Neutron stars are what remain after giant stars collapse, leaving behind a body so dense that its core crushes protons and neutrons into a tightly packed soup. These objects cool very slowly over millions of years, releasing their trapped heat into space.
That slow cooling may not sound exciting, but for physicists it offers something remarkable. A natural laboratory far more extreme than anything we can build on Earth.
A new study shows how these stellar remnants can help test the idea of a new kind of particle—one that could carry a fifth fundamental force of nature. If such a particle exists, it would transform our understanding of gravity and possibly even help explain dark matter in great detail.
“The existence of an additional fifth force can signal a paradigm shift in physics, and many experiments have been devoted to the quest for such a fifth force. Deviations from gravitation at the mesoscopic level (between the macroscopic and microscopic worlds) are, however, very challenging to explore,” Edoardo Vitagliano, one of the study authors, said.
An experiment that can’t happen on Earth
Searching for a fifth force is notoriously difficult. On Earth, any deviation from standard gravity at tiny distances is incredibly small compared with vibrations, temperature shifts, or electrical noise in a laboratory.
That is why physicists are turning to places where conditions are extreme enough to amplify even the weakest effects. Neutron stars are ideal for this because their interiors are packed with nucleons (protons and neutrons) to an unimaginable degree.
If hypothetical scalar particles interact with nucleons, neutron stars would be perfect factories for them. Scalar particles are theoretical particles with no spin. Some extensions of the Standard Model suggest that they might link to nucleons and transmit an additional force.
If this were true, every collision between neutrons or protons deep inside a neutron star would produce these particles, which would then fly out and drain heat. The important point here is that extra cooling would be the tell-tale sign of a fifth force at work.
To check this, a team of international researchers built detailed simulations that follow neutron stars from their formation to their current age. They included all known ways neutron stars lose heat—neutrinos, surface radiation, and internal processes—and then added the possibility of scalar-particle emission.
They tested their models against real, well-measured neutron stars, including the isolated X-ray–bright group known as the Magnificent Seven and the pulsar PSR J0659.
“For the first time, we demonstrate that old neutron stars, such as those in the Magnificent Seven and PSR J0659, place exceptionally tight limits on scalar–nucleon interactions—more than an order of magnitude stronger than any previous bounds,” the study authors note.
But what’s the limit?
The logic behind the researchers’ approach was straightforward. If scalar particles interact strongly with nucleons, neutron stars today should be far colder than what telescopes detect. However, observations show these stars are not unusually cold. Their temperatures match the standard cooling picture.
When the researchers compared their simulations to actual measurements, they found no sign of additional heat loss. Any scenario in which scalar-nucleon particles interact strongly with protons and neutrons would have cooled these stars far more than what telescopes actually see.
Using this mismatch, the researchers were able to find the exact value of the new force. Their analysis shows that the scalar–nucleon coupling must be weaker than about 𝑔𝑁≲5×10−14 — the strongest limit ever achieved for this class of particles.
“As we do not find evidence of exotic energy losses, we can exclude couplings down to 𝑔𝑁≲5×10−14. Our new bound supersedes all existing limits on scalars across 6 orders of magnitude in 𝑚𝜙 (mass of the hypothetical particle),” the study authors said.
Close, but still not there yet
This study shows that the universe itself can push the boundaries of physics in ways laboratory tests cannot. By ruling out strong versions of a fifth force, the results help narrow down which new particles are still possible and which theories have to be modified.
The work also demonstrates how astrophysical objects, especially those in extreme environments, can reveal tiny violations of gravity’s foundational laws, such as the equivalence principle or the inverse-square law.
However, there are limitations. Although neutron stars are extraordinary testbeds, scientists still do not fully understand their inner structure.
As models improve and more neutron stars are observed with next-generation X-ray and gravitational-wave instruments, researchers hope to check whether any of them show unusual cooling patterns that might point to new physics.
The study is published in the journal Physical Review Letters.