The Duchy of Cornwall has apologised to tenants for its handling of the sale of the Bradninch estate in Devon and promised new valuations of their farms and homes.
Last week, The Observer revealed growing concerns about the Prince of Wales’s decision to sell off the 1,215-hectare (3,000 acres) holding to raise money for other priorities, including tackling homelessness and the climate crisis.
Tenants have been offered the chance to buy their properties but some cannot afford to do so. Others claim their farms have been overvalued and the duchy has failed to take into account the amount they have invested in them.
Prince William was “not happy” to read the report, sources say. Last Sunday, he spoke to Matthew Morris, the duchy’s rural director, to discuss how to respond.
On Thursday, Morris visited Bradninch and met with the tenants. One said the royal representative was “all apologetic”, and admitted he had underestimated the amount of time involved in disposing of such a large estate.
Morris agreed to new independent valuations, with joint instruction by the tenants and the duchy. He also said he would look again at how the money spent on improvements should be recognised. One tenant said the conciliatory message was reassuring but “talk is cheap” and the “proof will be in the pudding”.
William is selling off a fifth of the land he inherited from his father in 2022 to focus on five geographic “heartlands” in the Isles of Scilly, Cornwall, Dartmoor, Bath and Kennington, south London.
The decision to sell the Devon estate, part of the Duchy of Cornwall since the 14th century, has provoked a furious backlash.
Mary Ryan, a former GP who has lived in Bradninch for 36 years and is supporting the tenants, has accused William of “hypocrisy” for promising to focus on homelessness and mental health causes in urban areas while causing distress and potentially making families homeless in rural Devon.
The King is said to be particularly dismayed by the sale of the Bradninch estate, which he visited regularly when he was Prince of Wales, and sees as the embodiment of the kind of rural community that is the “backbone of Britain”.
Questions are also being raised about whether the Duke of Cornwall should pay capital gains tax. A duchy spokesman said he was exempt because “all proceeds from the disposal of capital assets are required, by law, to be reinvested and are not available for his personal use”.

Bradninch Estate, near Exeter, Devon. John Palmer and Mary Ryan’s property borders the Bradninch Estate.
But the tax expert Dan Neidle said there was “no legal basis” for the exemption, and if HM Revenue and Customs wrote to the Duke of Cornwall, saying he was liable for capital gains tax, he would have to pay it.
“What benefit he thinks he has is irrelevant. If it’s not a company or a separate entity, then, when it makes a sale, it’s a capital gain,” Neidle said. “It’s essential to the tax and the legal system that everyone is treated the same. The King is different but everyone else is the same. The prime minister pays tax. The duke should pay tax.”
The duchy spokesperson said all tenants in Bradninch were being offered first refusal to buy their homes and farms, often with discounts that reflect their length of tenure, type of tenancy and investment they have made in the property.
Eight out of nine farming tenants are actively exploring the purchase of some or all of their farm, and about two-thirds of residential tenants are considering the same option.
“We recognise that these are important and deeply personal decisions,” the spokesperson said. “Every tenant is being supported through the process on an individual basis, with access to practical guidance from the estate team, independent welfare and mental health support services, and ongoing discussions about what is right for their circumstances. These services have been available for many years and remain available throughout this process.
They added: “These changes are part of a long-term strategy to direct future Duchy of Cornwall investment where it can deliver the greatest… benefit for communities, farming, nature and the local economy. We will continue to support tenants with care, respect and fairness, whatever decision they ultimately make.”
Photographs by Mark Cuthbert/UK Press via Getty Images, Francesca Jones/The Observer