A series of catastrophic failures contributed to the deaths of three elderly men at the hands of a mentally ill psychotic who went on a killing spree in Exeter, an inquest has found.

Anthony Payne, 80, and twin brothers Dick and Roger Carter, 84, were savagely attacked in their homes by paranoid schizophrenic Alexander Lewis-Ranwell in February 2019.

He was suffering from severe delusions at the time, exhibiting bizarre behaviour and wrongly believed the men he killed were paedophiles holding people prisoner.

The triple killer was subsequently cleared of their murders by reason of insanity and detained in hospital.

Now, nearly eight years on, an inquest into how and in what circumstances the three men died has taken place.

The inquest looked at key events leading up to the homicidal spree. In particular the 48 hours before the killings when Lewis-Ranwell was twice arrested and released by police in Barnstaple.

Lewis-Ranwell was released despite ‘grave concerns’ about his state of mind and disturbing behaviour in the cells. Within hours of walking free he had travelled to Exeter and killed the men in what he later described as a ‘whirlwind of destruction’.

Much of the inquest focused on why he was not detained for assessment under the Mental Health Act 1983 and whether warning signs about the danger he posed were missed.

The failures meant that Lewis-Ranwell did not have a MHA assessment which would have detained him and not given him the opportunity to kill.

The jury found there were multiple shortcomings in the way that Lewis-Ranwell was dealt with whilst in police custody.

They highlighted ‘systemic failings’ and ‘uninformed and incorrect decisions’ made about whether a face-to-face assessment was needed before a MHAA could be arranged.

There were also crucial shortcomings in the medical assessment carried out by a doctor who assessed Lewis-Ranwell in custody.

Devon and Cornwall Police officers misunderstood their own powers to detain Lewis-Ranwell under the Mental Health Act and should have used them, said the jury.

Failings about G4S recruitment and training were also identified by the jury.

In all these areas the jury concluded the failings ‘probably made a more than minimal contribution to the deaths of the three men’ on February 10, 2019.

Lewis-Ranwell, then aged 27, had a history of drug-induced psychosis and violent behaviour. He was known to police and mental health services and had twice been sectioned under the Mental Health Act in 2016 and 2017.

On the morning of February 10, 2019, he travelled from Barnstaple to Exeter by taxi and bus. On the way he had a number of chilling encounters with members of the public , including the taxi driver who thought he might strangle him with rosary beads.

He was relieved when Lewis-Ranwell got out of his cab at Copplestone and completed his journey by bus.

Lewis-Ranwell walked from St David’s Station along Bonhay Road and entered the house of Anthony Payne. CCTV showed the killer opening the front door.

Mr Payne, a quiet-living pensioner, had been feeding his cats and taking moving the bins that morning. He was found dead upstairs. Lewis-Ranwell killed him with a hammer. He died of blunt force head injury.

Lewis-Ranwell then walked to Cowick Lane via Exeter city centre. Along the way he had further disturbing encounters – chasing one man from St David’s Church, posing as a policeman at Exeter University and reducing a teenage girl to tears due to his menacing manner.

Dick and Roger Carter lived alone in a detached house. There was CCTV evidence that one of the brothers may have seen Lewis-Ranwell trying to enter the front gate and ushered him away.

Alexander Lewis-Ranwell

Alexander Lewis-Ranwell(Image: Devon and Cornwall Police/PA Wire)

The killer walked around their property, near the Cowick Barton pub, climbed over a rear wall and fatally attacked the twins with a spade he picked up in the garden.

They died of head and facial injuries. Dick Carter was later found deceased in the kitchen and Roger Carter on the stairs.

The jury heard four weeks of evidence. Much of the focus was on Lewis-Ranwell’s interactions with police and the mental health services in the lead up to the killings, particularly the two crucial periods he spent in custody at Barnstaple Police Station on February 8 and 9.

Police officers who dealt with him described him as ‘disturbing and aggressive’. He complained about a lack of oxygen in his cell, smelling explosives, the food being poisoned, eating a hen and losing his unicorn. He said he had a duty to ‘protect all animals and sentient beings in the universe’.

HM senior coroner for Devon, Plymouth and Torbay, Philip Spinney, identified a list of issues for the jury to consider before reaching a narrative conclusion.

He asked them whether there were shortcomings in five crucial areas which ‘probably or possibly made a more than minimal contribution to their deaths’.

Alexander Lewis-Ranwell being released from Barnstaple Police Station, hours before he killed three elderly men.

Alexander Lewis-Ranwell being released from Barnstaple Police Station, hours before he killed three elderly men.(Image: PA)

The areas included how custody staff gathered and shared information. Conversations between medical professionals about whether a face-to-face meeting with Lewis-Ranwell was needed before a Mental Health Act Assessment could take place was another key area.

Dr Mihail Pichiu, a forensic medical examiner for Devon and Cornwall Police provided by G4S, did carry out a medical assessment of Lewis-Ranwell while he was in custody on the evening of February 9.

The jury was asked to look at that assessment and telephone conversations about whether Lewis-Ranwell was suffering from an underlying medical condition.

They also considered whether police should have used their powers to detain him for longer; G4S recruitment; and who made the decision not to refer Lewis-Ranwell for an MHAA.

The jury concluded Dr Pichiu made that decision and that he fundamentally misunderstood how to conduct his assessment. Lewis-Ranwell should have been recorded as having exceeded the threshold for a MHAA referral and he based his decision on a 15 minute meeting.

Lewis-Ranwell, a privately-educated, grade-A student, originally from Kent, started experimenting with drugs as a teenager, particularly cannabis, the inquest heard.

After the family moved to North Devon he attended fee-paying West Buckland School.

After periods travelling to different countries and working as a railway fencer and at polo yards he started to show signs of mental illness.

By 2013 he was living on a campsite, taking drugs and showing signs of paranoia, believing he was being monitored by electrical devices. His mother said he was clearly delusional.

He was sectioned under the Mental Health Act in 2016 and in 2017 after violent incidents.

On February 8, 2019, police were called just after midnight to a report of a man with a drill in the Castle Inn pub in Combe Martin. The landlord said they had a ‘crazy guy’ in the pub being aggressive .

Police arrived and spoke to Lewis-Ranwell outside but allowed him to go on his way.

Eight hours later the owner of a farm called 999 after finding a ‘strange man’ tending to her horse. She described him as scruffy-looking, rambling and not making much sense.

She was terrified and reduced to tears by the encounter.

Lewis-Ranwell was arrested for the first time but bailed in the early hours of the next morning. He was arrested again on Saturday, February 9, after attacking an elderly man with a 4ft saw at his home in Goodleigh .

Farmer John Ellis called 999 and reported the ferocious attack, describing Lewis-Ranwell as ‘crazy’ and ‘bloody dangerous’.

“He’s going to kill somebody,” he added. “He’s just attacked me again. My God, this man’s really dangerous, I tell you.”

Armed police chased Lewis-Ranwell over a neighbouring field and arrested on suspicion of causing GBH with intent. The inquest was shown bodycam of that arrest during which Lewis-Ranwell resisted and needed to be restrained.

The jury heard extensive evidence about Lewis-Ranwell’s behaviour during both periods in custody.

His mother spoke to police officers over the phone and expressed ‘grave concerns’ about her son. She feared for his safety and others if he was released.

“I believed he was having a psychotic episode,” she told the inquest. “I knew immediately he was having a mental health episode and would likely need to be sectioned [under the Mental Health Act],” she said.

He was visited by Dr Pichiu on the evening of Saturday 9. After speaking to Lewis-Ranwell for 15 minutes, he concluded he was not suffering from an acute medical condition, was not delusional and did not warrant an out-of-hours Mental Health Act Assessment.

He left a written instruction for a Liaison and Diversion nurse to see him the next morning. But before that assessment could take place Lewis-Ranwell was released on bail for the second time.

The jury was asked to consider the instruction left by Dr Pichiu, his assessment of Lewis-Ranwell and whether there were any shortcomings that probably or possibly contributed to the deaths.

The jury concluded it was ‘impossible to understand’ what was meant by his instructions.

Lewis-Ranwell was arrested two days after the killings. He was involved in an affray at the Rougemont Hotel in the centre of Exeter. CCTV showed him chasing members of staff around the car park and smashing a lampshade against a car.

The moment police tasered him as he walked down the hotel lobby stairs was also recorded.

At that time of his arrest police did not know he had killed three men. He was charged with murder after the discovery of the men’s bodies on February 12, 2019.

A trial took place in Exeter in November and December of 2019.

Lewis-Ranwell was found not guilty by reason of insanity and detained by a hospital order. The verdict meant he bore no criminal responsibility for the killings.

As an interested party Lewis-Ranwell had been invited to take part in the inquest but declined. It is understood he is still in hospital.

Lawyers representing Devon & Cornwall Police, Devon Partnership NHS Trust, Devon County Council and G4S all attended the inquest as interested parties and their respective roles and interactions with Lewis-Ranwell were examined.

At the conclusion of the inquest the legal representative for the families thanks the jury for the attention they gave to the evidence.

The jury was asked to complete a record of inquest detailing how the men died.

The coroner said they should not use words like ‘crime’ or ‘guilt’ in their conclusion as there was no criminal liability. They could use words like ‘error’ and failure’ if appropriate.

The coroner said it was important to remember the human beings at the centre of the tragedy.

Anthony George Payne lived in Exeter almost all his life and was one of eight siblings.

He enjoyed a quiet life with his three cats in Bonhay Road. He was a big fan of Exeter City and would often enjoy simple pleasures like having a drink with friends at pubs in Heavitree, doing the crossword and reading the paper.

He had been living elsewhere with a friend but had returned to his property to feed his cats when he was fatally beaten over the head.

Roger John Carter and Dick Edward Carter were identical twins who lived at the family home in Cowick Lane all their lives.

They were described by their niece as ‘life-long companions’ who were gentle, kind and considerate men. They worked in the family mushroom-growing business established by their father and loved nature.

Roger was the more reserved and meticulous, Dick the more sociable.

She recalled happy childhood memories at the home their father built in 1930 and shared family holidays in Cornwall.