Before his groundbreaking triumph as the first Democrat elected to the U.S. Senate from Kansas in nearly a century, Sen.-elect Adam Hamilton dealt with defeat and change in his role leading a centrist movement within the United Methodist Church.
Hamilton, pastor of Resurrection, a megachurch in Leawood, fought hard to avoid a splintering in the nation’s largest mainline Protestant denomination over disagreements about LGBTQ+ inclusion. He wanted to preserve unity between a conservative faction that maintained control over church policy and progressives who felt despondent over the exclusion that LGBTQ+ people continued to experience. That desired outcome ultimately failed in a sobering turn of events, but it taught Hamilton important lessons as he now enters the U.S. Senate.
“The two-party system in the United States requires that people are thoughtful, listening to each other’s convictions and are working on trying to find a compromise that is not a zero-sum game,” Hamilton told Sojourners. “That’s not always possible, but many times I think it is.”
Hamilton’s election on Nov. 3 made him the first Democrat elected to a U.S. Senate seat in Kansas since 1932. The arena he’s now about to step into is in some ways wholly unfamiliar. But allies and critics of Hamilton within Methodism say there are also traits of the Kansas pastor’s advocacy for compromise in the church that will serve him well in office.
To describe his philosophy both in the church and now in politics, Hamilton often invokes the phrase “via media” —a popular phrase in Methodist circles that refers to finding a “middle way” between two extremes.
“Adam Hamilton is very much a via media person and obviously identifies as a centrist who wants to keep people altogether,” Mark Tooley, president of the Institute on Religion and Democracy, a leading traditionalist group, told Sojourners. “And I think that’s part of what made him a very effective and successful politician. But I don’t think it works in the church very well.”
Hamilton became a rival of the faction that Tooley helped lead after the Kansas pastor helped champion a proposed substitute amendment at the 2012 UMC General Conference that wanted the denomination to affirm the “sacred worth” of gay and lesbian people while acknowledging differences of opinion. Conservatives defeated that proposal and subsequent attempts to change policy by centrists, who promoted a view known as “faithful people can disagree.”
Sens.-elect Abdul El-Sayed (D-Mich., left) and Adam Hamilton (D-Kan.) are seen in the U.S. Capitol as new members of Congress arrive to Washington, D.C., Nov. 9, 2026. Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call/Sipa USA via Reuters.
The splintering ended after about a quarter of all UMC congregations left the denomination between 2019 and 2023, most to join a more conservative breakaway denomination. Throughout the conflict, Hamilton maintained a centrist position but began working closer with progressives over time. This history was cited and misconstrued on the campaign trail, when President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance attacked Hamilton for being a liberal who masquerades as a moderate.
The accusation is laughable to some progressives in the UMC, who long criticized Hamilton and other centrists’ incrementalist approach. Laura Young, an organizer with Reconciling Ministries Network, an LGBTQ+ rights advocacy group in the UMC, sympathizes with some of those criticisms. But as someone who worked closely with Hamilton over the years on some of his strategic maneuvers, Young saw the advantages of his method.
“The slower-than-I-hoped-for pace from Adam has kept many, many more people in this conversation,” Young said. “And as a result, more people have changed their hearts and minds over the years. It’s helped reduce harm.”
A ‘middle way’ pays off and comes at a cost
Hamilton founded Resurrection in 1990, initially gathering in a funeral home chapel along the aptly named State Line Road at the nexus of the borders of Kansas and Missouri.
After moving into its flagship campus in 1994, it expanded across the Kansas City metro region. Today, its total membership is more than 24,000 across nine campuses. It’s the largest UMC congregation in the United States.
When this growth was taking off, Hamilton began authoring popular books and launched a leadership institute to share wisdom from his success with others. That’s where Rev. Magrey deVega, pastor of Hyde Park UMC in Tampa, Fla., first met Hamilton in the early 2000s. That day, Hamilton lectured on the via media.
“That lecture was singularly formative for me,” deVega told Sojourners. “It cemented for me with profound language why I’m a United Methodist.”
DeVega and Hamilton became friends over time, and deVega now leads a congregation with an average weekly attendance of more than 900 people across two campuses.
“People I have seen who have gotten drawn to churches like Hyde Park and like Church of the Resurrection want to take the Bible seriously. … They want to honor 2,000 years of Christian history,” deVega said. “And they want to be able to address real hurts of marginalized people.”
At times, attentiveness to marginalized people has come at a cost for Resurrection. When Hamilton began calling for a more open-minded stance toward LGBTQ+ inclusion in the church, a wave of parishioners left the church, said Cathy Bien, the church’s communications director. But she said they gained new members shortly thereafter, many of whom were young singles and families.
“The two-party system in the United States requires that people are thoughtful, listening to each other’s convictions and are working on trying to find a compromise that is not a zero-sum game,” Hamilton told Sojourners. “That’s not always possible, but many times I think it is.”
Resurrection has never become a “Reconciling congregation,” meaning it formally adopts practices affirming LGBTQ+ people.
“We considered it, and we had Sunday school classes that were Reconciling … But by becoming a Reconciling congregation, we would be making a statement that wasn’t consistent with where 25 to 30% of our people were yet and where they might never be,” Hamilton told Sojourners.
Other prominent pastors and bishops in the UMC shared Hamilton’s sentiment, and that camp mobilized behind a legislative proposal to give individual churches more agency on the question of LGBTQ+ inclusion. At the time, Reconciling Ministries Network criticized the position for “prioritizing a surface level kind of unity over the well-being of LGBTQ people,” according to a September 2017 statement.
These competing visions for the future of United Methodism came to a head in 2019 during a special legislative session in St. Louis. A more moderate set of proposals that Hamilton championed narrowly failed in a surprising turn of events, followed by the adoption of alternative legislation that tightened restrictions for LGBTQ+ people. The outcome moved Hamilton to tears in a video he filmed for Resurrection members shortly after.
“Hearing the results of that decision, I can’t say broke my heart, but I felt great pain for the people who were being hurt by the church I care about,” Hamilton recalled.
When a pastor’s centrism meets Congressional partisanship
Soon after conservatives prevailed at the 2019 assembly in St. Louis, centrists and progressives convened for a three-day postmortem at Resurrection.
There, they formed a coalition to work toward dismantling denomination-wide restrictions on LGBTQ+ inclusion. That coalition ultimately succeeded in its mission at the 2024 UMC General Conference in Charlotte.
“Would that have happened if not for a venue as large as Church of the Resurrection and the credibility of someone like Adam Hamilton? Probably not,” deVega said.
But Hamilton’s ability to preserve that centrist position will face different pressures in the Senate. Democrats’ new majority contains multiple factions and intra-party disputes, making every member of the caucus potentially decisive in votes challenging the Trump White House. Hamilton said he’s already planning to attend a bi-weekly Bible study for senators, which he said is attended by mostly Republicans and just one other Democrat. Meanwhile, he said he’s eager to seek out opportunities to work with Republicans on regulating artificial intelligence and reforming immigration and healthcare policy.
Momentum on those goals may sputter, but deVega is confident Hamilton won’t altogether forfeit his pursuit of the via media.
“I suspect that the way he votes and way he works the Senate floor will be very consistent with his views on loving God and loving neighbor,” deVega said. “The two are inseparable for him without having to preach from the Senate floor.”
One of the most striking moments for Young in her many years of collaborating with Hamilton on advocating for change in the UMC was at the 2024 general conference. After stepping up as a mouthpiece of the movement for so long, Young said Hamilton deliberately took a back seat in public debates in Charlotte, allowing room for LGBTQ+ voices to defend the proposed changes.
Young hopes that what Hamilton did for others back then, his Senate colleagues will now do for him and other fresh faces, like Texas Sen.-elect James Talarico.
“They’re compassionate and thoughtful and the nation is clearly ready for more compassion and more fairness,” Young said. “So, Adam and his freshman friends need to get the mic.”