Exeter Chiefs were beaten 43-40 by Toulouse at the Stadium de Toulouse on Sunday in Round One of the 2026/27 Investec Champions Cup
Exeter Chiefs’ Will Butt runs in to score his sides fifth try of the match (Photo: ©INPHO/Ben Brady)
Rugby can be cruel. Exeter Chiefs deserved to come away from Toulouse with something to show for a monumental performance in one of the all-time classic Champions Cup encounters, but Henry Slade’s 37m penalty kick with the last play of the game drifted wide to see the English side fall agonisingly to a 43-40 defeat against the French Champions.
The spirit is real in this young group from Devon. They shocked the European champions within sixty seconds when Zack Wimbush, who was drafted into the side after an injury crisis in the back three, crashed over in the corner following sharp carries from Will Butt and Ross Vintcent, with Henry Slade nailing a brilliant touchline conversion. Toulouse struck back almost immediately through Ange Capuozzo, before a penalty try and a yellow card for Sam Harris put the hosts ahead.
READ MORE: Toulouse 43-40 Exeter Chiefs LIVE: Reaction and highlights from European epic
Then came the turning point: in the 16th minute, as referee Hollie Davidson showed a red card to Toulouse loosehead Rodrigue Neti for a high shot on Vintcent.
Exeter made their extra man count. Wimbush zipped over for his second after a big miss-pass from Stephen Varney. Despite a Toulouse power surge yielding tries for Joshua Brennan and Teddy Thomas, who was subsequently sin-binned for a deliberate knock-on, Chiefs finished the half in control.
Jack Yeandle touched down from a maul before Varney scored with an absolute stroke of genius, going down the blindside from inside his own half, dummying and sprinting 60m to give Exeter a 24-26 halftime lead.
The second half began at a blistering pace. In the 48th minute, Chiefs captain Daf Jenkins charged down Antoine Dupont, allowing Vintcent to set up Will Butt for a crucial score. Toulouse responded with ruthless quality. Dupont moved to fly-half and pulled the strings as Matias Remue and Romain Ntamack crossed in quick succession to nudge the French giants 38-33 ahead.
Yet Exeter refused to lie down. Patient forward drives from a lineout allowed Wimbush to run in for a hat-trick try on 62 minutes, despite the big winger limping, with Slade’s conversion reclaiming a 38-40 lead.
Disaster struck five minutes later when Ben Hammersley was yellow-carded for head-on-head contact, leaving it 14 v 14. Remue immediately took advantage, stepping Slade to score his second and make it 43-40.
Exeter fought back heroically in the dying minutes. Replacement Kane James produced a stunning maul turnover inside his own 5m line, and with Hammersley back on, Exeter earned a final chance.
After a painful crooked throw at a lineout from young replacement hooker Louie Gulley, the Chiefs pack conjured an unreal moment—driving against the head at the 80th-minute scrum to win a penalty 38m out.
The tee came on for Slade to salvage a draw and cap off a heroic comeback. Exeter’s ‘Mr Big Time’ stepped up, but his kick pulled agonisingly wide, bringing the full-time whistle to end a heart-wrenching, magnificent European thriller.
Toulouse: 15. Matias Remue, 14. Teddy Thomas, 13. Kalvin Gourgues, 12. Santiago Chocobares, 11. Ange Capuozzo, 10. Romain Ntamack, 9. Antoine Dupont (c), 1. Rodrigue Neti, 2. Thomas Lacombre, 3. Dorian Aldegheri, 4. Joshua Brennan, 5. Joel Merkler, 6. François Cros, 7. Efrain Elias, 8. Théo Ntamack
Replacements: 16. Peato Mauvaka, 17. Benjamin Bertrand, 18. Georges-Henri Colombe, 19. Romeo Bonnard Martin, 20. Anthony Jelonch, 21. Marc-Elie Kouassi, 22. Paul Graou, 23. Tommaso Menoncello
Exeter Chiefs: 15. Sam Harris, 14. Zack Wimbush, 13. Henry Slade, 12. Will Butt, 11. Tom Wyatt, 10. Harvey Skinner, 9. Stephen Varney, 1. Will Goodrick-Clarke, 2. Jack Yeandle, 3. Josh Iosefa-Scott, 4. Tom Hooper, 5. Dafydd Jenkins (c), 6. Ethan Roots, 7. Ross Vintcent, 8. Greg Fisilau
Replacements: 16. Louie Gulley, 17. Ethan Burger, 18. Jimmy Roots, 19. Harry Wilson, 20. Kane James, 21. Sam Wolstenholme, 22. Will Haydon-Wood, 23. Ben Hammersley
Referee: Hollie Davidson (Sco)
Assistant referees: Rob McDowell (Sco), Finlay Brown (Sco)
TMO: Dave Sutherland (Sco)