BarcelonaThe Barcelona Provincial Court has spoken out for the first time on the Andic case, the judicial investigation into Jonathan Andic for the death of his father, the founder of Mango. The court did so to dismiss the appeal filed by the firstborn of the Andic family against the Martorell court’s decision to send him to prison if he did not pay a bail of one million euros –Jonathan Andic paid it that very same day and has been free ever since–. The Provincial Court has decided to maintain all precautionary measures, such as the withdrawal of his passport, the prohibition on leaving Spain, and a mandatory court appearance, endorsing the decision of the Martorell judge instructing the case and considering that there is a moderate risk of flight – hence the bail is maintained and he is not being sent to prison.


Read it all

The Provincial Court’s stance, however, was not unanimous: the decision was approved by a majority of two votes to one. In a 118-page judicial resolution to which ARA has had access, the two magistrates who do endorse the Martorell court’s decision believe, after thoroughly assessing all the evidence in the case, that there are grounds “to support the possible involvement of Jonathan Andic” in the death of his father. However, they also clarify that the accident hypothesis is plausible and cannot be “excluded”.

The Provincial Court’s resolution focuses on important new details of the case, such as the fact that Isak Andic planned in an “undercover” way, without telling his son, a plan to remove him permanently from Mango. This is clear from the conversations with J.L., the Andic family therapist, who was in charge of speaking with the firstborn so that he would embrace the idea of a sabbatical year, of stepping away from Mango, of finding new challenges, without him realizing that it was an imposition by his father – even though the son was clear that he was losing responsibilities at the company –. The sabbatical year was foreseen as the first step of a “gradual” exit from Mango, but a definitive one. In fact, Isak Andic died on December 14, 2024, and it was the previous November when J.L. communicated to the founder of Mango that his son had already accepted the idea of the sabbatical year. Isak congratulated her for achieving it. In December, Jonathan was to communicate this decision to his father, something he wanted to do in a quiet, secluded place, which ended up being the route through Collbató. It was Isak who, after initially canceling it, proposed doing the route on December 14.

“Intense and changing relationship”

In this sense, the Court X-rays the relationship between the two: “The relationship between father and son was intense and changing. The communications show affection, family activities, financial support, and a sustained will for reconstruction. They also document deep conflicts related to the 2015 business crisis, the suspect’s loss of responsibilities, his perception of a lack of recognition, his economic dependence, and the way he conceived the inheritance in life,” the magistrates point out. This inheritance in life is a high amount of money that the therapist demanded Isak hand over to Jonathan so that he could become independent in the professional sphere, and Isak gave him several amounts.

However, the Court is clear and, in a way, downplays two hypotheses that could explain a possible crime: they do not consider the fact that Jonathan could lose his inheritance a motive on its own, nor the foundation that his father wanted to create, an element they believe was not a threat. They also point out that they were therapeutic and figurative terms when, within the framework of therapy, it was mentioned that the father had to die “in his head”. In the resolution, the magistrates refer to the inconclusive results of the Mossos d’Esquadra Mountain Unit regarding how Isak Andic fell or the fact that it cannot be confirmed that the footprint found in Collbató belongs to the founder of Mango. They also question whether it can be ensured that the mobile phone stolen in Ecuador was a way to make information about the case disappear.

The dissenting opinion

From the tribunal formed by two female magistrates and one male magistrate, the latter disagrees with his colleagues and has issued a dissenting opinion. Specifically, he highlights the “indications” that support the “plausibility of an accidental fall,” recalling that the victim had stated that “his knees swelled up when he went up and down” steep slopes. He also insists that the technical reports are not conclusive and that Jonathan Andic’s attitude has been, from the moment of his father’s fall, one of “collaboration.” At the same time, he highlights that both wanted to fix their relationship. In short, he believes the indications are not solid enough to send him to prison.

For the magistrates who do endorse the resolution, there are indeed several pieces of evidence, such as Jonathan’s previous visits to Collbató or the “contradictions” in his explanations regarding the fall – initially, he said he had seen his father fall and later that he had not. Nevertheless, they also state that “in isolation,” none of these indications allow for concluding a homicidal plan.

The defense’s response

Following this resolution, Jonathan Andic’s defense values its “technical quality.” They assert that this judicial text “opens the investigation to consider innocent” the eldest of the Andics, referring, above all, to the dissenting vote, which highlights, they affirm, the “doubtful evidentiary intensity.”

The defense highlights that the resolution values that the accidental hypothesis has “plausibility” and “weakens” the thesis regarding the impact of the foundation and the will. “This resolution balances the debate, focuses on the need for a serene trial on equal terms, and reminds us that criminal reproach requires more than conjectures, lucubrations, or evaluative biases,” the defense asserts.