Cities are key to fighting climate change. They are often small and nimble enough to avoid the gridlock of national politics, and yet they’re also big enough to make a meaningful difference. Valérie Plante, the Mayor of Montreal, told me that municipalities can act more swiftly than national governments while inspiring them to emulate effective programs; they can also mobilize and motivate citizens directly. Montreal is currently aiming for a fifty-five per cent reduction in emissions by 2030, and for carbon neutrality by 2050. Plante cited Oslo as a source of inspiration, calling its 2030 goals “amazing.” Each city is different, and will approach the climate transition in its own way. But the model being pioneered in Oslo may well show the world a way forward.
Oslo’s climate budget isn’t one line item among others. Instead, it’s a process for measuring to what extent different policies reduce emissions, and for guiding decision-making across all municipal departments. Some policies require extra funding: electric excavators are more expensive than diesel machines. Others, such as increasing tolls and parking prices for non-electric vehicles, are money-makers. “The climate budget is a tool to operationalize our climate goals and the climate strategy on an annual basis,” Heidi Sørensen, the head of Oslo’s climate agency, told me. The budget process establishes exactly what has to be done when, who has to do it, and what it will cost. It brings specificity to a sweeping goal.
Climate budgeting requires the accurate measurement of emissions. If you don’t know the quantity of emissions that different activities cause, it’s impossible to assess the efficacy of different proposed measures. According to the Norwegian Environmental Agency’s most recent studies, nearly eighty per cent of emissions in Oslo come from three sectors of the city’s economy: waste incineration and energy supply (twenty-three per cent), private cars and vans (thirty-three per cent), and other “mobile combustion,” including construction machinery (twenty per cent). The statistics aren’t perfect—among other things, they lag behind the present by two years—but they let the city focus on policies that are likely to have the largest impact. Debates about climate policies can become contentious; people have lots of ideas for how to reduce emissions. Einar Wilhelmsen, a vice-mayor of Oslo, told me that the budget lets the city settle arguments: “We can calculate it, we can say, ‘Yes, we can do that—but that won’t cut emissions much at all.’ ”
Many of Oslo’s climate-focussed policies are incentives-based. The city has created more and cheaper parking for electric vehicles, for example. But measures have also escalated, over time, from nudges to prohibitions. Non-electric vehicles already have to pay more to enter and park in the city; the newest climate budget will go further, creating an “emission-free zone” with entrance and parking for zero-emission vehicles only. These kinds of escalations can be powerful: a delivery company might be willing to pay higher parking fees for its non-electric vans, but the prospect of losing access to a whole section of the city could motivate the switch to replace its entire fleet. The same pattern is unfolding in construction—zero-emission machinery will be mandatory for work that is commissioned for the city by 2025—and in home heating: after several years of using grants to encourage people to replace their oil-fired furnaces, the city banned them outright in 2020. “I can’t remember anyone missing them,” Sørensen, the head of the climate agency, said.
Procurement is another far-reaching tool. Oslo spends roughly three billion dollars each year buying goods and services. Climate budgeting insures that much of this money flows to businesses that reduce emissions. Private companies that provide services from transportation to locksmithing are more likely to win contracts with the city if they use electric vehicles. Seven high schools, which hire outside venders for their cafeterias, are taking part in a pilot program serving only vegetarian or pescatarian lunches. Emissions “don’t care about budgets or borders,” Sirin Stav, another vice-mayor, told me. People still fly into Oslo’s airport, emitting carbon—but local changes do matter. The city can encourage its residents to come home from the airport using electric taxis or public transportation, and it can push venders that work in multiple cities to change their approaches.