Bernie MontásSANIBEL, Fla. —

The Sanibel City Council amended an ordinance on Tuesday, allowing The Island Cow restaurant to rebuild with a mini golf course after Hurricane Ian and a fire destroyed the landmark.

Before the destruction, The Island Cow was a popular spot for residents like Kim Schleider.

“It’s a staple on Sanibel. It’s really nice to see part of Sanibel recovering,” Schleider said.

The restaurant’s owners plan to add a mini golf course to the building, a move approved by the council.

“We have heard feedback from residents that we need things for our families to do,” Sanibel City Manager Dana Souza said.

Schleider expressed concerns about the decision.

“I think it’s a slippery slope because if you let one business in, then you’re going to have a horde of them trying to come,” Schleider said. “What makes Sanibel so special is that it’s natural, it’s serene, and it’s preserved.”

City officials emphasized that the change is not a sweeping shift and includes strict guidelines to preserve Sanibel’s character.

“In this case, The Island Cow will have a restaurant, and that will be complementary to the miniature golf course,” Souza said.

Despite these assurances, Schleider remains hesitant.

“If you have the guardrails up to prevent it from being an overdeveloped area, I would be OK with that,” Schleider said.

The Island Cow’s owners must still submit a final design for the property, and no timeline has been set for construction.

DOWNLOAD the free Gulf Coast News app for your latest news and alerts on breaking news, weather, sports, entertainment, and more on your phone or tablet. And check out the Very Local Gulf Coast app to stream news, entertainment, and original programming on your TV.