Devon and Cornwall Police says it will ‘take time to reflect’ in the wake of a triple death inquest which highlighted major failings.

Alexander Lewis-Ranwell fatally attacked Anthony Payne, 80, and twins Dick and Roger Carter, 84, at their homes in February 2019.

He was mentally unwell at the time and had twice been released from police cells in Barnstaple in the 48 hours before the killings in Exeter.

An inquest, which concluded on Tuesday, identified a number of healthcare and police failings. Afterwards the families of the men killed called for changes across all the organisations involved in light of the jury’s damning conclusions.

The jury found ‘systemic failings’ and ‘uninformed and incorrect decisions’ made by police and healthcare professionals employed by Devon County Council and G4S which probably contributed to the deaths.

Devon and Cornwall Police has now commented on the outcome of the inquest.

Assistant Chief Constable Nikki Leaper said: “We acknowledge and accept the findings of the jury and will take time to reflect on each of the matters raised in detail. Our thoughts, as always, remain with the loved-ones of Anthony Payne and Dick and Roger Carter.

“Over the past five weeks, the inquest has looked in depth into the agencies that were directly involved with Alexander Lewis-Ranwell before the deaths of Anthony, Dick and Roger on 10 February 2019, including Devon & Cornwall Police.

“The inquest heard evidence from a number of police witnesses.

Anthony Payne

“Areas of learning and change identified during the inquest and prior reviews are being, and have been, addressed. We continue to make every possible effort to ensure the security and safety of any member of the public admitted into police custody, including during their detention and release.”

Lewis-Ranwell was a 27-year-old paranoid schizophrenic when he carried out the killings. He was known to mental health services and police and had twice been sectioned in 2016 and 2017.

He was released from police custody in Barnstaple on February 10 having been held for attacking a man with a 4ft saw. He was bailed despite warnings, clear mental deterioration and bizarre behaviour.

The inquest explored why a Mental Health Act (MHA) assessment was not ordered while he was in the cells and, ultimately, why he was at liberty to kill and not sectioned.

The jury found there were multiple shortcomings in the way that Lewis-Ranwell was dealt with whilst in police custody.

In a statement, the Carter family said they hoped the findings of the inquests would “lead to meaningful, lasting changes across all the organisations involved” with lessons being learned not just in Devon but nationally so that others “are spared the devastating loss we’ve endured over this time”.

Triple killer Alexander Lewis-Ranwell

Triple killer Alexander Lewis-Ranwell(Image: Copyright unknown)

“We believe the evidence heard during this inquest demonstrates the need for a national review of guidance and training on mental health issues in police custody so that meaningful lessons are learned and similar failures are not repeated,” the statement said.

“Further, private companies such as G4S, who have been outsourced to provide public services, need to be scrutinized much more heavily.”

The Payne family added: “We can only hope that the agencies listen to this damning conclusion and take stock of the changes that need to be made to ensure this doesn’t happen again to another family.”

Within hours of his release Lewis-Ranwell had travelled to Exeter and killed the three men while under the delusional belief they were paedophiles

A Devon County Council spokesperson said: “Our thoughts and condolences are with the families of Anthony Payne, and Dick and Roger Carter at this time and we recognise it must have been difficult to hear the details of their deaths again.

“Following the inquest into their tragic killings, the jury concluded that all three died from injuries inflicted by Alexander Lewis-Ranwell while he was suffering from a period of mental ill health.

“In his directions to the jury, Devon Coroner Philip Spinney was clear that the inquest ‘is not a trial’ and ‘is not concerned with attributing blame’.

“The events have previously been scrutinised through civil proceedings brought by Lewis-Ranwell, whose claim of negligence against public authorities in Devon, including the County Council, was struck out before the Supreme Court.”

The inquest found crucial shortcomings in the medical assessment carried out by a G4S doctor who assessed Lewis-Ranwell in custody.

A G4S spokesperson also commented. They said: “We offer our condolences to the families affected by these tragic events.”

Mr Payne, a quiet-living pensioner, had been staying at a friend’s address prior to his death but returned to his terraced home on Bonhay Road on the morning of February 10 to feed his cats.

He was found dead upstairs at his property. Lewis-Ranwell, who did not know him, had walked in off the street and killed him with a hammer. He died of blunt force head injury.

The killer then walked to Cowick Lane via Exeter city centre, where Dick and Roger Carter lived alone in a detached house.

He walked around their property, near the Cowick Barton pub, climbed over a rear wall and fatally attacked the twins with a spade he picked up in the garden.

They died of head and facial injuries. Dick Carter was later found deceased in the kitchen and Roger Carter on the stairs.

Lewis-Ranwell, who was privately-educated and originally from Kent, started experimenting with drugs as a teenager, particularly cannabis, the inquest heard. After the family moved to North Devon he attended fee-paying West Buckland School.

By 2013 he was taking drugs and showing signs of paranoia, believing he was being monitored by electrical devices. His mother said he was clearly delusional and he was sectioned under the Mental Health Act in 2016 and in 2017 after violent incidents.

The days before the killings were marked by his sharp mental health decline. He was arrested on February 8 on suspicion of burglary and for a second time on February 9 for GBH with intent.

He was visited by Dr Mihail Pichiu on the evening of Saturday 9. After speaking to Lewis-Ranwell for 15 minutes, he concluded he was not suffering from an acute medical condition, was not delusional and did not warrant an out-of-hours Mental Health Act Assessment.

Before any further assessment could take place Lewis-Ranwell was released for the second time.

Lawyers representing Devon & Cornwall Police, Devon Partnership NHS Trust, Devon County Council and G4S all attended the inquest as interested parties and their respective roles and interactions with Lewis-Ranwell were examined.

Lewis-Ranwell was cleared of three murders at a criminal trial in 2019. The jury accepted his defence of insanity and he was detained by a hospital order.

Supreme Court justices later unanimously ruled that Lewis-Ranwell was barred from suing the authorities for damages. He had claimed all four were negligent in their treatment of him by failing to provide adequate care and releasing him back into the community before the attacks.