The US is offering Ukraine a Nato-like security guarantee in return for ceding the rest of the Donbas, as the second day of talks in Abu Dhabi turn to territory on November 11.
Washington has formally asked Moscow to accept “an Article 4 and an Article 5-like security guarantee” for Ukraine, a senior US official told reporters on November 9, Politico reported. US officials tie the territorial question to that guarantee and want the two settled together. The first day of talks on November 10 was given over to ceasefire monitoring and postwar security arrangements, Bloomberg reported, citing a US official.
Donbas for security is the trade at the heart of any settlement, and neither half of it has yet been defined. Nobody has said what a “Nato-like” pledge would oblige the US and Europe to do if Russia attacked again, and Kyiv is being asked to give up the fortress cities it still holds in Donetsk region for a currently very vague promise.
Even if the deal is struck, growing doubts over the effectiveness of Nato support in Europe is growing thanks to the Trump administration pull back after he spelled out a reduced US commitment to European security in his National Security Strategy (NSS) in December, when the Pentagon committed itself to a “hard deadline” pull out of Europe, which will have to take over its on conventional forces security by 2027.
It is in this context that Zelenskiy has to decide if any security guarantee deal offered by his Western allies will be strong enough to deter a second Russian invasion in the near future.
US envoy Jared Kushner, who leads Washington’s mediation with special envoy Steve Witkoff, said the aim was a “sovereign, secure, and prosperous Ukraine and lasting peace across Europe”. “We are encouraged by the constructive discussions today,” he wrote on X on November 10. After meeting Putin, he and Witkoff believe the Russian president is ready for peace “under the right conditions”, Kushner said.
What security?
Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has made the vagueness of the offer his main objection, and set out the exchange with the Americans in a post on X.
“Ceding Ukrainian land for peace is just abstract words. It’s not only about reality, even more about philosophy… This is why when Americans asked, ‘Can you exchange Donbas for security?’ I said right there, ‘Can you tell me what it means? What security? Nato?’ ‘Not Nato, but similar to Nato.’ ‘Similar? But you don’t want the answer about Donbas to be ‘similar’. You want a clear answer about Donbas. This is your goal. And this is Putin’s goal, for today. What will you do if we have security guarantees but not Nato?’ … Nobody trusts Putin to stop if we leave Donbas. He will pause. Then he will come back in one year, two years, or five years. And who will be guilty?”
Zelenskiy has said any guarantee must be “ironclad”. It is the word Moscow used in January 2022, when Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov demanded ironclad guarantees that Ukraine would never join Nato at talks with the US in Geneva, weeks before the invasion. Ryabkov is in Russia’s delegation in Abu Dhabi. The US refused to offer those guarentees and the war started a month later.
Kyiv’s worry is that the guarantee will be bundled into a wider deal over Europe. “A new European security architecture is on the American agenda for the Abu Dhabi talks,” Tymofiy Mylovanov, president of the Kyiv School of Economics and a former economy minister, wrote on X, summarising Zelenskiy. “This is the same idea Putin raised with Biden in 2021. It is dangerous.”
Witkoff said after a meeting of US, Ukrainian and European delegations on November 10 that any agreement must respect Ukraine’s sovereignty and territorial integrity and include credible security guarantees. The meeting, which included the UK, France, Germany, Italy, the European Commission and Nato, discussed a “practical” security framework for Ukraine after the war, the future of European security and ways to stop the fighting from flaring again. A strong Nato will remain central to Euro-Atlantic collective defence, Witkoff said.
US Secretary of State Marco Rubio has left open whether the guarantee would be modelled on Article 5, and said it could be written into a separate US treaty, while pointing to the difficulty of winning Senate approval. It has to deter another attack and be acceptable to Moscow, he said.
That is the weak point, according to Eric Ciaramella in a commentary for RUSI published on November 10. No country has been willing to send combat forces to Ukraine, and the UK- and France-led coalition of the willing has set such conditions on a postwar deployment – a total ceasefire, Russia’s agreement and an American backstop – that it may never happen. Article 5 is credible because of forward-deployed troops, an integrated command and contingency planning, not the treaty text.
“It is time for Kyiv and its partners to abandon the fiction of recreating Article 5 and instead focus on what will deter Russia: a strong Ukrainian military, supported by partners in a coherent and sustainable manner,” Ciaramella wrote.
Neutrality again
The Kremlin has accepted the principle before. At the Istanbul talks in March 2022 Kyiv offered permanent neutrality – no military blocs, no nuclear weapons and no foreign bases – in exchange for international legal guarantees from a list of states that included Russia, the US, the UK, China, France and Turkey. Russia’s objection was to Ukraine in Nato, not to security pledges as such. In March this year Kyrylo Budanov, now head of the presidential office and a member of Kyiv’s delegation, said Russia had explicitly accepted the guarantees the US was offering.
The US first put an Article 5-like guarantee on paper in the 28-point plan in November 2025, the first time Washington had offered one, but the terms were vague and the plan was later reworked. Whatever form the guarantee takes, Moscow still rejects any foreign troops on Ukrainian soil.
Ukraine’s 1990 declaration of state sovereignty committed it to becoming a permanently neutral state. Parliament dropped its non-aligned status in December 2014, and in February 2019 then-president Petro Poroshenko signed a constitutional amendment making Nato and EU membership a “national goal,” written into the country’s basic law. Putin cites Nato’s eastward expansion, which began when Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic joined in 1999, as the “root cause” of the war – which translates to a demand Ukraine returns to neutrality.
“Russia existed beside Nato and beside an independent Ukraine with very little tension, incl when Ukraine had fiercely pro-Western leader after Orange Revolution. This was possible so long as Ukraine was neutral. It should be neutral again,” British commentator Mary Dejevsky wrote on X.
Redrawing the Donbas
But a compromise on the map may be taking shape. US negotiators have proposed redrawing the administrative boundaries of Donetsk and Luhansk regions so that Russia could declare it had taken the whole Donbas without capturing the cities Ukraine still holds, The Economist reported, citing people involved in the talks. It is not clear whether the idea is a formal US proposal, and neither side has confirmed they are considering it. Russia holds most of Luhansk and about 70% of Donetsk region. Zelenskiy confirmed in October that Washington had also proposed a buffer zone on both sides of the line of contact.
Both sides have shown some flexibility in private, which is new, although any territorial deal is likely to come right at the end of the negotiations at a mooted meeting between Putin and Zelenskiy, a US official told Reuters on November 10.
Kyiv’s opening position hasn’t changed: freeze the war on the current front line and then do talks – a position the Kremlin has rejected out of hand since the start of negotiations.
“The second issue was territory, which was raised by the Russians. This is an issue for the leaders to discuss – our negotiators have that mandate,” Zelenskiy told a press conference on November 11, Ukrainska Pravda reported.
Ukraine’s constitution bans ceding territory, but in a little remembered story, last December Zelenskiy floated the idea of a referendum that would give him the authority to give away unoccupied land to Russia. That poll was never held.
The possibility of meeting between Putin and Zelenskiy is increasing as both side signal they are ready. Ukraine’s UN ambassador Andriy Melnyk told the Security Council on November 9 that Zelenskiy was ready to meet Putin “anywhere except Moscow.” Putin has repeatedly invivted Zelenskiy – to Moscow. The step-by-step process currenlty underway is meant to close this gap and facilitate a meeting of the two leaders somewhere neutral. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has already thrown his hat into the ring and said he is willing to host a meeting again – an option that should be acceptable to both Moscow and Kyiv. But no one is expecting a breakthrough in the first round in Abu Dhabi; there are only “expectations” for the next steps, said Davyd Arakhamia, parliamentary leader of the ruling Servant of the People party and a member of the delegation.
Talking while fighting
Both sides are turning the military torniquet, while their envoys fence, in an effort to apply added pressure for compromise. The fighting on the battlefield remains brutal as their armies press for advantage while the delegations talk. Russia struck Ukraine’s energy and oil and gas sectors 128 times between November 2 and November 8, up from 94 times the week before, First Deputy Energy Minister Artem Nekrasov said on November 9. Strikes on November 7-8 forced emergency power cuts in Kyiv and left more than 600,000 customers without electricity in Dnipropetrovsk region, as Moscow presses its campaign to freeze Ukraine into submission by hitting power plants and high-voltage substations.
Putin has threatened to completely destroy Ukraine’s bridges, ports, railways and power plants by next year unless Kyiv accepts Moscow’s ceasefire terms, the Financial Times reported. He has said Kyiv opened a “Pandora’s box” by striking the Russian economy, and Ukraine’s drones have kept up their attacks on Russian refineries.
Zelenskiy says Ukraine’s battlefield gains are strengthening its hand. Operation Vivaldi, the 3rd Army Corps counteroffensive near Lyman, has been a surprising success, retaking 176 sq km by late September and pushed Russian troops back from the Donbas fortress belt giving up almost all the gains they made this year. Kyiv’s defence ministry put Russian personnel losses at 54,400 in October alone – the highest monthly figure it has reported since the full-scale invasion began.