A recent Gallup poll has revealed a steep decline in Americans’ perceptions of the importance of higher education. In 2013, 70% of Americans believed that a college education was “very important.” Today, that number has fallen to 31%.
As a college president, I believe that the erosion of trust in higher education is largely self-inflicted. Tuition and fees at many colleges and universities have skyrocketed. Students have taken on enormous debt that can burden them for decades. And many are finding that the better jobs they sought by attending college haven’t materialized. Families across the country are questioning whether college is worth the investment, and they are right to do so.
In Florida, we’re modeling how going to college doesn’t mean going into debt. Florida’s 28 state colleges have long prioritized affordable access to higher education. At Valencia College, our Board of Trustees has not raised tuition in more than a decade. With grants and scholarships, more than 40% of students pay nothing out of pocket for tuition and fees.
Still, even with affordable tuition, students face a tremendous opportunity cost when they enroll in college. They sacrifice time that they could otherwise spend working and earning a paycheck. They juggle homework with jobs, family responsibilities and countless competing demands. Students’ investment is real, even when tuition is free. We owe it to our students to ensure that investment pays off.
For students pursuing a bachelor’s degree, Valencia has long made a powerful promise: complete your associate in arts degree, designed as a baccalaureate pathway, and you’re guaranteed admission to the University of Central Florida. A similar promise now also extends to Florida A&M University. Our associate in arts students know exactly where their Valencia degree can take them.
Valencia is working toward an equally meaningful promise for students pursuing an associate in science degree, designed to prepare students for employment: graduates should earn more than they could reasonably expect to earn by going to work directly after high school.
In Central Florida, many jobs that do not require a college degree offer starting wages of $17–$20 per hour. Students who invest additional time and effort in earning an associate in science degree should reasonably expect that credential to open doors to better-paying careers upon graduation.
With the support of our Board of Trustees, Valencia has established a minimum average annual graduate earnings benchmark of $42,000 for our associate in science programs. Most of our programs already exceed that threshold, with graduates of some programs earning average salaries of more than $80,000.
We’re examining employment outcomes for all programs, working closely with local employers to understand the skills they need, and making difficult decisions about programs that aren’t delivering a meaningful economic return for graduates. Some programs will need to change to better align with employers’ evolving needs. Other programs will need to be consolidated or closed, particularly when employers hire applicants without a college credential or prefer candidates with a bachelor’s degree. These changes will also allow us to reinvest in expanding our high-demand, high-wage programs, including nursing and allied health.
While program closures at colleges and universities often result from declining enrollment or a financial crisis, our decisions at Valencia are driven by neither. Instead, we’re making these changes to ensure that our associate in science degree programs keep pace with our region’s economy, deliver real value to students, and make the best possible use of the public resources entrusted to us.
Students and families who choose Valencia trust that our associate in science degree programs will provide a strong return on their investment, leaving graduates better off for having earned their degrees. We must ensure that our programs honor that trust. It’s a promise every student, every parent, and every employer in our community should be able to count on.
Kathleen Plinske has served as president of Valencia College since 2021.