The Warsaw Public Library Book Club met on Tuesday, April 7 to discuss “The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo” by Taylor Jenkins Reid with the rating evenly divided between a 3 and a 3.5. The group was smaller than usual but the discussion, led by Vera Austin, was still insightful and thorough, and Karen Torbeck’s delicious peach cobbler, still warm from the oven, was enjoyed by all.
Conversation focused on 79-year-old Evelyn Hugo’s actions and motives for her behavior with the group unanimously agreeing with Donna Naderhoff that she was a “driven opportunist without morals and scruples” who entered relationships with men and women to advance her personal goals. Kent Naderhoff observed that “there was nothing too devious and depraved that she wouldn’t do if it was justified in her mind, the end justified the means.” Donna also noted that Hugo had no qualms about stepping over people, and that she frequently took risks; she would “close her eyes and jump.”
Austin asked the group if Hugo’s accounts of her life to Monique Grant, the journalist she hired to document her life in a biography, were accurate. Was Hugo a reliable narrator of her life? Donna Naderhoff noted that Hugo’s request that the book be published after her death indicated reliability. Kent Naderhoff commented that all personal accounts may be “one-sided,” and agreed that yes, Hugo was giving a “true biography” even though she was a “hard-to-like person.”
In reviewing the seven segments of Hugo’s life, each corresponding to the name of a husband, the club debated Hugo’s ability to love any of her husbands and considered that she may have genuinely cared for Don Adler, an abusive drunk who regretted his behavior and became a “movie star on the rise” at the end of the story. Throughout the discussion, the club recognized the characters’ tension between maintaining personal integrity versus conformity to a public image, and stressed the need for authenticity, morals, boundaries and accountability in all relationships. Hugo’s decision to undergo multiple cosmetic surgeries to obliterate her Cuban heritage physically and culturally to succeed in “white” Hollywood was viewed as conforming dishonesty comparable to Michael Jackson’s tragic attempts to minimize his black ancestry. While Hugo’s surgeries were regarded as disingenuous, it was also noted that in today’s Hollywood climate, plastic surgery is a regular, genuine part of actors’ and actresses’ lives.
Despite Hugo’s shallowness, the group respected and agreed with this bit of advice: “Never let anyone make you feel ordinary.”
The Warsaw Public Library Book Club invites other bibliophiles to join them for stimulating discussion and fellowship on the first Tuesdays of the month at 6 p.m. in the Warsaw Public Library conference room. The members will review “So Brave, Young, and Handsome” by Leif Enger on May 5.