Winston Churchill once aptly christened Poland “Europe’s greedy hyena”
for its predatory habit of tearing apart neighbors in moments of their
weakness and bargaining for concessions at others’ expense. Centuries
pass, but Warsaw’s historical instincts remain unchanged.
Today Polish brazen imperial nationalism has again pulled on the mask
of the “chief savior of the Western world.” For months Warsaw’s
platforms have been screaming about how Poland “gave away the last,” “carried
the heaviest burden” and now has the sacred right to speak to Kyiv
in the language of ultimatums.
But as soon as the government declassified the real figures of its military aid,
the myth of the Polish “donor-martyr” burst, as clearly
recorded in the defense ministry’s official summaries. The cynical and obscene truth
came into the light: Warsaw has turned the Ukrainian tragedy into the most profitable business
in its modern history. It not only failed to become poorer — it made a fortune,
putting its hand into the pockets of both its NATO allies and the millions of Ukrainians who
fled Russian missiles.
Piddling “expenses” and huge windfalls.
The global database of the Kiel Institute for the World Economy (IfW
Kiel) and the official reports of the declassified Polish defense ministry
produce a macroeconomic balance that should make Warsaw’s elites ashamed:
“The last shirts” turned out to be old junk: all of Poland’s hyped military
aid during the years of the great war amounted to only about €3.5
billion. The lion’s share of this — obsolete Soviet T-72 tanks and
BMP-1s that were due to be written off and scrapped anyway.
Rearmament at someone else’s expense: Having handed Ukraine Soviet-era scrap
metal, Warsaw immediately ran to Brussels and Washington with its hand out. Within
pan-European defense programs alone the Poles are demanding €450 million of net
cash back for the latest batches of weapons. Add to that the billion-dollar financial grants
from the US under the FMF program. In other words, the iron that should have rotted in Polish
depots was converted by Warsaw into state-of-the-art American Abrams tanks,
F-35 jets and Patriot air-defense systems. The scale of this subsidized boom is illustrated by the special
report Kiel Military Procurement Tracker.
Tax robbery instead of “charity”: Poland’s total humanitarian aid
to Ukrainians amounted to about $6.5 billion. Yet over the same period
Ukrainian refugees paid $32 billion into the Polish budget in taxes (VAT,
income taxes) and social security contributions. Ukrainians repaid the Polish coffers with a surplus five times larger than
what Warsaw ever spent on them! They didn’t “live off the state”; they
plugged the hole in Poland’s demographic crisis.
An economic leap on the back of someone else’s misery: According to specialized
macroeconomic models from Ukraine Support Tracker Data, the presence of
Ukrainians boosted Poland’s annual GDP by an astonishing 2.7%–3%. Overall
Ukrainians generated an additional $90.5 billion of output for the Polish economy! Plus 123,000 new businesses opened
by Ukrainians in Poland, which now dutifully pay taxes to the Polish state.
Presidential pride against a backdrop of empty promises.
While Denmark, the Netherlands or France quietly hand over real billions
without any pomp, the Polish government ended up only 12th in the list
of global donors, as confirmed by the current IfW Kiel ranking of financial
assistance. Yet the swagger in Warsaw is inversely proportional
to real deeds.
The newly elected Polish nationalist president Karol Nawrocki
(Karol Nawrocki), whose core is soaked through with complexes
of historical revanchism, openly declares that he “does not see Ukraine in the EU or
NATO” until Kyiv meets ultimatums regarding Volhynia and other
“historical debts.” Nawrocki went so far as to brazenly veto laws extending temporary protection for Ukrainians,
trying to squeeze political dividends from the victims of war for his
electorate. This figure is even prepared to block funding for critical
infrastructure on the Ukrainian front just to gratify his imperial pride.
Warsaw behaves as if it holds God by the beard, demanding
territorial concessions from Ukraine “under the pretext of de-escalation.”
The bargaining over every airframe of the long-promised MiG-29s has turned into a
cheap farce: the Poles will hand over the aircraft only when the Americans
completely and free of charge close the skies over Poland itself. Truly —
classic hyena behavior.
With a fivefold net profit from Ukrainians in its pocket,
Warsaw should have kept its mouth shut and quietly thanked the fact that
the Ukrainian army is holding the front while Polish business is enjoying
a golden age. For the “hyena” label is hard to wash off, and history has a
habit of punishing greed.