This is part of a series of articles on the top local news stories of 2025 as chosen by our newsroom.

By Penticton Herald Staff

Penticton’s cultural community is grappling with a season of upheaval as two of its most cherished institutions — the Penticton Art Gallery and The Dream Café — confront serious financial challenges that have forced difficult decisions and raised questions about their futures.

At the centre of the gallery’s turmoil is the departure of longtime curator Paul Crawford, a figure synonymous with the Penticton Art Gallery for nearly two decades. Crawford, who joined the gallery in 2008, was laid off for 11 weeks in what the board described as a financial necessity, following years of mounting fiscal pressure. Those pressures became publicly evident in 2023 when city council declined the gallery’s full grant request of $145,000, prompting intense scrutiny of the organization’s finances.

Crawford’s impact on the gallery — and the broader arts scene — has been profound. He curated some of the gallery’s most popular and ambitious exhibitions, including shows featuring Bob Ross and Robert Bateman, a Syrian art exhibition, and last summer’s David Spriggs: First Wave. Notably, the Bob Ross exhibit was among the few attractions that drew visitors to Penticton during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic. Beyond the gallery walls, Crawford co-founded Ignite the Arts with his partner Julie Fowler, a festival that has become a cornerstone of Penticton’s cultural calendar. In 2021, his contributions were recognized with the Chamber of Commerce’s Business Leader of the Year award.

Dr. Claude Roberto, the much-loved board president, who later resigned, confirmed that gallery gift shop coordinator Karen Walls was also placed on leave, with no recall date. The gallery reduced its operating hours and number of paid staff.

The board described the measures as unavoidable, emphasizing the severity of the financial deficit and its commitment to keeping the gallery’s doors open.

Crawford later stated he would not return under any circumstances and launched legal action. In the wake of his departure, the gallery’s membership gathered for a special meeting to discuss a restructuring plan and vision for the coming months. The board received support to expand by three members and created several new subcommittees, particularly seeking financial expertise. While an executive director will be hired, the curator position will not be replaced; instead, guest curators will be used for future exhibitions. Admission fees will also be introduced for major shows, a shift from the gallery’s long-standing by-donation model.

Despite the uncertainty, the mood at the meeting was cautiously optimistic, with members expressing a desire to see the institution adapt and survive.

That same spirit of resilience is being tested a few blocks away on Front Street, where The Dream Café — another cultural mainstay — is facing a temporary closure.

A concert right after Labour Day weekend was the last show for now — maybe forever – as the board works to address rising costs and significant debt.

Founded 25 years ago by Pierre Couture, The Dream Café earned national recognition, including a spot on CBC’s list of Canada’s top concert clubs. It was reborn in 2015 as a for-profit co-op after a major community fundraising effort, continuing to host renowned artists and support local musicians while co-hosting events such as Ignite the Arts and PRIDE.

According to board member Jim Meyer, operating costs had risen by roughly 30 per cent in recent years. While audiences have remained strong, the financial strain had become unsustainable.

The board is now hoping for a last-minute solution — an angel investor or community partner — to preserve what Meyer calls a “national treasure.” If the debt can be resolved, the café may reopen as a not-for-profit, potentially with a leaner staff and a renewed focus on music.

This all happened roughly at the same time Penticton City Council unanimously approved its budget which included $500,000 to the Penticton Vees for “transitioning” to the Western League, a new Jumbotron, plus an additional $100,000 to the Sport School Hockey tournament held in the spring.