KHNP-Daewoo Engineering & Construction Co., Ltd., Impact on terminated investors
사진 확대 Warsaw Pact troops entered in August 1968 in front of a radio station in Prague, Czechoslovakia. [Josef Koudelka, a master from the Czech Republic, Magnum Photos]
On the night of August 20, 1968, Soviet-led Warsaw Pact tanks crossed the Czechoslovak border. The “Praha Spring,” which pushed for the abolition and liberalization of censorship after Alexander Dubcek took office as the Communist Party’s first secretary in January of that year, came to an end just a few months later.
However, it has become an identity that symbolizes the Czech Republic. a failure to conform unconditionally to the order of a great power. It is what does not follow the logic of the empire.
July 2024, more than half a century later.
The Czech Republic chose South Korea, not France, a European nuclear powerhouse, as a project to build a new nuclear power plant that will determine the country’s energy security. After fierce competition between the French Electric Power Corporation (EDF) and Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power (KHNP), KHNP has been selected as the preferred bidder for the two Dukovani nuclear power plants worth about 27 trillion won.
This was a monumental event. This is because South Korea, a latecomer, defeated France, the founder of nuclear power plants.
사진 확대 A bird’s eye view of the Czech Republic’s Dukovani units 5 and 6. [Picture = Korea Hydro & Nuclear Power]
On the surface, Korea’s “On Time (On Budget)” strategy to complete nuclear power plants with the budget promised at a fixed time worked.
Inside, however, the Czech identity also had an impact. The Czech Republic ruled out Chinese state nuclear power plant companies CGN and Russia’s Rosatom from the bidding race for security reasons in 2021, when the bidding was in full swing. “At that time, the difference in bidding prices between EDF and KHNP was not large,” a senior government official said. “However, the Czech Republic wanted to do it with the West, not China and Russia, and in the end, South Korea was able to win the final victory.”
In particular, during the bidding process, France’s EDF cooperated with Chinese equipment companies to set the supply price similar to that of Korea. The Czech Republic, the client of the order, seems to have become more favorable to Korea in this section.
Czech nuclear power plant, unprecedented replacement of contractors
The gap in construction costs between KHNP and Daewoo Engineering & Construction exceeds 1 trillion
The Czech media “neglected Europe to focus on South Korea and the U.S.”
The Czech Republic’s trust gained in this way has been put to a new test for the first time in more than two years. This is because the construction cost conflict between Korean companies led to the replacement of the construction company.
KHNP ended construction contract negotiations with Daewoo E&C and Doosan Energy Consortium on the 29th of last month and started the process of selecting a new construction company. Since signing the main contract with the Czech client in June last year, 91 consultations have been held for 15 months, but differences over construction costs and contract terms have not been narrowed.
사진 확대 Maekyung DB
The differences between the two sides regarding construction costs far exceed 1 trillion won.
Neither side has officially raised the exact amount. However, KHNP reportedly wanted to set the construction cost within about 30% (8 trillion won) of the total project cost of 27 trillion won.
An industry official estimated, “It seems that the 30% project cost of the KHNP line is seen as an implicit reference point in the case of the UAE Baraka nuclear power plant.” This is because KHNP has to pay not only construction costs but also periodic and design costs.
On the other hand, Daewoo Engineering & Construction reportedly offered an amount that exceeded this amount. Regarding this, KHNP recognized that Daewoo Engineering & Construction was measuring construction costs too high. In the past, the Baraka nuclear power plant in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was built, and the construction contract between Hyundai Engineering & Construction and Samsung C&T totaled about 7.5 trillion won.
사진 확대 Participants are taking a commemorative photo at the signing ceremony of the contract for the purchase of steam turbines for the Czech Republic’s Dukovani nuclear power plants 5 and 6 in Prague, Czech Republic, on the 16th (local time). From left, Karel Havlicek, Czech Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Industry and Trade, Son Seung-woo, Head of Doosan Energy Power Services BG, Daniel Prochazka, Chief Operating Officer (COO) of Doosan Skoda Power, and Kim Jung-kwan, Minister of Industry and Trade. [Doosan’s potential]
The Czech Republic’s view of this is not as good as it is.
The Czech government officially represents the Korean government and KHNP, saying, “There will be no major problems with delivery.” However, there are also other voices in the Czech Republic.
※ The full text of the article is available on Maeil Business Newspaper’s premium financial content platform Maekyung Plus. Search ‘Maekyung Plus’ on Naver or take a QR code below with your smartphone to connect.
사진 확대