Nov. 3, 2026, 9:40 p.m. CT

Voters in Muskego and New Berlin defeated referendums to increase taxes for more police and firefighters.Muskego’s proposal failed by a nearly 2-to-1 margin, while New Berlin’s was also decisively rejected.The proposed tax increases would have funded new personnel and equipment for public safety departments in both cities.City officials and some voters acknowledged the need for more funding but understood residents’ reluctance to support the initiatives.

Separate bids by the cities of Muskego and New Berlin to add more police and firefighters through tax-levy overrides both failed on Nov. 3.

As part of a busy mix of midterm election choices, including state and federal offices and three state constitutional questions, voters defeated the strictly local public safety referendums by nearly a 2-to-1 margin in Muskego.

According to preliminary results, about 64.4% (9,023 to 4,984) voted against the Muskego measure. The vote count in New Berlin, with about 56.2% (11,908 to 9,285) voting “no,” was closer but nonetheless decisive.

“I respect the voters’ decision, and I appreciate everyone who took the time to ask questions, share their views and vote,” Muskego Mayor Rick Petfalski said in an emailed statement to the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. “This proposal did not receive the community’s support. We need to listen and better understand what residents believe would be a better path forward.”

New Berlin Mayor Dave Ament did not immediately respond to a request for a statement Tuesday night. A statement on behalf of the city acknowledged the result, adding: “The city appreciates the residents who attended public information meetings, reviewed referendum materials, and asked questions throughout the process.”

Muskego voters don’t buy into city’s plan

Muskego, which has depended on the Tess Corners Volunteer Fire Department for fire and emergency medical service needs, wants to hire a city-employed staff – consisting of one full-time fire chief, 15 full-time personnel and 36 part-time, paid-on-call staff – to supplement Tess Corners services and provide coverage at all times.

The city has its own police and public works departments, but officials proposed funding for another five police officers and one dispatcher, and four additional public works employees and one administrative support position.

Without voter approval, the city can only levy about $14.5 million (based on August projections), a half percent more for 2027 than it did for the 2026 fiscal year. With voter approval, the city could have levied about $20.4 million, a 40.2% increase. The $5.9 million public safety initiative would have extended annually beyond 2027 to continue to pay for the new personnel.

Petfalski, who has repeatedly raised concerns about how state funding formulas rely too heavily on local taxes, said he can understand why voters turned down a plan that could have cost many households another $500 in taxes annually.

“I share the frustration about asking property owners to shoulder more of the cost of local government,” he said. “In my opinion, relying so heavily on property taxes is an unfair way to pay for services that benefit everyone. The state needs to do more to support local public safety and provide meaningful property tax relief.”

New Berlin voters defeat public safety plan

Unlike Muskego, New Berlin has its own fire department, but the city’s public safety initiative sought to add staff to the 54-member department as well as the 70-member police department.

The permanent fund would have allowed the city to hire three police officers plus a division chief, 12 paramedics and support staff, plus at least one additional vehicle and related equipment.

The city wanted to generate $3,122,149 in taxes over the limit state-mandated levy limit, or an 8.1% increase in the overall levy. For an average value home of about $375,000, the cost would be $156 more per year.

How the city will deal with the referendum’s defeat isn’t clear.

Voters share their own views at the polls

In both cities, some voters put the choice into some perspective. They understood the need, but acknowledged the mixed political feelings the measures were bound to generate at the polls.

“My feeling is that it’s not gonna pass,” Brandon Anderson said at Muskego City Hall during the late-afternoon rush. “Usually, that’s how a lot of the referendums go anyway. It usually takes a few times. We’ve done that with schools [as well].”

Though he voted in favor of Muskego’s plan, he wasn’t necessarily an ardent supporter.

Across the border into New Berlin, Denise Meyer also voted in favor of her city’s public safety initiative. “I mean, I think it impacts fire and safety, right? So I think we need to fund those,” she said.

But she recognized that many people wouldn’t, possibly swayed by a campaign that incorrectly connected to the Milwaukee Rescue Mission’s New Journey residential drug and alcohol treatment center to the public safety initiative. “I don’t think that’s tied together. If you vote for [the referendum], it doesn’t mean they’re going to build that,” she said.

The push for a workable safety initiative doesn’t end with the vote, Muskego’s mayor said.

“The challenges facing public safety, especially our current Fire and EMS service model, remain. The Common Council and I will take the voters’ feedback into account and keep working toward a solution that addresses those needs and earns the community’s support,” Petfalksi said.

Contact reporter Jim Riccioli at  james.riccioli@jrn.com.