iran war on Democrats’ list. Ukraine Business News sees a chance of renewed US support by the spring. Zelenskiy, before the vote, warned that “many hopes may once again end in disappointment”.

IRAN: Two opposite forecasts are circulating. The result “might set the stage for a deal”, because a chastened Washington and a Tehran able to claim victory would both find concessions easier, according to Batmanghelidj. Trita Parsi of the Quincy Institute sees the balance tilting towards escalation: the political cost of high gasoline prices has been paid, war supporters will see the weeks before Congress takes over as their last chance and government funding expires on December 11. Schmieding splits the difference, with one more round of strikes and then a deal to reopen Hormuz by 2027.

Washington told Gulf allies before the vote to brace for post-midterm strikes, but Trump told the Financial Times after it that “we’re locked and loaded if we need to go, but there may be no reason for it”. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer promised that “we are going to end the war” through the power of the purse, though Democrats controlled both chambers from 2007 without ending George W. Bush’s wars. Tehran is split in public: parliament speaker Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf said Americans “said NO TO WAR”, while a statement attributed to Supreme Leader Mojtaba Khamenei warned against “even the slightest inclination towards submission”. Iranian commentators are debating wider strikes and the country’s nuclear doctrine, Iran International reported, and Dania Arayssi of the New Lines Institute told RFE/RL that Iran will feel no pressure “to offer any additional compromise”.

CHINA: Short-term gain, long-term pain for Beijing is the verdict of a Reuters analysis on November 5. Trump meets Chinese President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit in Shenzhen this month and at the G20 in Miami in December, with the trade truce due to lapse in January. He may be even less willing to upset the relationship, according to Wu Xinbo of Fudan University, while Craig Singleton of the Foundation for Defense of Democracies warned that pushing too hard could cause a “miscalculation that unsettles the very stability Xi is trying to preserve”.

The longer-term danger for Beijing is Congress: Democrats may press to unfreeze the $14bn Taiwan arms package that Trump is holding back, which former Chinese foreign ministry official Shen Weizhong called “risk number one”, and possible successors such as Rubio are seen as more hawkish. “If we can have two more years of stability, that’s already a good thing for China,” Shen told the agency. A renewed Iran war would threaten China’s energy supply too. China said it will send its Middle East envoy to Iran, Oman and Saudi Arabia later this month.

THE CALENDAR: The Hegseth vote could come in the week of November 9, with Abu Dhabi on November 10-11, Shenzhen on November 18-19, where a Trump-Putin meeting is possible, the government funding deadline on December 11, the new Congress on January 3 and the end of the China truce on January 10.