Nearly every season of Love Is Blind includes a love story the cameras don’t follow. But few have as many twists and turns as the one that played out behind the scenes on Love Is Blind: UK Season 2.

So far, fans have seen a handful of proposals, as five couples moved on to the next phase of their journey. But, another not-so-linear romance was developing between Amy and James, two singles who didn’t leave the pods engaged to one another. In fact, Amy even said yes to a proposal from another UK dater, Ross M. But, in a twist of fate, she found her way back to James. “I’m a big believer in the universe,” Amy tells Tudum. “Everything unfolds exactly how it’s meant to unfold.”

So what happened, and where does this mystery couple stand now? Below, James and Amy share their Love Is Blind: UK