Battle lines have been drawn between two Devon farmers with very different ideas about the future of agriculture. Derek Banbury is a third-generation dairy farmer who believes in intensive farming and is committed to producing food ‘to feed the nation’.
His neighbour is Derek Gow, a high-profile eco-minded farmer who has turned his entire farm into an oasis for nature. The pair are neighbours on land near Lifton but the rolling hills of Devon are about all the two Dereks have in common.
“I don’t know what he’s doing. It’s not farming, it’s just a mess,” says Banbury.
“This is my land and I’m going to heal it” says Gow – a former sheep farmer who has turned away from conventional farming. His focus is on creating a large-scale nature restoration project: digging dozens of ponds, using wild boar to turf up his fields, breeding and releasing endangered native species.
Farmers are finding their businesses under increasing pressure. A 2023 report on a range of farm products estimated farmers were receiving less than 1p in the pound in direct retail profit.
UKs farm subsidies have changed since leaving the EU with new payments for environmentally-friendly land management offering hope. But the overall real-term drop in the value of subsidy farmers receive means many are left struggling to make ends meet.

Derek Banbury (left) and Derek Gow(Image: Joss Barratt)
The two Dereks argue over everything from beavers, storks, wild boar, hedge cutting and the reintroduction of wolves.
The pair are the main characters in a new film by award-winning director James Dawson who says he wants to encourage conversations about how farming and nature restoration can work together.
Filmed over four years, Derek vs Derek’s stories unfold over the seasons. Like the vast majority of Britain’s farms, they’re small family businesses who are more vulnerable than ever to the vagaries of a changing subsidies and shrinking profit.

Derek Gow(Image: Joss Barratt)
Dawson’s gentle film focuses on the underlying crisis of biodiversity loss.
“We’re going to completely change this farm into a haven for wildlife,” says Gow.
He has an unlikely ally in Derek Banbury’s wife Linda who lets holiday cottages to visitors attending Derek Gow’s conservation and wolf conferences.
Derek Gow says that if farmers were paid by the taxpayer to give over 10% of their least productive land to nature, it would make a huge difference. Whilst pesticides have transforming the productivity of agriculture they have also hit insect numbers.
Don’t let an algorithm decide what Devon news you see – click here to add DevonLive as your preferred Google source.
And since the second world war scrub, heath and wetlands have been drained and ploughed up and 97% of our wildflower meadows have gone under the plough.
Intensive farmer Derek thinks rewilding Derek is “destroying a perfectly good farm” while rewilding Derek thinks intensive farming Derek is “a psychopath when it comes to hedges”.
James Dawson says: “Unlike most environmental films it might not make you miserable in the telling. It could be funny (as well as scary) because both Dereks are classic Ealing Comedy characters. Their relationship is not aggressive or angry but shaped by mutual misunderstanding.
“They peer over the high hedge that separates their farms with horror and bewilderment, each neighbour driven by their very different visions of how the land should be used,” he says.
Derek Vs Derek is coming to Exeter Phoenix from 9-15 October (excluding 11 October), as part of its UK-wide cinema release from 2 October.