
Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today.
Already a member?
Log in
Elbridge Colby, the US under secretary of war, said “quite a stupid thing”, according to the German defence minister Boris Pistorius, when he told Ukraine’s western allies in Nato that Kyiv should limit its attacks on Russia.
He was especially stupid, as an ally of Russia, in that he accidentally revealed that Ukraine is winning.
There is consternation in the Pentagon over the way the conflict is going. The US administration, as Colby told Nato’s defence establishment, wants to see Ukraine’s front lines stuck where they are.
Washington does not want to see a Ukraine victory. But as a large chunk of the Kerch Bridge lay in the sea below, smashed by Ukrainian missiles, Colby and Co clearly got a whiff of how Kyiv may win this war.
The Kerch Bridge is not merely a symbolic link between the illegally annexed Crimean peninsula and Russia’s mainland. It is a vital artery that supplies the oxygen of fuel, ammunition, troops and communications to the brain of the whole Russian invasion of Ukraine’s Donbas region and beyond.
Comparative images of the Kerch bridge in Crimea take in 2022 (top) and damaged after a strike on November 17 (AFP/Getty)
Crimea, invaded in 2014, has been the quiet focus of Ukraine’s war effort for more than a year. Ukraine’s medium-range weapons shut down the Russian navy’s use of the port in Sebastopol. They have blown up Russia’s rings of air defences, they keep the highway along the coast to Rostov-on-Don in Russia under constant pressure and they have forced Russia’s command and control communication centres – known as C2 – to disperse.
To do that, Ukraine has relied on the American satellite communications system Starlink and its military version, Starshield. It is no accident that the speed at which these terminals can be flown through space has been restricted by the US, and it is irrelevant whether that order came from Elon Musk, who runs Starlink, or Trump himself. The fact is that Ukraine’s offensive technology depends in large part on Starlink terminals mounted on missiles. Choke them and you protect Russia’s C2.
“Crimea is essential. If Ukraine can break the Russians there then the whole Russian invasion will collapse,” a senior Ukrainian military official told The Independent.
Causing that collapse is not just a local matter. Ukraine needs to strike “in depth” against Russian territory itself.
A drone view of the damaged bridge across the Kerch Strait (Reuters)
For the last 18 months, a campaign to cripple Russia’s oil refining capacity, shut down its airports and force its long-range bombers farther from their targets in Ukraine has been successful. Ordinary Russians across the country now have to queue for fuel. That means Crimea is under even greater pressure and, more widely, it is getting harder for Russians to kill Ukrainians.
For the Americans, as Colby said this week, this is going too far. So they are demanding that Ukraine stop using a strategy that could deliver them victory, rather than what the US-Russian negotiating teams have been trying to sell, which is Kyiv’s capitulation and the loss of Ukraine’s east to Moscow’s invading armies.
“While the public conversation focuses on the spectacle of deep strikes designed to incur pain on the Russian population, our assessment is that such strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia’s advances on the front line,” said Colby. “Moreover, such strikes, especially those that target civilian infrastructure, such as [the Russian online retailer] Wildberries, have actually probably hardened the Russian public’s resolve and the Kremlin’s own willingness to escalate. Moreover, it is important to note that the balance of advantage in deep strikes may well favour Moscow.”
Colby listens to Volodymyr Zelensky speaking via video link at Nato headquarters on Tuesday (Getty)
This is nonsense. He may be “stupid” as Pistorius said. But it’s worse than that.
“Instead of criticising that, we should rather criticise and talk about the terroristic strikes every night and every day on civil energy… water and heating infrastructure in Ukraine,” Pistorius said.
Wes Streeting, the UK defence secretary, joined the Pistorius chorus with similarly passive-aggressive language. Ukraine’s long-range strikes “helped to degrade Putin’s war machine, buying time and saving lives”.
Neither spelled out what Ukraine’s development of cheap, effective long-range missiles and self-guided drones and their use against Moscow means, which is that if they carry on there’s a chance that Russia’s forces will collapse in Ukraine – and Putin could end up like Saddam Hussein or Muammar Gadaffi, but killed by his own citizens.
Colby’s entire speech focused on Ukraine’s defence – not on its ability to take the war to Putin. “A successful Ukrainian denial defence substantially reduces the gains which Moscow can expect from continuing its war,” he said. “Ukrainian forces have continued to mount a resilient denial defence.”
Drivers queueing at a Rosneft petrol station in Moscow in August. Russian authorities acknowledged that some regions face petrol shortages (AFP/Getty)
Denial defence is not an attack. Colby insists that it will help “set the conditions for an end to the war”. He is not stupid to say that. He is absolutely right – if those “conditions” are Russian.
At every stage since coming into office Trump has backed Russia, so Colby’s demand that Ukraine scale back its war fighting capacity to make it easier for Russia to prevail is a sure sign that the US administration has been asked, by Putin, to step in to help the Kremlin survive.
It is coincidence, perhaps, that the UK has just announced its will give 1,000 short-range defensive missiles plus radar systems to Ukraine in a £240m winter package. That sounds like a lot but it is enough for less than a week in Ukraine’s defence against hundreds of incoming missiles every day.
It’s offensive missiles that Ukraine needs most to win, not just survive and surrender. The Americans know that.