Japan’s Supreme Court has ruled that a blanket ban on voting by prisoners does not violate the Constitution. This is the top court’s first judgment on the matter.
The court’s Grand Bench handed down the ruling on Wednesday.
The lawsuit was filed by Yagihashi Kentaro, who served a prison term for fraud. He was unable to vote in the 2021 Lower House election and other polls while incarcerated. He sued the government, arguing that the legal provision of the public offices election law violates the Constitutional right to vote. He demanded that the government pay him 30,000 yen, or about 188 dollars, in compensation.
Yagihashi had appealed after his claim was dismissed by the district and high courts, which both found the restriction was constitutional.
In Wednesday’s ruling, Chief Justice Imasaki Yukihiko said the restriction on prisoners’ right to vote in elections has largely been supported by the people, who are the sovereigns of the state. He said many other countries impose restrictions on inmates’ voting rights, considering them to be justified.
Imasaki noted that prisoners are allowed to vote in national referendums to revise the Constitution. He said the blanket restriction is increasingly seen as in need of review, but sufficient discussions in the Diet and by the public have yet to take place, and therefore the provision cannot immediately be deemed unconstitutional. Imasaki also rejected the plaintiff’s demand for compensation.
Six of the 15 justices on the bench issued opinions saying the provision is unconstitutional and invalid, as it uniformly restricts voting rights totally regardless of individual circumstances such as the type and specifics of the crime.
In 2013, the Osaka High Court ruled in a separate finalized lawsuit that the blanket restriction violates the Constitution. The ruling showed the differences in interpretation among Japan’s high courts.