Europe has talent. Europe has ideas. Europe doesn’t have a thriving AI sector that can scale without uprooting to the US. And the European Commission seems intent on making sure that this isn’t about to change any time soon.
Is that an alarmist, anti-EU message to warm the hearts of nationalists everywhere? Maybe it can be mis-interpreted that way, but in fact it’s a thesis that underpins a lot of the tech sector concern that the AI age will repeat the errors of the past and watch as potential sectoral leadership drifts away to the US in order to become a significant factor on a global stage.
Europe certainly doesn’t make things easy for young companies. Despite the emphasis placed by proponents of the European Union (EU) as a Single Market, appearances can be deceptive.
Eileen O’Mara is Vice-Chair of fintech Stripe, a firm with two Irish founders and a dual HQ in Dublin and in San Francisco. She notes:
I think a lot of people have the perception that the EU is a 27 member State [where] we’re all in the Euro and we can form a company and go anywhere. That’s not the case.
Access to the European market is not straightforward, she adds:
Europe is complex under its current construct. I mean, Europe is such a great role model for all of us, but the ability to, for example, build in Germany, and then [ask], ‘What market will I go to next?’, is harder to do that than it is in the US…You have to regulate in every country. If you want to go to Spain, you need to go and create your company there as well. There’s different laws governing things.
That has consequences for European firms, she warns:
What you have is you’ve got companies who form in one country and they look to the US [to scale]. They’ll incorporate in Delaware and start hiring in the US and they will say, ‘My expansion is the US’.
That’s a wasted opportunity, she suggests:
We’re sitting on 450 million Europeans here in Europe. It’s a bigger market actually than the US.
But the reality is stark:
Europe is lagging. We know particularly now in this AI era that we’re lagging. Some of the stats that we have is the revenues of AI companies in the US are 30 times larger than their European equivalent. So we have to make sure that this divergence doesn’t continue.
This is not down to some kind of mindset difference between Europeans and Americans, she insists:
There’s no difference in capability or ambition or ability to work hard or eagerness to succeed between the Europeans and the Americans. Honestly, there is no difference. Where we see the big divergences is when you get to a level, maybe it’s a Series A level, then we start seeing a divergence. That divergence happens because access to capital is a real constraint for European companies that are looking to scale. In Europe, only 20% of capital is non-bank capital versus over 60% in the US.
EU-Inc – ready for business, but…
O’Mara’s hope is for an EU in which:
The next range of founders in Europe can found a company in one country in Europe, and then have access to the European market from day one, in the same way as in the US you can form your company in Delaware and have access to 340 million people in 48 hours. You can’t do that in Europe.
It’s critically important that we get that over the line to support this next wave of founders to really look at the European market as the first opportunity for them to grow and scale with access to capital, mobility of talent, rather than having to look to the US as the place that they have to like have the idea in Europe and then export that to the US.
But is this message being heard in Brussels? On the face of it, yes. In practice, is it breaking through? Not so much. EU Inc – aka The 28th Regime – is a proposed corporate legal structure set out in March of this year by the Commission. At its heart is the idea of enabling founders to register a single limited liability company online that can operate across all EU member states and for this to possible within 48 hours. O’Mara explains:
We’re not suggesting that anything should be taken away. What we’re trying to advocate for at EU Inc – and I think the proposal is outstanding in its ambition – is that if you’re a founder and you’re trying to start a company in one country because you’re German, [that] that enables you to build your company and sell your products and services across any of the 27 member states. That’s not possible today. It’s really hard to start a company and be successful [in Europe]…The proposal is under discussion now at every country level, and obviously there’s a fear that some of this gets diluted and for it to be ineffective.
Will the EU act to save us from the EC’s actions?
Those fears are growing. In an open letter entitled Dear Europe, why are you killing EU-Inc?, supporters of the idea last week laid into what they see as the Commission wimping out on the planned reform. The letter calls on Europe’s political leaders to step in and save it from evisceration at the hands of the Eurocrats, warning:
Two years ago, Europe’s most prominent founders and investors, representing companies valued at hundreds of billions of Euros and employing tens of thousands of people on the continent, brought Brussels an EU-Inc proposal backed by research, legal expertise and full industry support. The Commission took it forward and introduced a workable solution. The compromises have rendered it toothless.
EU-Inc is now just about facilitating fast incorporation of companies, it argues, which while important, is far from the only reform that needs to happen. The letter calls for a beneficial stock options framework to incentivize staff; a central EU digital registry to remove friction involving critical business processes, such as opening a bank account across borders; and local worker protections so that the fact that a firm is registered in a different EU State does not dilute those protections or change where taxes are paid.
The letter warns the politicos that their administrative underlings are doing great damage to this idea and that this will have bad consequences for Europe’s prospects:
Please understand the importance of getting this right. It’s about more than just EU Inc. If Europe’s leaders cannot even align on a solution like EU-Inc. Europe’s founders will lose more than a proposal. They will lose faith in Europe’s ability to face the challenge of our time. Europe’s founders will have a future; whether that future is European is in your hands.
Make Europe proud
For her part, O’Mara argues:
For Europe to be competitive this really needs to be a platform so we can support and feel proud of obviously the entrepreneurs and that they’re building in Europe, for Europe, first, and then go to the US which is not the case today.
This is particularly important as the AI age takes shape, she suggests:
AI companies are going global faster than any other cohort of company in SaaS land, and that’s really unique. The median AI company in the Forbes 50 is in 59 countries in one year. That never happened any time before. You [used to] start a company and think, ‘OK I’ll be in my domestic market, then I might go cross-border and I might go to Germany or Australia or Canada’. That’s happening faster than any any time in history.
That’s actually very exciting, she suggests:
We’re seeing a surge in solo entrepreneurs, and we’re really excited about this. There was a time when you had to be a tech-forward founder in order to start a company, and that’s now been disrupted. So you have non-technical founders and solo entrepreneurs that are building businesses, and they’re building them really fast. On top of that, they’re getting to revenue, substantial revenue, within a year.
In such an economy AI should be something that brings everybody along, she contends:
This is an opportunity for everybody to drive productivity, to drive growth, but most importantly, especially for Europe, to drive entrepreneurship and drive business, like meaningful business and durable companies for the long term.
O’Mara concludes:
We have to make sure that all of the young people coming through really feel that they can build a company and scale a company and that’s there for them [in Europe], as opposed to [feeling] that’s an American story and not a European story. I think we all have work to do on that to be quite honest.
My take
The Single Market is not a single state. While there are State-wide regulatory differences across the US – and these are currently being emphasized all the more by the rise of AI. See the war between California, home to Silicon Valley, and Trump’s Washington for proof of that! – it is undeniably easier to scale a business to a global market-level in America than it is in Europe.
The EU-Inc proposal was not perfect when it was submitted for consideration, but it was a damn sight better than the status quo and a definite step in the right direction. But the eternal need to find a ‘Euro-fudge’ that won’t upset anyone and will pander to the self-interests of everyone has rendered it essentially spineless. If Europe’s posturing politicians are really genuine about making the continent a serious contender alongside the US and China, they must urgently intervene and reverse the damage done by the Eurocrats in Brussels.
If you don’t learn from the mistakes of the past, you are doomed to repeat them. Europe has no serious tech industry to speak of for good reasons. It doesn’t have to be this way – but already, given the pace of innovation in the AI space, time is running out for the desperately-needed course correction to take place.