{"id":196032,"date":"2026-10-31T21:52:31","date_gmt":"2026-10-31T21:52:31","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/196032\/"},"modified":"2026-10-31T21:52:31","modified_gmt":"2026-10-31T21:52:31","slug":"from-beijing-to-brussels-pathways-to-the-integration-of-gender-in-research-and-development-igird","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/196032\/","title":{"rendered":"From Beijing to Brussels: pathways to the integration of gender in research and development (IGIRD)"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>As a result of the event analysis, four analytical clusters were identified: Gender Equality Policies and Anti-discrimination Frameworks, Women\u2019s Advancement in Science, Technology and Education, Health and Medical Research, and IGiRD. These clusters are best read as partially overlapping institutionalisation logics that emerged at different points in time, developed at different speeds across regions, and sometimes reinforced one another. Figure\u00a0<a data-track=\"click\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-track-action=\"figure anchor\" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#Fig1\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">1<\/a> visualises these clusters and marks selected critical junctures that changed the rules, resources, responsibilities, or legitimacy claims through which sex and gender analysis became anchored in R&amp;I systems. In line with the purposive character of the corpus, the analysis uses the EU, US, and South Korea as comparatively well-documented and analytically contrasting cases, while drawing on other regional developments where they illuminate alternative pathways.<\/p>\n<p>Fig. 1: Layered pathways and critical junctures in the institutionalisation of IGiRD.<img decoding=\"async\" aria-describedby=\"figure-1-desc\" src=\"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-content\/uploads\/2026\/10\/41599_2026_9484_Fig1_HTML.png\" alt=\"Fig. 1: Layered pathways and critical junctures in the institutionalisation of IGiRD.\" loading=\"lazy\" width=\"685\" height=\"939\"\/><\/p>\n<p>Four partially overlapping pathways shaping the integration of sex and gender analysis in research.<\/p>\n<p>Starting Point: Gender Equality Policies and Anti-discrimination Frameworks<\/p>\n<p>The national and international women\u2019s movements, situated within the broader context of fundamental human rights for all individuals, regardless of gender, gained momentum in many countries throughout the 20th century. These movements can be seen as the starting point of the path to IGiRD, at a time when science was still viewed as gender neutral. They focused on explicitly extending constitutional principles of equality to women, resulting in the institutionalisation of equality claims in national constitutions and international agreements, particularly concerning the labour market. In terms of the framework developed above, this cluster mainly represents the formal anchoring of gender equality as a legal and normative principle. It did not yet establish IGiRD as a research-content requirement, but it created an enabling institutional layer on which later research-specific developments could build.<\/p>\n<p>Path formation: a narrower, liberal concept of gender equality<\/p>\n<p>These early, basic equality policies and anti-discrimination frameworks often emphasised economic considerations, social policy or gender equality. For instance, early legal provisions like those in the EU\u2019s Treaty of Rome (1957) predominantly adopted a liberal perspective on gender equality, aiming to ensure broad participation of women and men in a harmonised European market. This claim was reflected in the principle of equal pay for men and women outlined in Article 119 of the Treaty of Rome (Jacquot, <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference n.d.\" title=\"Jacquot, S (n.d.). European Union gender equality policies since 1957. In Encyclopedia of European History. Retrieved from &#010;                  https:\/\/ehne.fr\/en\/encyclopedia\/themes\/gender-and-europe\/gender-citizenship-in-europe\/european-union-gender-equality-policies-1957&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR31\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1134\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">n.d.<\/a>). Around the same time, a pronounced protection against discrimination for women developed in the US to enable their equal participation in the labour market. Key milestones in this development include the Equal Pay Act (1963), the Civil Rights Act (1964), and Executive Order 11375 (1967), which promoted affirmative action for marginalised groups, including women. Despite these advancements, the effective enforcement and practical application of these laws remain paramount.<\/p>\n<p>The gap between legislation and its implementation can critically undermine the objectives of gender equality. For example, the Pregnancy Discrimination Act (1978), despite its robust legal framework, also illustrates the broader challenge of translating formal protection into consistent enforcement. Research highlights that effective gender equality policies require not only strong legal foundations but also consistent monitoring and compliance systems to ensure their impact (McCann <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 1994\" title=\"McCann MW (1994) Rights at work: Pay equity reform and the politics of legal mobilization. University of Chicago Press\" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR44\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1140\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">1994<\/a>; Kelly and Dobbin <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 1999\" title=\"Kelly E, Dobbin F (1999) Civil rights law at work: sex discrimination and the rise of maternity leave policies. Am J Sociol 105(2):455&#x2013;492. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1086\/210316&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR35\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1143\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">1999<\/a>). This early implementation gap anticipates a recurring pattern in the later institutionalisation of IGiRD: formal anchoring alone does not guarantee operational embedding or substantive change in practice.<\/p>\n<p>Critical Juncture: the diffusion of gender mainstreaming<\/p>\n<p>From the 1990s onwards, a second phase for the fundamental anchoring of gender equality policies and anti-discrimination frameworks can be recognised. The endorsement of gender mainstreaming at significant international forums has catalysed the shift from a liberal idea of gender equality towards more proactive gender equality policies. This strategic approach involves integrating gender equality considerations into all policy areas, thereby promoting a holistic and inclusive framework that permeates every level of decision-making and policy development. In this context, the United Nations Fourth World Conference on Women, which resulted in the Beijing Declaration and Platform for Action (1995), stood out as a critical juncture, leading to the adoption of gender mainstreaming policies at national and supranational levels. It constituted a critical juncture because it changed the legitimacy basis of gender equality policy: gender was no longer framed only as a matter of equal treatment or anti-discrimination, but increasingly as a cross-cutting policy concern to be integrated into all domains of governance.<\/p>\n<p>The significance of the Beijing Declaration is exemplified by the introduction of the principle of gender mainstreaming in the Treaty of Amsterdam (1997). This commitment requires the EU to systematically incorporate gender equality across all policy areas, including science and research (Rees <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2005\" title=\"Rees T (2005) Reflections on the uneven development of gender mainstreaming in Europe. Int Feminist J Politics 7(4):555&#x2013;574. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1080\/14616740500284532&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR56\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1157\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2005<\/a>). The institutionalisation of the EU\u2019s commitment to gender mainstreaming is part of the critical trajectory triggered by the Beijing Declaration. The Treaty of Amsterdam established the legal framework for gender-sensitive policies and led to its operationalisation through specific action plans and funding programmes in subsequent years. This trajectory was confirmed by the adoption of United Nations\u2019 Sustainable Development Goal 5: Gender equality in 2015, although progress towards this goal remains significantly behind schedule (United Nations <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2023\" title=\"United Nations (2023) The Sustainable Development Goals Report 2023. Available at: &#010;                  https:\/\/unstats.un.org\/sdgs\/report\/2023\/The-Sustainable-Development-Goals-Report-2023.pdf&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR67\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1160\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2023<\/a>). For the EU pathway, this development was particularly consequential because it created a governance architecture through which later IGiRD requirements could be layered onto research and innovation policy.<\/p>\n<p>Different regional path speeds and path stabilisation mechanisms<\/p>\n<p>However, translating global gender norms into local action highlights the challenges of cultural and regional variations. Each region and country may experience different stages of gender policy development, influenced by local cultural, economic, and political contexts. For instance, while the EU and the US have long-established frameworks for gender equality, countries like South Korea and Japan have seen a more recent surge in policy development. Following the global endorsement of gender equality norms, South Korea enacted the Equal Employment Opportunity and Work-Family Balance Assistance Act (2001), marking a significant step in its institutional pathway towards gender equality. This illustrates that similar transnational norms can generate different institutional trajectories depending on domestic political structures, advocacy coalitions and administrative capacities.<\/p>\n<p>To navigate the pursuit of gender equality in society, continuous monitoring and impact assessments have been established to evaluate the effectiveness of current policies and guide necessary adjustments and improvements. For example, the European Institute for Gender Equality (EIGE), established in 2006, or the Cabinet Office Gender Equality Bureau in Japan (since 2001) monitor gender equality policies, provide data and reports that inform policy revisions, and promote changes to societal systems across all areas from a gender equality standpoint. These monitoring mechanisms not only enable adaptive improvements but also play a critical role in stabilising the institutional path of gender equality by reinforcing existing frameworks, legitimising ongoing efforts, and discouraging deviations from established goals. They are therefore not merely manifestations of institutionalisation, but can become mechanisms of path stabilisation by producing data, accountability expectations and policy feedback.<\/p>\n<p>The foundational policies set the stage for advancements in all subsequent clusters. The establishment of gender equality as a constitutional principle, the enactment of anti-discrimination laws, and their conceptual transition from a liberal to a broader understanding of gender mainstreaming, created a legal and normative framework that supports and drives gender integration in various sectors, including research. However, this relationship should not be understood as an automatic spill-over from gender equality policy to IGiRD. Rather, anti-discrimination frameworks and gender-mainstreaming policies provided an enabling institutional layer. Whether this layer translated into research-specific IGiRD requirements depended on additional mechanisms, including funding rules, programme design, disciplinary advocacy, review procedures, monitoring systems and research-quality framings.<\/p>\n<p>Policy expansion and layering: Women\u2019s Advancement in Science, Technology and Education<\/p>\n<p>The cluster Women\u2019s Advancement in Science, Technology and Education comprises strategic, multifaceted approaches aimed at integrating women more fully into regional research and innovation systems. Examples of these approaches are broader legislative frameworks, their implementation through specific support systems, compliance mechanisms, institutional reforms, data collection methodologies, and continuous evaluation strategies that underpin these efforts. On the path to IGiRD, the cluster describes the expansion and layering of gender equality policies into the R&amp;I system. However, the focus is still on promoting the participation of women and not on the gender-sensitive design of research. In terms of the analytical distinction introduced above, this cluster primarily concerns formal anchoring and operational embedding of equality goals within research institutions, rather than substantive methodological integration of sex and gender analysis into research content.<\/p>\n<p>Path formation: from general to targeted gender equality policies<\/p>\n<p>In some cases, clear regional extensions of more general gender equality and anti-discrimination policies into regional R&amp;I systems can be identified. In the US, the Science and Engineering Equal Opportunities Act (1980) laid the foundation, establishing a framework for addressing gender disparities in STEM fields. This Act directed the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and National Science Foundation (NSF) to increase the participation of underrepresented groups in medicine, science, and engineering, with dedicated funding. This groundwork was expanded by acts like the Advancement of Women and Minorities in Science, Engineering, and Technology Development Act (1998) and reinforced by compliance mechanisms such as the Title IX common rule (2000) on non-discrimination in education. The US therefore represents an important federal pathway in this cluster, even though these initiatives were not embedded in a comprehensive gender-mainstreaming architecture comparable to the EU.<\/p>\n<p>Another comparable point of policy expansion can be seen in South Korea with the Act on Fostering and Supporting Women Scientists and Technicians enacted in 2002. This law established a robust legal framework that includes affirmative action and career support measures. At this stage, the South Korean pathway was primarily concerned with women\u2019s participation and career advancement in science and technology, not yet with the systematic integration of sex and gender analysis into research design. Similarly, Japan demonstrates a gradual approach to adapting gender equality policies, with the government showing commitment by progressively increasing hiring targets for women under its successive Science and Technology Basic Plans (since 1996).<\/p>\n<p>In contrast, other countries, e.g., Germany, do not have a single equivalent legislative act. Instead, Germany\u2019s policy expansion toward gender equality in R&amp;I has emerged incrementally through a combination of federal laws, EU directives, and funding guidelines \u2013 such as the German Research Foundation\u2019s Research-Oriented Standard on Gender Equality (2008) and the Women Professorship Programme (since 2007). This illustrates that similar institutional goals can be pursued through different combinations of legal mandates, funding incentives and organisational standards.<\/p>\n<p>Regional path adoptions: structured top-down vs. decentralised-situational gender mainstreaming<\/p>\n<p>In contrast to the US, the EU\u2019s supranational and structured approach to address gender disparities in science and technology began with data collection and monitoring. Following the Beijing Declaration, it established the European Technology Assessment Network (ETAN 1998) and, influenced by the Treaty of Amsterdam, the Helsinki Group on Women and Science (1999), creating a robust system for continuous monitoring. The recurring publication of \u201cShe Figures\u201d (since 2003), coordinated by a specific unit within the EU Commission\u2019s Directorate-General for R&amp;I, has provided a data-driven foundation for policy decisions, reflecting the EU\u2019s commitment to evaluating gender dynamics in science and technology. However, until 2018, the \u201cShe Figures\u201d focused solely on gender representation and not IGiRD. This distinction is important because monitoring women\u2019s representation in science stabilised the equality path, but did not yet amount to monitoring sex and gender analysis in research content.<\/p>\n<p>Moving beyond data analysis, the EU policy to establish the ERA (ERA, since 2000) saw the promotion of gender mainstreaming as an essential component and a criterion of success, encouraging EU member states to develop national action plans to support women in R&amp;I and advance integration of the gender dimension. However, historically it has faced challenges such as inconsistent implementation across member states and a lack of binding commitments, which have limited the effectiveness of these initiatives and the development of the ERA more generally. This points to a recurring tension in the EU pathway: supranational coordination can create strong formal and programmatic expectations, but their operational embedding still depends on national implementation, institutional capacities and monitoring arrangements.<\/p>\n<p>In the context of the EU, it is important to highlight the influence of the FPs, which allocate billions of Euros in research funding and require multinational collaborations in projects. Given the substantial volume and Europe-wide reach of the funding provided, the respective funding guidelines and programme policies serve as key steering mechanisms for gender equality requirements and the integration of the gender dimension into R&amp;I content (European Commission <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2020a\" title=\"European Commission. (2020a) Gendered innovations 2: How inclusive analysis contributes to research and innovation. Luxembourg: Publications Office of the European Union\" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR13\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1213\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2020a<\/a>). Thus, the FPs function as a key mechanism of path stabilisation: once gender equality and, later, the gender dimension in research content are linked to funding expectations, they begin to shape organisational strategies, proposal practices and evaluation routines across the European R&amp;I system.<\/p>\n<p>The aim of increasing female representation in STEM is also evident at national level, as shown by the UK and Germany, albeit with different justifications. The UK has often framed women as an underused resource in the research sector, while the DFG Code of Conduct emphasises research quality and aligns with the EU narrative that diversity is relevant for good scientific practice. These frames matter because they shape how easily women\u2019s advancement policies can later connect to IGiRD as a question of scientific excellence.<\/p>\n<p>Path stabilisation mechanisms<\/p>\n<p>Both the US and EU have placed a strong emphasis on evaluating the effectiveness of gender equality policies in R&amp;I. Reports such as the U.S. Government Accountability Office (<a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2004\" title=\"U.S. Government Accountability Office (2004) Gender issues: Women&#x2019;s participation in the sciences has increased, but agencies need to do more to ensure compliance with Title IX (GAO-04-639). &#010;                  https:\/\/www.gao.gov\/products\/gao-04-639&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR68\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1227\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2004<\/a>) report and the mid-term assessment of the EU\u2019s Sixth Framework Programme offered critical insights that helped refine and adjust policies on gender mainstreaming in R&amp;I. Furthermore, the EU operationalised gender mainstreaming in research institutions and science practice by providing scientific evidence and expert recommendations through FP projects like GenSET. This marked a significant shift toward recognising the two-way interdependence between embedding gender equality considerations in science practices and the adoption of the gender dimension as a criterion of quality in research outcomes, driving innovative strength. In path-dependency terms, such monitoring reports, expert networks and funded coordination projects are not merely outputs of institutionalisation. They also generate feedback effects by producing evidence, legitimising further interventions and creating communities of practice.<\/p>\n<p>In summary, when comparing different regions, different approaches and outcomes become visible. Whereas the EU relies heavily on data-driven strategies, financial incentives, and capacity building, the US contrasts with the more legislatively focused approach. These differences underscore the influence of cultural and institutional contexts on addressing gender disparities. For the development of IGiRD, the main significance of this cluster lies in its bridging function: it brought gender equality concerns into the R&amp;I system, created monitoring and funding infrastructures, and helped establish gender as a legitimate concern of research governance. However, it did not by itself ensure that sex and gender analysis would be integrated into research content. This required further institutional layering through biomedical research policies, funding criteria, methodological guidance and evaluation standards, as discussed in the following clusters.<\/p>\n<p>External shocks and epistemic urgency: Health and Medical Research<\/p>\n<p>This cluster traces the institutionalisation of IGiRD in health and medical research, particularly in the US and Canada. It shows how formal anchoring was translated into comparatively concrete requirements, research procedures, reporting standards and training.<\/p>\n<p>Critical junctures: Women\u2019s Health Movement and medical scandals as external shocks<\/p>\n<p>In the US, the Women\u2019s Health Movement emerged as a transformative force as early as the 1960s, with grassroots organisations such as the Boston Women\u2019s Health Book Collective and the National Women\u2019s Health Network challenging a male-dominated healthcare system and its neglect of women\u2019s health needs. Unlike broader gender equality policies, health research was also shaped by medical scandals. The Thalidomide scandal and the Diethylstilbestrol controversy exposed systemic neglect of women\u2019s health and prompted regulatory reform. In path-dependency terms, these scandals functioned as external shocks. They challenged the assumption that gender-blind medical research was scientifically adequate and opened the way for new regulatory, ethical and methodological standards.<\/p>\n<p>Path formation: towards a broader concept of women\u2019s health<\/p>\n<p>Sustained advocacy efforts began to crystallise into more formalised changes with the establishment of the US Office of Research on Women\u2019s Health (ORWH) in 1990. The ORWH was tasked with broadening the concept of women\u2019s health beyond the female reproductive system. Legislative actions, such as the NIH Health Revitalisation Act (1993), mandated the inclusion of women and minority groups in clinical trials, although this requirement did not extend to the discovery and preclinical phases that utilised cells and animal models. This limitation later became a major focus of policy debates on sex as a biological variable, particularly in relation to preclinical research. This legislation was a response to earlier findings that the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) had failed to include women in clinical trials. Similar reports on women\u2019s involvement in health research were missing in the EU, representing a significant oversight. Such initiatives established precedents that influenced other regions. For example, the European Medicines Agency\u2019s adoption of the ICH guideline on gender considerations in clinical trials and Health Canada\u2019s development of gender-based analysis, later expanded into Sex- and Gender-Based Analysis Plus, reflect an expanding acknowledgement of the role of sex and gender analysis in health research and policy (European Medicines Agency <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2005\" title=\"European Medicines Agency. (2005) Gender considerations in the conduct of clinical trials. &#010;                  https:\/\/www.ema.europa.eu\/en\/gender-considerations-conduct-clinical-trials&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR12\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1257\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2005<\/a>; Health Canada <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2023\" title=\"Health Canada (2023) Health Portfolio Sex- and Gender-Based Analysis Plus Policy. Government of Canada. &#010;                  https:\/\/www.canada.ca\/en\/health-canada\/corporate\/transparency\/heath-portfolio-sex-gender-based-analysis-policy.html&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR28\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1260\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2023<\/a>). These policy mandates are pivotal, as they provide the necessary legal and institutional frameworks that compel researchers and institutions to abide by specific gender parameters. They also illustrate how health research developed a comparatively strong operational infrastructure for IGiRD: inclusion rules, reporting expectations, clinical guidelines, agency responsibilities and later training resources.<\/p>\n<p>Path stabilisation: monitoring systems, reporting standards and integration in medical education<\/p>\n<p>As in the previous clusters, regular reporting and evaluation, such as those conducted by the U.S. Government Accountability Office since 1990, play a critical role in assessing the effectiveness of policies and educational efforts in the health sector, thereby contributing to path stabilisation. Such monitoring mechanisms stabilise the path because they make implementation gaps visible, create accountability pressures and provide evidence for further policy refinement.<\/p>\n<p>This area has also seen a shift towards the institutionalisation of gender-sensitive training in medical curricula, exemplified by the Sex and Gender Health Education Summit (2018). This educational approach is complemented by international efforts, including the adoption of guidelines that require sex and gender analysis in reporting basic research for the first time (2016). Such standards are crucial because they harmonise research practices beyond national regulatory systems and shape how results are reported, assessed and translated into clinical and regulatory contexts. Journal guidelines are therefore not merely dissemination instruments; they act as operational embedding mechanisms by shaping what counts as adequate reporting and, indirectly, as adequate research design. Recent evidence from 574 NIH-funded publications illustrates the remaining gap between operational embedding and substantive methodological integration: although most studies included both sexes, fewer than half analysed their results by sex (Warden et al. <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2026\" title=\"Warden JH, Parangalan M, Welty LJ et al (2026) Incorporation of the National Institute of Health (NIH) sex as a biological variable policy by R01 grant awardees. Commun Med 6:208. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1038\/s43856-026-01547-0&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR75\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1274\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2026<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>These international efforts are complemented by national measures, including Germany\u2019s 2021 coalition agreement and Canada\u2019s Sex- and Gender-Based Analysis Plus (SGBA\u2009+\u2009) framework, established in 2011. This framework mandates the integration of sex and gender considerations in federally funded health research and encourages medical schools to incorporate these principles into their curricula. Canada is particularly relevant here because SGBA+ connects biomedical research quality with a broader policy framework that also acknowledges intersecting factors. This makes the Canadian pathway different from the US pathway, where the strongest institutionalisation has historically been concentrated around women\u2019s health, clinical inclusion and sex as a biological variable.<\/p>\n<p>Overall, health and medical research provides the clearest indications in the event corpus of progression from formal anchoring and operational embedding towards substantive methodological integration. The findings also show that inclusion and reporting requirements do not necessarily translate into consistent sex- and gender-based analysis in research practice.<\/p>\n<p>IGiRD: from research-content integration to programmatic institutionalisation<\/p>\n<p>The cluster brings together events in which formal anchoring and operational embedding are increasingly directed towards substantive methodological integration. Compared to the others, this cluster represents the most explicit research-content-oriented layer of the development from promoting the participation of women in working life to a broader approach that connects Gendered Innovations with Gender Mainstreaming in research. This cluster captures a later layer in which sex and gender analysis increasingly became a formal expectation of research design, funding, evaluation, reporting and institutional strategy. IGiRD is a relatively new policy and analytical object, having developed around the turn of the millennium, largely driven by the EU\u2019s gender mainstreaming policy. A closer look at the cluster shows that it is not a closed development process, but that a variety of research fields and region-specific dynamics characterise the institutionalisation of IGiRD.<\/p>\n<p>Critical junctures and path stabilisation: IGiRD in the ERA and the Framework Programmes<\/p>\n<p>The EU is widely regarded as a pioneer in institutionalising gender integration within research, primarily through its funding mechanisms under the FPs. IGiRD has played a key role since the inception of a harmonised European research policy in the form of the ERA. The recommendations of the Helsinki Group on Women and Science (1999)\u2014which can be traced back to the Beijing Declaration and took IGiRD into account alongside women\u2019s advancement\u2014were largely incorporated into this policy area. In path-dependency terms, the Helsinki Group and the early ERA process helped connect two previously distinct institutional layers: women\u2019s advancement in science and the integration of the gender dimension into research content.<\/p>\n<p>FP5 (1998\u20132002) marked a critical juncture by requiring proposals to describe how they considered gender issues. FP6 (2002\u20132006) expanded these requirements by asking for more detailed sex and gender analysis and the inclusion of gender expertise, but many researchers struggled to apply them. FP7 (2006\u20132013) therefore simplified some provisions, focusing more on awareness and capacity-building. Horizon 2020 (2014\u20132020) reintroduced gender as a cross-cutting issue, while Horizon Europe (2021\u20132027) strengthened the gender dimension through several institutional anchors at once: eligibility rules, proposal requirements, evaluation expectations and the framing of sex and gender analysis as part of research excellence. This sequence illustrates that institutionalisation is not simply cumulative: formal requirements stabilise only when accompanied by guidance, reviewer competence and implementation support.<\/p>\n<p>In this context, IGiRD is viewed through the lens of \u201cexcellence in science\u201d. This framing builds on a growing body of evidence and has gained recognition among researchers, policymakers, funders, publishers, journal editors, reviewers and gender scholars. It supports engagement within the scientific community on how integrating sex and gender analysis can improve research quality and contribute to economic and societal wellbeing (Portia Ltd <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2010\" title=\"Portia Ltd (2010) Recommendations for action on the gender dimension in science. Available at: &#010;                  https:\/\/gender-summit.com\/archive\/images\/genSET_Recommendations_for_Action_on_the_Gender_Dimension_in_Science.pdf&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR55\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1306\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2010<\/a>).<\/p>\n<p>Although the EU\u2019s IGiRD policy is comparatively strategic and centrally coordinated due to its integration into its framework programmes, the EU, unlike nation-states, shares competencies in R&amp;I policies with the member states. Occasionally, it relies on intergovernmental agreements\u2014of which the ERA is a prime example\u2014to shape and influence the commitments of its member states. Significant challenges remain in harmonising gender policies across diverse national contexts and ensuring consistent enforcement and monitoring of gender mainstreaming initiatives. Recent ERA developments further indicate that the EU pathway is moving toward path stabilisation through implementation, monitoring and evaluation rather than toward a fundamental reorientation of its IGiRD approach. For instance, in 2023, the Hungarian Court of Auditors criticised the university system for promoting so-called \u201cpink education,\u201d emphasising traditional roles for women as homemakers and mothers rather than encouraging their full integration into academia. This assessment highlights the persistent cultural and political barriers to achieving EU-wide gender equity in research. It also shows that programmatic embedding at EU level does not remove political contestation or implementation gaps at national level.<\/p>\n<p>On the other hand, member states follow the EU\u2019s approach with national flagship initiatives. The Irish Research Council (<a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2013\" title=\"Irish Research Council (2013) Gender strategy &amp; action plan 2013&#x2013;2020: Ensuring excellence and maximising creativity and innovation in Irish research. &#010;                  https:\/\/research.ie\/assets\/uploads\/2013\/01\/irish_research_council_gender_action_plan_2013_-2020.pdf&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR30\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1316\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2013<\/a>) mandated the inclusion of sex and gender analysis in all research proposals, a practice also adopted by the German Research Foundation (DFG <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2020\" title=\"Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (2020) Sex, gender and diversity: Importance to research projects. Statement of the Senate of the DFG. &#010;                  https:\/\/www.dfg.de\/resource\/blob\/334066\/stellungnahme-en.pdf&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR9\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1319\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2020<\/a>). Additionally, Germany\u2019s funding programme Gender Aspects in Focus (DLR Projekttr\u00e4ger, n.d.) allows national research organisations to secure funding to structurally anchor IGiRD into their processes. The Third Spanish Strategic Plan for the Effective Equality of Women and Men set out a broader equality-policy framework (Government of Spain <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2022\" title=\"Government of Spain (2022) The Government of Spain approves the Third Strategic Plan for the Effective Equality of Women and Men 2022&#x2013;2025. La Moncloa. &#010;                  https:\/\/www.lamoncloa.gob.es\/lang\/en\/gobierno\/councilministers\/Paginas\/2022\/20220308_council.aspx&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR23\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1322\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2022<\/a>), while Spanish higher education has also seen teaching and curricular initiatives on gender equality (Gonz\u00e1lez Torrico <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2023\" title=\"Gonz&#xE1;lez Torrico MC (2023) A statutory requirement? Teaching innovation for gender equality at university. Int J Educ Dev 96: 102704. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1016\/j.ijedudev.2022.102704&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR22\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1325\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2023<\/a>). These examples illustrate how EU-level requirements can generate feedback effects within member states by encouraging national funders, universities and research organisations to develop their own operational embedding mechanisms.<\/p>\n<p>Policy diffusion: global impact of EU\u2019s IGiRD policy<\/p>\n<p>The EU\u2019s approach to requiring sex and gender analysis in grant proposals resonates with similar initiatives globally. The Wellcome Trust (Hunt <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2023\" title=\"Hunt L (2023) A policy framework for inclusive research design. Wellcome. &#010;                  https:\/\/wellcome.org\/news\/policy-framework-inclusive-research-design&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR29\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1336\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2023<\/a>) developed a five-part framework to assist research funding organisations in implementing and evaluating policies related to sex, gender, and diversity analysis. The American Physiological Society (Miller <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2012\" title=\"Miller VM (2012) In pursuit of scientific excellence: Sex matters. Adv Physiol Educ 36(2):83&#x2013;84. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1152\/advan.00039.2012&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR45\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1339\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2012<\/a>) requires authors to report the sex of cells and human research participants, while Nature Medicine (<a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2022\" title=\"Nature Medicine (2022) Raising the bar on sex and gender reporting in research. Nat Med 28(6):1099. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1038\/s41591-022-01860-w&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR50\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1342\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2022<\/a>) prompts authors to detail how sex and gender were considered in their study design, data analysis, and interpretation. Following the 2013 Gender Summit, Canadian granting agencies began integrating Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (EDI) principles into research agendas, and South Korea\u2019s Framework Act on Science and Technology (2021) mandates gender-inclusive approaches in policies and evaluations. These developments should be interpreted as policy diffusion and selective adaptation rather than simple replication of the EU model. They show that IGiRD can travel through funding rules, reporting standards, journals, expert networks, international summits and national legal reforms.<\/p>\n<p>The EU\u2019s approach has been emulated by other funding bodies, which increasingly stipulate that sex and gender analysis must be included in grant proposals as a funding criterion. While the direct impact of these funding policies on gender integration remains to be fully determined, such mechanisms could potentially drive compliance with requirements for integrating sex and gender analysis into research. However, as the South Korean case illustrates, formal requirements and legal mandates do not automatically produce substantive methodological integration Lee and Kim (<a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference 2024\" title=\"Lee H, Kim H (2024) How South Korea can buildbetter gender diversity into research. Nature, 632, S13. &#010;                  https:\/\/doi.org\/10.1038\/d41586-024-02688-9&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR84\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1348\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">2024<\/a>). Their effectiveness depends on reviewer expertise, discipline-specific guidance, incentives, training, monitoring and feedback mechanisms.<\/p>\n<p>European funding extends beyond integrating gender into specific research projects, actively supporting the development of Europe-wide and global IGiRD infrastructures. Notable highlights include:<\/p>\n<p>The funding for the development and continuous update of the Gendered Innovations website (2011\u20132020), which serves as a central repository of case studies and tools for IGiRD.<\/p>\n<p>The ongoing Gender Summit series, initiated by the genSET programme, provides a platform for multi-stakeholder exchange and international comparison focused on IGiRD. It has supported policy diffusion and collaboration among European, Japanese and South Korean researchers and has extended the dialogue to the Americas and Africa. This demonstrates the growing recognition of the importance of gender integration in research globally.<\/p>\n<p>The SAGER (Sex and Gender Equity in Research) guidelines (2016), which provide a framework for peer-reviewed journals to include sex and gender analysis in research reporting, setting a global standard for research transparency and inclusivity. The journal policy, while still relatively new, represents a significant advancement as it operates independently of national regulations and is rooted in scientific integrity rather than political agendas. The fact that this policy, like the guidelines from the DFG, emerges from the scientific community underscores its credibility and relevance.<\/p>\n<p>These initiatives illustrate how European funding fosters the institutionalisation of IGiRD, not only within Europe but also globally, by providing knowledge-sharing platforms, standardised tools, and guidelines that drive progress in gender-sensitive R&amp;I. In theoretical terms, they also show that institutionalisation can be recursive: instruments that begin as outputs of a policy process, such as websites, guidelines or expert networks, may later become mechanisms that stabilise and diffuse IGiRD by shaping expectations and practices across research communities.<\/p>\n<p>Regional variations beyond the EU: different pathways rather than isolated beacons<\/p>\n<p>The systematic European approach to institutionalising IGiRD lacks a direct counterpart in the US. More precisely, the US does not have a comprehensive and centrally coordinated federal gender-mainstreaming framework for research policy and funding comparable to the EU framework. This does not imply an absence of federal action. On the contrary, federal agencies\u2014particularly in biomedical research\u2014have played a crucial role in institutionalising the inclusion of women in clinical research and, later, sex as a biological variable. The US pathway is therefore better characterised as a bifurcated institutionalisation pattern: comparatively strong in biomedical and health-related sex\/gender analysis, but less comprehensive and more politically vulnerable in relation to broader gender-mainstreaming and DEI infrastructures.<\/p>\n<p>Remarkably, however, IGiRD has seen the emergence of prominent initiatives outside European frameworks, particularly in Asia. South Korea stands out with its multi-step development of gender equality policies in R&amp;D, beginning in the mid-1990s. In 2021, the Amendment of the Framework Act on Science and Technology emphasised gender considerations in master plans and assessments. This was followed in 2022 by legislation requiring gender-inclusive evaluations for research projects. In 2023, the 5th Master Plan of Science and Technology integrated sex and gender-based analysis into research priorities. South Korea, therefore, represents an important formal-legal SGBA pathway rather than merely an isolated national beacon. Its trajectory shows that IGiRD can become legally and strategically anchored outside the EU model. The event corpus indicates that operational embedding remains incomplete, particularly with regard to binding requirements, reviewer expertise, discipline-specific guidance, incentives, monitoring and feedback mechanisms (also see Kim et al. on the legal framework for SGBA in South Korea in this edited collection).<\/p>\n<p>Today, several leading research institutes place IGiRD at the core of their work, though often with a strong emphasis on health and medical research. The Canadian Institutes of Health Research (CIHR) launched its Institute of Gender and Health in 2000, focusing on how sex and gender influence health outcomes (Canadian Institutes of Health Research, <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference n.d.\" title=\"Canadian Institutes of Health Research (n.d.) Institute of Gender and Health. &#010;                  https:\/\/cihr-irsc.gc.ca\/e\/8673.html&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR5\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1391\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">n.d.<\/a>). Sweden\u2019s Karolinska Institutet established its Centre for Gender Medicine in 2001 to explore sex-based differences in clinical medicine. More comprehensive approaches are pursued in South Korea and Japan. The Korea Center for Gendered Innovations for Science and Technology Research (GISTeR) was founded in 2017 to develop research cases across fields and to promote Gendered Innovations based on these cases (Korea Center for Gendered Innovations for Science and Technology Research, <a data-track=\"click\" data-track-action=\"reference anchor\" data-track-label=\"link\" data-test=\"citation-ref\" aria-label=\"Reference n.d.\" title=\"Korea Center for Gendered Innovations for Science and Technology Research (n.d.) About GISTeR. &#010;                  https:\/\/www.gister.re.kr\/eng\/user\/main.do#&#010;                  &#010;                \" href=\"http:\/\/www.nature.com\/articles\/s41599-026-09484-y#ref-CR36\" id=\"ref-link-section-d242830289e1394\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">n.d.<\/a>). Japan\u2019s Institute for Gendered Innovations at Ochanomizu University, established in 2022, similarly supports the integration of sex and gender analysis into research and education (Ochanomizu University, n.d.). Such institutes and centres are important intermediary translation structures. They do not replace binding funding or evaluation requirements, but they can provide training, methodological guidance, case studies, advocacy and feedback loops that help move IGiRD from formal recognition toward operational embedding.<\/p>\n<p>The EU pathway is distinctive because it combines supranational coordination, funding conditionality, programme-level requirements, monitoring and a research-excellence framing in a comparatively systematic way. This distinctiveness was shaped by a strategic concept for the development of the ERA from the outset, in which gender mainstreaming, including IGiRD, was treated as an important policy approach. This created favourable conditions for civil society and political stakeholders to advocate for IGiRD. However, the fact that the European approach is not a unique trajectory is illustrated by South Korea and now also Japan. The comparison therefore suggests that the EU pathway is distinctive not because it is the only route to IGiRD, but because it combines supranational coordination, funding conditionality, programme-level requirements, monitoring and research-excellence framing in a comparatively systematic way. Other regions demonstrate alternative pathways: biomedical institutionalisation in the US and Canada, formal-legal SGBA anchoring in South Korea, and emerging intermediary research infrastructures in Japan and elsewhere.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"As a result of the event analysis, four analytical clusters were identified: Gender Equality Policies and Anti-discrimination Frameworks,&hellip;\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":196033,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":"","_share_on_mastodon":"0"},"categories":[104],"tags":[211,210,1193,8706,8707,4347,87711],"class_list":["post-196032","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-brussels","tag-belgium","tag-brussels","tag-history","tag-humanities-and-social-sciences","tag-multidisciplinary","tag-science","tag-technology-and-society"],"share_on_mastodon":{"url":"https:\/\/pubeurope.com\/@dk\/117537744316595409","error":""},"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/196032","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=196032"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/196032\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/196033"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=196032"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=196032"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.europesays.com\/dk\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=196032"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}