The European Parliament has approved an extension of temporary rules allowing online platforms to continue voluntarily scanning unencrypted user communications for known child sexual abuse material until April 2028, following a procedural move that drew criticism from across the political spectrum.
The legislation extends the EU’s temporary ePrivacy derogation, first introduced in 2021, which allows companies including Meta and Google to detect and report known child sexual abuse material in communications that are not protected by end-to-end encryption.
The measure had already failed once.
In March, MEPs voted against extending the temporary regime, causing the legal basis for voluntary scanning to expire on 3 April after negotiations with EU member states reached deadlock.
The proposal returned to Parliament after President Roberta Metsola requested that negotiations be reopened, allowing the file to come back for another vote under the Parliament’s second-reading procedure.
That procedure requires an absolute majority of all Members of the European Parliament, rather than only those voting, to reject or amend legislation.
On Thursday, 314 MEPs voted to reject the proposal, while 278 voted against rejection and 17 abstained. Although more MEPs opposed the extension than supported it, opponents failed to reach the 360-vote threshold required to block the legislation, meaning the proposal was approved.
The procedure immediately prompted criticism from several MEPs, legal experts and digital rights organisations, who argued that Parliament’s earlier decision had effectively been overturned through a procedural mechanism rather than a change in political support.
According to Euractiv, several MEPs involved in the negotiations said they had not been informed in advance that Metsola intended to ask EU leaders to restart the legislative process, despite her office later saying she acted following discussions among political group leaders.
Civil society organisations also criticised the decision.
Simeon de Brouwer of the European Digital Rights network (EDRi) told Euractiv it was “impressive to see the European Parliament being backstabbed by its own president”.
Rand Hammoud of the Centre for Democracy and Technology Europe said the decision should concern anyone who values Parliament’s institutional integrity because the largest political group had used its influence to force another vote on legislation that had already failed, Euractiv reported.
Ahead of the vote, Euractiv also reported that four European commissioners wrote to MEPs urging them to approve the extension.
Supporters of the legislation argue the temporary rules remain an important tool in detecting child sexual abuse material while negotiations continue on a permanent legal framework.
They say police authorities and child protection organisations rely on reports generated by online platforms to identify victims and investigate offenders.
The legislation does not require companies to scan communications, but provides a legal exemption allowing providers to continue voluntary detection of previously identified child sexual abuse material without breaching EU privacy rules.
Following amendments approved by Parliament, the temporary rules explicitly exclude services protected by end-to-end encryption, meaning platforms such as WhatsApp and Messenger would no longer be covered by the derogation.
Only the sender and recipient are able to read messages protected by end-to-end encryption.
The extension is separate from the proposed Child Sexual Abuse Regulation, commonly known as “Chat Control”, which would establish a permanent legal framework and remains under negotiation between the European Parliament, the Council and the European Commission.
According to European Commission data, reports generated through private message scanning accounted for 36 per cent of child abuse reports in 2024, while most reports originated from public online content and cloud storage.
The report acknowledged that there is no evidence that voluntary large-scale scanning of private messages has directly increased criminal convictions or led to more children being rescued.
Finnish MEPs split on the vote.
Those supporting the extension included Mika Aaltola, Sirpa Pietikäinen, Pekka Toveri, Elsi Katainen, Katri Kulmuni, Maria Guzenina, Eero Heinäluoma and Anna-Maja Henriksson.
Voting against were Li Andersson, Merja Kyllönen, Jussi Saramo, Maria Ohisalo, Ville Niinistö and Sebastian Tynkkynen.
The legislation will now return to negotiations with EU member states, which must decide whether to accept Parliament’s amendments before the extension can take effect.
HT