First published in Deník N.

A new European security alliance consisting of Scandinavian and Baltic countries as well as Poland, Turkey, Romania, and Bulgaria could soon be created, said former Ukrainian defence minister Oleksii Reznikov in an interview. He shared behind-the-scenes insights from negotiations with Moscow near the start of Russia’s full-scale invasion and how he negotiated more military support from Europe.

Some say Ukraine might hand over Donbas to Russia in exchange for Nato membership. Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky said the day before yesterday that Americans had proposed this to him. But is this realistic?

This is a move which, based on negotiation theory, I would describe as the Harvard negotiation approach. Incidentally, one of US president Donald Trump’s envoys Steve Witkoff studied at Harvard.

At its seminars, students learn the term ‘poisoned pill’. It means that during complex negotiations, one side throws it, and when the other side picks it up, discussion about it begins. In reality, however, it is already poisoned.

All of a sudden, we start thinking about two things: whether Russia’s demand that Finland leave Nato is actually justified. And whether Ukraine is prepared to concede territory. This so-called concession, coming from the Russian side, conceals a provocation.

What do you mean exactly?

Either you hand over territory, or you will not be in Nato.

Imagine Zelensky says: “No, we will not join Nato.”

Ukrainians would say: “But we must join, because our constitution enshrines a strategic course towards full Nato membership.”

Zelensky would reply: “We are prepared to give up territory.”

Russia is changing lanes, which is dangerous. These are the Kremlin’s usual negotiation tactics: first, take a hardline position, then retreat.

US negotiator Steve Witkoff and Russian president Vladimir Putin (Source: kremlin.ru)

Are Americans now on Russia’s side?

I would not put it that way. But I would recall the events of February 2025, when, a month after Trump’s inauguration, Zelensky visited the White House.

I watched that scandalous meeting closely for the entire 50 minutes, because I teach negotiation at university.

Trump said during the meeting that he is not one of the parties; he is a mediator who wants to settle this conflict. And I do not think his position has changed.

Earlier talks when Americans negotiated separately with the Russians and the Ukrainians is called a “caucus”, when the parties to a conflict sit in separate rooms.

And you run back and forth between them as the mediator …

Yes. It may appear that the Americans are more on Russia’s side, because they seem to give greater consideration to its arguments. But that is their strategy.

They think it is easier to persuade us Ukrainians, that we are in a weaker position.

But for the US side, the mere signing of a peace agreement would be a victory.

Zelensky was once scolded by his US counterpart in the Oval Office (Source: Zelenskiy official, Telegram)

Europe will presumably be involved in negotiations. It may be that an EU delegation is present rather than one individual, as was discussed at the EU summit in Dublin. Does that pose a problem?

Europe must be represented at the negotiating table, because its security interests are at stake.

And now the question: we are all used to saying Europe, Europe. But what actually is it?

Some understand it as the EU, with 27 member states. And the United Kingdom? And Norway? There are other countries that belong to Europe, such as Switzerland. They also have interests.

If we say it is, for example, the EU plus two, we can assume that one of the commissioners will be at the talks. The EU has an official foreign minister, Kaja Kallas.

It also has a defence commissioner Andrius Kubilius. And there is EU commission president Ursula von der Leyen.

All of them have an official mandate to represent the EU’s interests.

The negotiators chosen will more than likely be diplomats who know the Russian mentality well.

Would that include Kallas?

Why not? She is from a Baltic country, people who know how to speak with Russians. Ultimately, there will not be 10 people at the table, but two.

In December 2019, I was a member of president Zelensky’s delegation. The only meeting with Putin took place at the Élysée Palace then, with French president Emmanuel Macron acting as mediator.

Such high-level meetings take place when almost everything is already prepared — when trusted people have worked everything out and approved the proposals. Only when everything is ready do top leaders meet and bless the document, like a priest in a church.

A European negotiator is now being sought, and you previously said the appointee should know the Russian mentality. But is it also important that the negotiator is accepted by the Russians?

Putin takes notice of only two people in the world: his friend [Chinese president] Xi Jinping in Beijing and Trump.

The three of them think they can divide up the world, so they do not care at all who sits at the negotiating table as the [European] negotiator. Not at all.

Then comes another tier — the other heads of state with whom he negotiates.

But Putin does not sit at the negotiating table. [Kremlin aide] Vladimir Medinsky, [sovereign wealth fund CEO] Kirill Dmitriev, or someone else he has designated, who behave entirely professionally and properly.

Do Russia-Ukraine negotiations unfold as people expect them to?

The reality is different to what you see on TV. For example, in February 2022, four days after the full-scale invasion, talks were held in Belarus. The first meeting with the Russian delegation!

We met on the Pripyat River, at the hunting residence of Belarusian president Alexander Lukashenko.

The Russian delegation was led by Medinsky [now head of the Russian negotiating delegation and adviser to Putin]. The talks were followed by another round of talks in Belarus, with a fourth round in Istanbul.

The Russian delegation behaved entirely in accordance with diplomatic ethics and protocol. And there was no rudeness.

They treated us with absolute respect. And not only that: they addressed me by my first name and as Oleksii Yuriyovych.

Yet for some reason unknown to me, they addressed the head of our delegation [Davyd Heorhiyovych Arakhamia, chairman of the parliamentary group of the president’s Servant of the People party] as “Davyd”. Yet, they used my full name.

How do you expect things to go at new negotiations which will include Europeans?

I am convinced that the same happens when Russians meet our Ukrainian representatives. Russian negotiator Dmitriev is a businessman and certainly no thug.

Professional negotiators from Europe and Ukraine will not communicate with the Russians in an entirely easy and calm manner. But they will also certainly not behave rudely.

Russian president’s special envoy for foreign investment Kirill Dmitriev (right) welcomed US negotiators Witkoff and Kushner at Moscow airport in November (Source: RIA Kremlin ru, Telegram)

Will they shake hands?

Ah! That is quite a complicated question. I too faced such a challenge [in 2022]. Protocol dictated that we should shake hands, but you simply cannot offer them your hand.

It is incredibly difficult – an immensely complicated matter.

In Ukraine, there has been much discussion about the ombudsman, Dmytro Lubinets, shaking hands with his Russian counterpart, Yana Lantratova.

It is an unusual situation, but everyone must find their own way.

One fundamental thing must be understood: when you are a professional negotiator, you have to leave all your emotions in the next room.

After all, you have come here to work in the interest of whoever sent you. It is not about your emotions, but about agreeing a lasting peace in Ukraine’s interest. If you cannot do that, do not travel anywhere.

I too had such a dilemma. At a personal meeting, I told the Ukrainian president quite sincerely that I do not feel qualified as a negotiator.

He replied: “Oleksii, I understand you, but it is necessary. I feel the same way myself, but we need to resolve the issue of humanitarian corridors, to enable people to leave Mariupol, Berdiansk and occupied Volnovakha. And secondly, we must agree at least on an exchange of prisoners.”

Reznikov with Zelensky at the beginning of Russia’s full-scale war. (Source: Oleksii Reznikov via X)

So I put all my emotions in my pocket and composed myself and said to myself: “You are a negotiator – you must bring people something positive.”

That is why I see no problem in how Europeans, Ukrainians, Russians, and Americans work together.

There will be no shouting matches at the table or behind closed doors. After all, such dramatic scenes tend to play out only in front of the cameras as a public relations exercise. Everyone wants to look like they’ve won.

And in such complex negotiations, agreements tend to be written in the format of constructive ambiguity. For instance, if you look at the Good Friday peace deal between Ireland and Britain, you will see that it was written in a way that allowed the Irish Republican Army to stand before its own people and say: “We won.”

Any agreement that is reached now will be with constructive ambiguity where each side will interpret it as it likes.

But I think the most important aspect of peace talks is whether negotiators will have direct contact with their bosses. At Belarus talks, those sitting at the table did not have direct contact.

There was one person who had access to the top, but he was not even sitting at the table. [Russian oligarch] Roman Abramovich was busy walking around, observing from a distance and taking coffee breaks.

It is said that Ukraine was pushed to reject Russia’s peace terms in 2022 in Istanbul by then-British prime minister Boris Johnson.

That suggestion is “durnia” – the Ukrainian word for nonsense. Nobody can influence Zelensky, he makes his own decisions. Johnson’s opinion carried great weight with our president, but not in terms of a dilemma over whether to keep fighting or not.

Personally, I think the main reason for the sharp change in the negotiation process with the Russians was not Johnson, but Bucha. When the Russians withdrew from Bucha, Irpin, and Hostomel, they appeared to have shown some goodwill.

The very next day, I went there with interior minister Denys Monastyrskyi and general Oleksandr Syrskyi, who was then responsible for the defence of Kyiv. I saw with my own eyes the bodies of the dead with their hands tied behind their backs.

It was horrific. That was when we understood that we were fighting an army of rapists, murderers and looters. It was this emotional shock that changed our view on negotiating, not Johnson.

Did you always believe you would manage this war?

In December 2021, the US Senate Committee on Foreign Relations held a closed session. The Pentagon and US intelligence presented a report on the possibility of a Russian invasion of Ukraine.

The information then leaked to the press. Everyone kept saying that in the event of an invasion, Kyiv would fall within three days. Ukraine came to resemble someone given a terminal diagnosis. A neighbour brings them flowers and oranges, but will not invest money or anything else in them. After all, they will die tomorrow.

That was why they supplied us only with weapons suited to guerrilla warfare and street fighting — their maximum range was two and a half kilometres. Everyone thought Ukrainians would fight as guerrillas. But the Ukrainian people disagreed.

Indeed, Ukraine has endured, while Europe does not provide enough aid. As defence minister, what annoyed you most about dealing with Europe?

Nothing irritated me, because I was prepared for everything. And I am an optimist. When you go into talks with partners to persuade them to supply you with weapons, you must be optimistic and courteous. I always tried to understand what might deter somebody from helping and look for counterarguments.

For instance, we produce our own tanks in Ukraine but we did not have enough ammunition. We therefore needed Western-made tanks, which use a different type of ammunition. I approached Christine Lambrecht, who was Germany’s defence minister at the time, and told her: “I need Leopards [a German tank type].”

She replied: “But you have T-72s and T-80s.”

I said: “We have tanks, but we will soon run out of ammunition.”

She went on: “Oleksii, that is not realistic.”

“Why?” I insisted.

“Don’t you understand? The Second World War. German tanks cannot fight against Russia; that is a red line that cannot be crossed,” she said.

Former German defence minister Christine Lambrecht of the SPD (Source: Henning Schacht, Bundestag)

I told her: “All right, Christine, let us approach it differently. Let us at least begin by training Ukrainian tank crews at your training grounds.”

She replied: “Oleksii, you are a lawyer, I know you. If I allow you to train, it will mean that I have given you tanks.”

So I tried a different approach. I met the Americans and told them: “I need three Abrams tanks. They will protect your embassy in Kyiv. And I will show everyone that I have American tanks, so that the Germans can see that you were first.”

Then I turned to the British: “I need three Challengers.” I told them we would place them at a training ground near Lviv. We would be able to say: “Do you see, Germans? We have British tanks.”

I also spoke to French president Macron. I told him: “Mr President, we need your tanks.” In the end, we agreed on the delivery of AMX-10 “light tanks”.

Then I spoke with Polish defence minister Mariusz Błaszczak. He told me: “Oleksii, what else can we do? We have T-72s, we can give you those.”

I replied: “Minister, but you have Leopards.”

To the left of Oleksii Reznikov is Mariusz Błaszczak, Poland’s defence minister at the time. (Source: Oleksii Reznikov via X)

He replied: “But the Germans will not allow us to give them to you.”

I said: “What if you announced that you were prepared to give Leopards to Ukraine if Germany granted you permission?”

That is exactly what he did.

Polish president Duda announced on television: “We are prepared to give Ukraine 60 Leopards, provided Germany grants us permission.”

Then, at Ramstein [the German Allied base], the Polish minister and I organised a so-called tank lunch. Around 15 countries were there, and Boris Pistorius, the newly appointed German defence minister, also arrived.

German defence minister Boris Pistorius among Bundeswehr soldiers deployed in Lithuania. (Source: Tom Twardy, Bundeswehr)

Everyone asked him: “Boris, how are things on your side?”

He replied: “Guys, it is only my second day in office at the ministry.”

We asked him whether we could use German training grounds to train Ukrainian soldiers on Western tanks. The Germans would provide instructors, training grounds, fuel and the necessary equipment. He agreed.

Ben Wallace [then the British defence minister] winked at me and said: “Boris, since your instructors will be working and the Ukrainian lads will be arriving, how about we start training them on Leopards in the meantime?”

“But we are not giving them Leopards yet,” Boris objected.

“But it is only training,” I told him. And in the end, he agreed.

I went out before the journalists and announced: “I have a small piece of news for you: tank crew training will begin in Germany.”

They asked: “On which tanks?”

And I said: “Abrams, Challenger, AMX-10, and Leopard too.”

A photograph with Boris Pistorius from 2023, when the “first” demonstration Leopard 2 tank arrived in Kyiv. (Source: Oleksii Reznikov via X)

Olaf Scholz, then Germany’s chancellor, later declared that we had reached an agreement. Germany would officially supply Leopard tanks to Ukraine. And that is how diplomacy works.

Why, from Ukraine’s perspective, is European and US support insufficient?

Nobody believes Ukraine can win because nobody believes Russia can lose. In fact, you are afraid of Russia losing. Risks are present in the minds of all kinds of experts. Above all, there is the fear of collapse and chaos across the territory of an empire where nuclear weapons are scattered.

The same as what the whole world feared during the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991?

Exactly. The second risk is a wave of migrants who could flee an outbreak of civil war. Millions of people would head to Europe, which frightens everyone to death. The uncontrolled fluctuations in the prices of gas, oil, and other energy commodities pose another risk as is the strengthening of Chinese influence. And, the rise of Islamic radicalism in the Caucasus.

Russia’s Burevestnik nuclear missile has been successfully launched in test mode only once. However, there have been many tests. (Source: Russian Ministry of Defence)

But I still see it more positively. Whereas people said that Ukraine could not win this war, a few months later US secretary of state Marco Rubio said in one of his speeches: “Nobody can win this war.” That is, neither Ukraine nor Russia.

Elections will be held across Europe next year. Do you envisage a scenario in which the political leadership in France changes and the new government becomes less helpful to Ukraine?

It is not so important for all of Europe to agree on supporting Ukraine. What matters is that there is a group of countries that understand Russia poses a threat. I expect a new security alliance to emerge in Europe. It will be based on Ukraine, with its wartime experience, and the United Kingdom. The Scandinavian countries and the Baltic states of Lithuania, Latvia, and Estonia as well as Poland will join. I think Turkey will join, too. And Romania and Bulgaria will also consider their involvement.