A woman has initiated a R400,000 legal battle after her Mercedes-Benz GLC 220d was towed for repairs following a breakdown, only to later find that she believed the vehicle’s condition had worsened.

The dispute, which dates back to April 2019, has now reached an appeal court where the dealership is challenging testimony from a witness who migrated to Germany.

Mercedes-Benz broke down

According to the judgment, the woman was driving her 2016 Mercedes-Benz GLC 220d along Lydenburg Road in Mpumalanga in April 2019 when the vehicle broke down.

She contacted roadside assistance and her vehicle was towed to Garden City Motors for repairs. The dealership specialises in Mercedes-Benz models.

However, when she later examined the Mercedes-Benz, she believed its condition was worse than when she had handed it over.

The woman sought a second opinion from experts, who reportedly confirmed her suspicions about the vehicle’s condition. She then demanded compensation from the company, but the company disputed liability.

R400,000 claim launched

The woman subsequently instituted proceedings in the Mbombela Regional Court in August 2020, suing the company for approximately R400,000.

The matter proceeded to trial, with the woman and her expert, Mr Faltermeier, giving evidence in February 2022.

While the woman was cross-examined, the cross-examination of her expert had not yet taken place when the matter was postponed indefinitely at the request of the company.

The company wanted to consult before proceeding with the expert’s cross-examination. Four years later, the expert had still not returned to court, while the magistrate who had originally presided over the matter had retired.

Expert moves to Germany

The lengthy delay created a further complication for the woman’s case.

Her expert had relocated to Germany and was no longer able to return to South Africa to give evidence in person.

The woman therefore applied for permission for the expert to testify via an audiovisual link.

The application was made under Rule 26A of the Magistrates’ Courts Rules, which provides for audiovisual evidence in civil proceedings. 

However, the dealership opposed the application, but the magistrate ultimately granted permission in September 2025 for the expert to testify remotely.

Dealership challenges remote testimony

The company then launched an appeal against the magistrate’s decision.

It raised 22 grounds of appeal, including arguments that the woman had not sufficiently established that her expert would be unavailable to testify in person at a future trial date.

The company also argued that allowing the expert to complete his testimony remotely could prejudice its ability to cross-examine him effectively.

Among its concerns were the ability to observe the witness, control his environment, manage documents and detect possible prompting during cross-examination.

The company further argued that the expert had already given evidence in person and that allowing him to complete his evidence remotely would create an unfair split in the manner in which his testimony was presented.

Appeal struck from the roll

The court found that the magistrate’s decision permitting the expert to testify through an audiovisual link was an interlocutory order and did not have the effect of a final judgment.

The court said the order dealt only with how part of the expert’s evidence would be presented and did not determine the merits of the underlying dispute over the Mercedes-Benz.

The court also found that the company had failed to demonstrate that it would suffer irreparable harm if the issue was only challenged after the trial had been completed.

It noted that if an appeal court ultimately found that the audiovisual evidence should not have been admitted, it could address the issue at that stage.

The appeal was struck from the roll, and the dealership was ordered to pay the costs of the appeal.

sinenhlanhla.masilela@iol.co.za

sundaytribune.co.za