The buildings at 314, 316, and 318 Main Street are gone, dismantled in a matter of hours after enduring years of abandonment and neglect. The derelict properties that once stood proud and strong as anchors in a thriving downtown Warsaw business landscape were beyond restoring to the distinct Italianate architectural style they represented, but their historical significance and cultural contributions to Warsaw are immortalized in photographs and residents’ stories.

Built in 1869 by Ike Broadhurst, the historic, commercial row of buildings was constructed using bricks fired in Broadhurst’s local brickyard. The three-story Mussetter building at 314 Main St., the first to be deconstructed on Tuesday, Oct. 13, began life as a bustling dry goods store before transitioning to a very popular billiard saloon under James McElwy years later. Prominent TP&W Railroad attorney, Robert Ingersoll, was a regular patron who enjoyed shooting pool at the billiard hall during his frequent visits to Warsaw in the 1870s. The town can boast that it served a notable guest as Ingersoll became president of TP&W Railroad before rising to the role of Illinois Attorney General.

The Mussetter building housed a successful clothing and dry goods store under the Dory brothers, who sold shoes, boots, coats, hats, and an extensive line of men’s and women’s clothing for more than 20 years.

With Henry Roth as the proprietor, the building was remodeled in the early 1900s to house an oyster bar, before Roth ventured into his lengthy grocery business.

Famous for great food and friendly service, the Heffner Café, the next Musseter building enterprise, enjoyed steady patronage, leading to George Wepner’s decision to continue operating the building as an eatery for several years after he purchased the restaurant from Mrs. John Heffner in March, 1925.

In 1946, Ed Brownlee, a button cutter during the Warsaw button factory’s thriving riverfront business, founded a button cutting plant, the Hawkeye Button Works, at 314 Main St.. With 25 employees and 15 cutting machines, and clam shells shipped from the Tennessee River, the company manufactured 175,000 blanks weekly and shipped them to Muscatine for drilling and finishing.

Ironically, a great number of the finished buttons were shipped back to Warsaw and used by the Osgood Garment Factory, located directly across the street from the button plant. Wallace and Melvin Bennett, Ruth Clark, Florence Brownlee, Henry Sartory, Laun Brownlee, Joe Cline, John Zimmerman, Wendell Howren and Bill Courtois were some of the employees.

The second structure to come down, 316 Main St., was most likely a retail or service business in the later 19th and early 20th century. The third and last building to be razed, 318 Main St., once served as Wick’s Saloon, a popular community gathering place started in 1993 that is “fondly remembered for its role” in Warsaw’s “social fabric” during its years of operation under owner Jerry Lee Wichman, a lifelong Warsaw resident and general contractor who also worked with the postal service for many years. Larry Frederick Nelson, a local Navy veteran and Eagle Scout, was one of the well-known employees.

Prior to operating the saloon, Wichman was a central fixture in Warsaw’s civic and community engagement. He graduated from Warsaw High School and served two tours of duty with the Army in Vietnam, receiving multiple commendations including the Purple Heart. His notable contributions to Warsaw include spearheading local projects as president of the Jaycees and post commander of the Warsaw Veterans of Foreign Wars Post 9802.

Today, regional memorabilia collectors and historians fondly recall and gather Wick’s Saloon vintage promotional wooden nickels – drink tokens – and they are occasionally offered for sale on collector sites.

As the Warsaw Historical Society and Museum continues its mission to promote and preserve the town’s diverse heritage, members are compiling information for a walking tour that will focus on Warsaw’s rich architectural history. The buildings at 314, 316, and 318 Main Street may be gone, but their role in Warsaw’s thriving 1800s and 1900s riverfront commercial landscape will be shared during the tour and during history discussions in classrooms and locals’ gatherings. May the stories continue!