WASHINGTON — At first, President Donald Trump appeared notably unfazed by Vice President JD Vance’s postelection analysis blaming the Iran war for Republicans’ midterm wipeout.

“I think it’s largely true,” the president told reporters after Vance posted a lengthy missive on social media in which he also critiqued much of the administration’s messaging in the run-up to the elections.

But over the past two weeks, Trump has grown increasingly frustrated with how his vice president framed his assessment of what went wrong, complaining to aides and allies that Vance should have made a point of saying the president made the right decision in going to war with Iran, according to people with knowledge of the president’s comments.

At the same time, Trump has continued to praise Marco Rubio, his secretary of state, in private conversations and suggesting that he could be a strong presidential candidate, according to the people, who spoke on the condition of anonymity to describe discussions going on behind closed doors. Trump’s allies have noted that Rubio has repeatedly said the president’s move to attack Iran was essential for the country’s national security.

Trump has hinted at his irritation with Vance in public, saying this month that the vice president should have “made one other statement.”

“If you had it to do again, would you do it again? The answer is yes,” he said, laying out what he believes was missing from Vance’s analysis.

The tension comes at a critical juncture for Vance, who is considering whether to run for president in 2028, a campaign in which Trump’s support could be crucial to his ability to secure the Republican nomination. The president’s favorable comments about Rubio are the latest example of how Trump has been weighing the strengths of the two men as the question of his successor grows more urgent.

The White House did not respond to a request for comment. Vance’s office declined to comment, pointing to recent interviews the vice president has given.

When asked on Fox News this week about his postelection commentary and whether there was any “daylight” between him and the president, Vance said, “I think there’s no daylight between the president or any other senior member of the administration.”

On Wednesday, Vance canceled a planned appearance at The New York Times DealBook Summit, citing meetings in Washington to address the recent tech outages.

Since Trump brought him aboard as his running mate for a second term, many Republicans have assumed that Vance, a former senator from Ohio, would be the front-runner for their party’s nomination in 2028. But Trump has waffled publicly and privately on his vice president throughout his tenure, and Vance says he has not decided whether to run for president.

“I haven’t made a decision,” he said on Fox News. “We’ll figure it out sometime next year.”

Allies of Vance, who also spoke on condition of anonymity to describe private conversations, say he is genuinely undecided about his political future. They point to his young family (his fourth child was born in July) as one reason he might not mount a White House bid in 2028. They also note his obsession with political analysis and data and suggest that if he does not see a path to victory, he may sit out this race.

The fallout from the war with Iran — and its unpopularity among voters — could be a significant factor, too. Some allies of Vance say that if the president decides to resume major combat operations in Iran, it would drastically reduce Vance’s chances of running.

The vice president, who endorsed Trump in 2023 saying he would not drag the United States into new wars, expressed reservations about the conflict privately inside the administration. But after the huge GOP losses in this month’s midterms, he went public, laying out in blunt terms what he said went wrong.

“The reason we lost is the war,” he wrote in his lengthy social media post the day after the midterms.

Vance made the point of adding that Trump had also said as much — though the president has blamed Republicans’ losses on many factors, chiefly that he was not on the ticket.

For Vance, it appeared to be an attempt to separate himself from the administration’s policy without criticizing the president. But Trump soon announced that he was pulling his vice president from engaging in peace talks with Iran, an effort that Vance had intensified shortly before the elections. Trump said he wanted Vance to focus on investigating allegations of fraud in Democratic-run jurisdictions.

Alyssa Farah Griffin, who worked in Trump’s White House during the first term and is now a co-host of “The View,” said a comment from Vance reminded her of a comment that Kamala Harris, then the vice president, made on the ABC show during the 2024 campaign. When asked if she would have done anything differently from President Joe Biden, Harris said, “There is not a thing that comes to mind.”

“JD Vance is in the impossible position that any Trump VP inevitably ends up in,” Griffin said. “He can’t have any separation or daylight from the president.”

Vance’s “daylight” comment this week “may have seemed insignificant in the moment, but it will live in campaign ads,” she added.

Vance’s allies say a competitive primary, not a coronation, will benefit the next Republican presidential nominee, and they cite Harris’ loss in 2024 as evidence of that theory. Harris quickly secured the Democratic nomination after Biden dropped out of the race, despite some Democrats’ calls for a more formal nominating process.

But Vance ultimately could find himself in a similar situation to Harris, who many voters saw as an extension of Biden, political strategists said. Even as she privately signaled she had concerns about Biden’s handling of the Israel-Hamas war, she was unable to figure out how to separate herself from the unpopular president.

“It’s very hard to get me to say that I have any amount of sympathy for JD Vance because he put himself in this position,” said Rob Flaherty, a Democratic strategist and former deputy campaign manager to Harris. “But you do have to feel for him because he’s stuck. When you’re the vice president, you’re stuck. In the Harris situation, there was not much you can actually do to separate yourself.”

Vance now must wrestle with that complex dynamic as he assesses the future of the Republican Party and in which direction he would try to lead it. His path to the vice presidency — from a “never Trumper” to Trump’s vice president — suggests that he could go in different directions.

Vance was an avowed critic of Trump in 2016, calling him “unfit for our nation’s highest office.” He then became a supporter of Trump and sought the president’s endorsement when he ran for a Senate seat in Ohio in 2022. He received the endorsement and won that race.

Many Republicans believe Vance would need the explicit, or at least implicit, support from Trump to win a Republican primary. But that is far from a guarantee. The president has always relished competition among his aides, and his advisers say he is in no rush to endorse a successor.

And after Republicans’ disastrous results in the elections this month, in which Democrats won the largest midterm victory for either party since the post-Watergate elections, other Republicans see an opening, too. Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas and Gov. Ron DeSantis of Florida are among those considering possible bids.

Then there’s Rubio. He has said he would support Vance and dismissed reports that he is going to leave the administration to run for president. But some of his allies said he would run if Trump encouraged him to do so — and Trump has not been shy about lavishing praise on him.

“How hot is Marco, right?” Trump said Tuesday at the ASEAN summit in Manila. “Is Marco doing a great job? He’s been fantastic.”

While Vance has remained in the United States, as the vice president does when the president travels abroad, Rubio is playing a prominent role on the president’s trip. On Tuesday, he addressed public fears about the multiple technology outages in the United States, seeking to reassure Americans that there was no evidence of cyberattacks.

Rubio’s defense of the Iran war, in particular, has earned him goodwill with the president.

In a recent interview with the Times, Rubio said Trump “deserves a tremendous amount of credit” for authorizing strikes against Iran.

“Ultimately, that is the price of leadership — is the willingness to do things that may not be politically popular or expedient but are necessary for your country and its long-term future,” he said.

The distinct approaches of Rubio and Vance underscore a broader debate in the party — should the next Republican presidential candidate align themselves with Trump’s legacy?

Chris Christie, the former Republican governor of New Jersey, who is considering another run for the White House, said Vance’s challenges transcend his unique position as vice president.

“I don’t think anyone that was part of Trump 2.0 will be able to win in the fall of 2028,” he said. “They will be billed as another four years of Donald Trump, and that will not be salable to the American people.”

This story was originally published at nytimes.com. Read it here.