UK businesses seek compensation after charges for accepting online payments from EEA-issued cards rose at least five-fold.

Little more than a year after the ink dried on the Merricks settlement, Mastercard is facing another proposed opt-out collective action in the Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) – this time alongside rival Visa – with UK businesses seeking more than £700 million over allegedly excessive fees on payments made using European Economic Area (EEA)-issued cards.

The claim, announced today (8 October), is brought by Ann Pope, a former senior director at the Competition and Markets Authority, represented by Geradin Partners. It seeks compensation for a proposed class of approximately 126,000 UK businesses that have accepted online or other remote payments using cards issued in the EEA since October 2020. Pope is no stranger to collective proceedings; she is also spearheading a £2 billion claim against Apple.

Where the Merricks proceedings sought compensation for consumers who allegedly paid higher retail prices because businesses passed on Mastercard’s fees, Pope’s action concerns the costs incurred by businesses accepting payments.

The background

An interchange fee is paid by the bank handling a business’s card payments to the bank that issued the customer’s card. The cost is then reflected in the charges the business pays to accept cards. Visa and Mastercard set the default interchange rates, although the issuing banks receive the fees.

Before Brexit, EU rules capped the relevant consumer debit-card fees at 0.2% of a transaction’s value and credit-card fees at 0.3%. Those caps ceased to apply to UK–EEA cross-border payments after the transition period ended.

Visa increased the fees for EEA-issued cards used remotely at UK businesses in October 2021, with Mastercard following in April 2022. Debit-card fees rose to 1.15% and credit-card fees to 1.5%. On a £100 purchase, that meant an interchange charge of £1.15 rather than 20p for a debit card, or £1.50 rather than 30p for a credit card. For businesses trading with European customers, the claimants argue, avoiding those costs was scarcely a realistic option. The Payment Systems Regulator (PSR) found that Visa and Mastercard accounted for nine out of 10 online transactions at UK businesses using EEA-issued cards.

“Europe is a crucial market for many British businesses, who accept online transactions from EEA-based customers every day without a second thought,” Pope said. “Our legal action seeks to recover what we say UK businesses have wrongly been required to pay.”

The claim

The suit alleges that the card networks overcharged businesses, chiefly by exploiting the removal of the EU caps. Pope’s argument is that Brexit did not bring a corresponding increase in the underlying transaction costs: the UK remained in the Single Euro Payments Area, and the claimants say the costs of accepting these payments remained substantially unchanged.

The action also follows the CAT’s June 2025 judgment in Umbrella Interchange Fee Claimants v Visa and Mastercard, which found that default interchange-fee rules, including those covering inter-regional transactions, restricted competition under Article 101(1) of the Treaty of the Functioning of the European Union. That finding does not settle Pope’s new claim: in the existing proceedings, the networks can still argue that their arrangements qualify for a competition-law exemption because of the benefits they produce.

David Gallagher, a partner at Geradin Partners, said: “Visa and Mastercard have great power over the payments that businesses rely on every day.” He pointed to the CAT’s finding that their interchange-fee arrangements restrict competition and to the PSR’s proposed intervention following the post-Brexit increases.

Regulatory scrutiny

The PSR’s final market review, published in December 2024, found that ineffective competition had allowed the networks to increase fees to an unduly high level, costing UK businesses an additional £150 million–£200 million annually. It found no justification for the increases. It initially proposed an interim cap while it worked towards a lasting restriction but dropped the interim proposal in October 2025, opting instead to develop the methodology for a longer-term cap first.

The regulator’s proposed intervention was challenged by Mastercard, Visa and Revolut, which argued that the PSR lacked the statutory authority to impose caps on cross-border interchange fees. In January 2026, however, Mr Justice Cavanagh dismissed their challenge, ruling that the regulator had the necessary powers under the Financial Services (Banking Reform) Act 2013. The judgment did not determine whether the fees were excessive or what any cap should be.

The thousands of businesses potentially covered by Pope’s action are less likely to be concerned with the niceties of the PSR’s regulatory reach than with whether they are entitled to compensation for fees already paid. The CAT will first have to decide whether the proceedings can go ahead as an opt-out collective action, allowing eligible businesses to be included automatically unless they choose otherwise. Only then can the dispute move towards determining whether Visa and Mastercard breached competition law and, if so, how much the affected businesses should recover.