Mystery surrounds the future of a troubled Costcutter store in Exeter which closed without warning three months ago. The shutters came down on the Alphington Road shop in July. Before it shut locals reported empty shelves, dwindling stock and a general plummeting of standards.

The shop occupies one of the areas best known buildings and for many years was home to the Crawford Hotel pub. For a decade it was used as a Co-op before closing suddenly in 2025.

It became a Costcutter but lasted barely eight months. The company has not commented on the reasons for its demise. The Costcutter website gives no clue but Google says it is permanently closed.

Don’t let an algorithm decide what Devon news you see – click here to add DevonLive as your preferred Google source.

DevonLive has asked the company and is awaiting a response. The building has a rich history and dates back to 1825.

According to Exeter Memories it was was originally the grand residence of Georgian merchant, complete with large walled garden and stables and named Lion House. An old photo shows a large, handsome building set behind iron railings.

In 1939 it became a hotel. The road outside was the limit of the Alphington floods which engulfed the village in 1960. It regularly hosted wedding receptions, live music and local club functions. The lounge picked up regular drinking trade.

The Crawford Hotel closed in 2011 and there were unrealised plans for it to reopen as the Crawford Arms pub. By the time the Co-op bought it in 2013 it had been out of use for two years.

The Co-op closed in November of last year citing rising operating costs. A message on the shop’s Facebook page thanked shoppers for their loyalty and said there would be a smooth handover to the new retailer. The site was sold and reopened as a Costcutter.