The housing problems facing dozens of nations across the developed world continue to branch outwards. As millions push uphill against runaway domestic markets, one particularly large superpower has offered a glimpse at a system that is breaking at the seams.
The numbers facing China are quite something.
New home sales across the nation of 1.4 billion have fallen from 16.2 trillion yuan (AU$3.28 trillion) at the height of the boom in 2021 to just 7.3 trillion yuan (AU$1.50 trillion) last year. Property investment continues to contract across the board as developers remain under intense financial pressure, while overall construction activity across the country slows.
What was once one of the largest property booms in modern history is now being openly described by analysts as a painful “reset”.
Reuters columnist Ka Sing Chan warned earlier this year that “the issue may drag down growth for years to come”, arguing the biggest challenge facing Beijing is no longer identifying the housing bubble itself, but containing the fallout from its collapse.
“Bursting bubbles is the easy part,” Chan wrote. “Dealing with the fallout and rebuilding confidence, is harder.”
That confidence problem sits at the centre of a crisis that is giving the ruling party a mighty headache internally, as it simultaneously attempts to branch outward on the global stage as an economic powerhouse.
It appears to stem from a rapid expansion in the country’s now vast middle class.
Huang Youqin from the University at Albany says that after reforms accelerated in the 1990s, “a lot of people, overnight, became homeowners at a very cheap price.”
Much like Australia, home ownership in China is treated both as shelter and as the primary pathway to financial security and upward mobility. Following housing reforms in the 1990s, property ownership exploded across the country as the government shifted away from older welfare housing systems and aggressively incentivised private ownership.
Today, roughly 90 per cent of Chinese households own property — one of the highest ownership rates in the world.
By comparison, home ownership rates in countries like Australia and the US sit around 65 per cent.
While younger generations across much of the developed world have become increasingly locked out of housing markets due to soaring prices, weak wage growth and investor-heavy systems — particularly in countries like Australia, Canada and the United Kingdom — China spent decades moving in the opposite direction, creating one of the most ownership-heavy societies on earth.
But the scale of that success created its own risks.
At its peak, analysts estimated property-related activity accounted for roughly 30 per cent of Chinese economic output. Local governments became dependent on land sales while developers borrowed aggressively. Just like Australians have become accustomed to, apartments in China became increasingly viewed as cash flow assets first and homes second.
Then Beijing intervened.
In 2020, Chinese authorities imposed the so-called “three red lines” policy designed to curb excessive borrowing by developers and cool what was widely viewed as a market in a dangerous state of overdrive.
The move triggered a wave of defaults that engulfed giants such as China Evergrande Group and destabilised much of the broader sector.
Those aftershocks are still being felt five years later across the country.
There are fears that broader confidence has crashed, and that Chinese households are unlikely to suddenly begin spending again “if they feel their net worth is fading”.
That dynamic may prove particularly dangerous in China because property ownership has become deeply embedded in the country’s cultural and social structure.
Eric Fong, chair professor in sociology at the University of Hong Kong, told CNN that ownership became heavily tied to traditional family expectations and long-term security.
“The traditional Confucian value emphasises so much on family,” he said.
Combined with decades of rapidly rising values, property evolved into the default savings vehicle for millions of Chinese families.
Now, analysts say that mentality is beginning to shift.
“There’s still a gap between these signals and a real pickup in actual buying power,” Zhang Xiaoduan from Cushman & Wakefield told CNN, despite repeated government efforts to stabilise the market.
She added that Chinese buyers increasingly understand “the market can go through periods of turbulence,” but the shift is hard to accept for a country where housing, more importantly, cheap housing, was long viewed almost as a guaranteed upward climb.
That change in mindset may ultimately prove more significant than the falling prices themselves.
China still retains far more control over its banking system, capital flows and financial sector than most Western economies, making a sudden American-style financial implosion less likely.
But economists increasingly warn the country may instead face a slower, more prolonged drag on growth similar to the stagnation that followed Japan’s property bubble collapse in the 1990s.
There may be a lesson to be learned from the country’s fallout from overbuilding an economy that became too dependent on property, but it appears to be mostly an exercise in understanding damage control.
Beijing is now trying to stabilise the sector without reigniting the same debt-fuelled bubble that created the crisis in the first place, but for vast sections of the population, it feels like their lunch had been eaten before they got to work.
Read related topics:China