Banking regulatory trends post GFC have increased the cost of capital for riskier assets, such as leveraged finance lending. This incentivised banks to focus more on the arranging, rather than the on-balance sheet holding of certain assets, providing an onramp for direct lenders to step forward while the banks pulled back. This was illustrated during the March 2023 US banking crisis,4 further strengthening the call to raise barriers to lending due to liquidity needs. Banks restructured default risk exposures on pools of loans with the issuance of notes linked to the credit pool or via a special purpose vehicle (SPV) to private credit managers, and non-bank providers stepped up.

In a helpful explanatory article ‘Private credit: Characteristics and Risks’ published by the Federal Reserve on 23 February 2024, the authors note, “There is growing concern that tighter regulations such as Basel III endgame could intensify migration of credit from banks to private credit lenders. Considering borrower risk profiles, such substitution is less likely to occur to bank-held loans, and more so with syndicated leveraged loans. In such cases, banks stand to lose underwriting fees to private credit funds. These developments suggest that private credit will become increasingly important to credit market functioning.”5

While Bank of England’s Lee Foulger underlined the wide financial stability picture in his January 2024 lecture and put the source of finance the context of other funding sources (see Figure 4), he said, “The availability of private credit can be beneficial for economic activity and innovation. By providing finance where traditional means fall short, it can support investment and growth opportunities. And to the extent that private credit substitutes for bank financing, it can contribute to the diversification of financing sources. In many ways lending via private markets is likely to be lower risk from a financial stability perspective than had the lending been undertaken by the pre-GFC banking system.”

Figure 4: Highly leveraged corporates are reliant on a variety of funding sources, including from private credit, private equity and leveraged loans

Figure 4: Highly leveraged corporates are reliant on a variety of funding sources, including from private credit, private equity and leveraged loans

Source: Bank of England

It is often the most viable financing solution for many corporates. Borrowers appreciate the flexibility of private credit, which allows them to use it for expansion, refinancing, and improving working capital. Benefits include better servicing, and an increased number of providers, including one-stop shops such as private equity (PE) houses. Private credit typically also features more ‘bullet payments’, allowing borrowers to invest in growth rather than meeting immediate repayment obligations.

Investor demand for the resulting debt asset is primarily institutional, but retail flows are increasing due to the greater use of the BDC (Business Development Company) structure. Private credit offers compelling performance metrics, such as senior lending returning almost 9% annually over the last decade, which is greater than that for global equities and double that for publicly traded loans.

Private credit assets also offer investors:

Low correlation with public markets;
Current income through interest payments and fees. This is dramatically different from an investment in private pquity, which has a lock-up period typically of 8–10 years before capital is returned to an investor;
An illiquidity premium (investors can pocket the yield spread, often around 250 bps of yield per annum above leveraged loans; and
Potential for portfolio customisation through use of various private credit strategies.

Investors are boosting their investment in direct lending due to its lower volatility, higher yields, and superior risk-adjusted returns over public debt. The Cliffwater Direct Lending Index recorded 12% total returns in 2023,6 with one bank predicting annual returns of 8.5%+ for the next decade.7 Private credit’s resilience has been confirmed, with average returns of 11.6% across seven periods of high interest rates between 2008 and 2023, and losses during the Covid-19 pandemic at half that of high-yield bonds.8

In short, private credit offers investors increased exposure to corporates and sectors, increased flexibility in capital use, increased opportunities to collaborate with borrowers on ESG matters or in work-outs, increased resilience, and increased risk-adjusted returns.