Officers have explained what really went down as they faced an axeman, saying they don’t possess ‘call of duty magic’

Lisa Letcher Senior Reporter

20:34, 20 Nov 2026Updated 20:39, 20 Nov 2026

Tithe Hill in Churchstow

Tithe Hill in Churchstow(Image: Google Maps)

Local police have hit back at “armchair expert” critics following a tense three-hour siege in a quiet Devon village where a man armed with a hatchet threatened to kill attending officers. Around 30 police officers and six paramedics descended on Tithe Hill in Churchstow at approximately 1.30pm on Wednesday, November 18, after officers arrived at an address to arrest a suspect for several offences.

According to an officer who was at the scene, the man initially came outside to greet them before suddenly pulling out a small axe and making “loud, animated and highly believable threats” to kill the entire team.

The suspect then retreated inside and continued screaming threats for roughly an hour – a commotion an officer, posting to the Kingsbridge Police Facebook page, joked could likely be heard as far away as Aviemore in the Scottish Highlands.

Fearing the axe would be thrown at the team, officers requested a firearms unit and established a containment perimeter around the property to prevent the man from leaving and harming the public.

In a candid social media update aimed at dispelling local speculation, the attending officer directly addressed criticism from bystanders questioning how the incident was handled. Explaining why a Taser wasn’t used, the officer pointed out that Tasers are mechanical devices rather than “call of duty magic,” making them ineffective in the situation due to wind, line of sight and distance.

Don’t let an algorithm decide what Devon news you see – click here to add DevonLive as your preferred Google source.

File picture of police(Image: Penny Cross)

They also dismissed claims from critics who said they would have simply tackled the suspect, noting that doing so would have required vaulting a four-foot wall and charging uphill at someone making credible threats to their lives.

Walking away was similarly ruled out because the suspect was so agitated that officers feared he would harm himself or attack members of the public. Instead, specialist negotiators repeatedly offered the man peaceful opportunities to surrender while armed officers prioritised non-lethal tactical options.

After negotiators were met with prolonged silence, growing concerns for the man’s welfare prompted specialist Public Support Unit (riot squad) officers to force entry into the home three hours after the standoff began. The suspect was detained without any shots being fired, and neither he nor any officers were injured.

Reflecting on the peaceful resolution, the officer noted that in many other countries, a similar confrontation “probably would’ve ended a different way,” adding: “We’re a police force, not a police ask-nicely.”

A spokesperson for Devon and Cornwall Police said: “At around 1.30pm on Wednesday 18 November officers attended a property in Tithe Hill, Churchstow as part of arrest attempts for a man.

“It was reported that on arrival, the suspect exited the property armed with a small axe and threatened officers.

“He then went back inside the property and following a prolonged period of negotiation, was arrested on suspicion of affray, using threatening/abusive/insulting words or behaviour with intent to cause fear of violence and a racially/religiously aggravated offence.

“The suspect aged in his 40s has been released on police bail while enquiries continue.”