The demand to exempt the State Pension from income tax is gathering pace, with thousands of pensioners supporting a burgeoning petition calling for immediate reform of what they perceive as an “unfair” and antiquated system. Pension specialists have urged the government to heed the calls of the increasing number of elderly individuals now being taxed on their retirement income.

More than 4,300 have signed a fresh petition imploring the UK Government to cease taxing the State Pension, which campaigners contend should not be included in the personal tax allowance calculation. The allowance has been held steady at £12,570 since the 2021/22 fiscal year and is expected to remain so until at least April 2028, despite escalating State Pension payments.

David Bresnahan, the initiator of the petition, said that it was “wrong to tax the State Pension” – a view echoed by numerous retirees who feel disadvantaged after years of contributing to the system. Pension experts at Spencer Churchill Claims Advice suggest that the petition underscores a broader issue concerning the tax system’s treatment of the elderly.

“There’s growing frustration among pensioners who feel that taxing the State Pension – after a lifetime of National Insurance contributions – is fundamentally unfair,” said a spokesperson from Spencer Churchill. “While many retirees don’t exceed the personal allowance, a rising number with modest private pensions are being pulled into the tax net. The current petition reflects a wider call for reform.”

Pensioners could find themselves facing the taxman as the full New State Pension climbs to nearly £12,000 annually, with additional income from other pensions potentially pushing them over the tax threshold.

The spokesperson highlighted the issue, stating: “The Personal Allowance freeze until 2028, despite rising State Pension payments, means more pensioners will cross the tax threshold each year,” and “What we’re seeing is ‘fiscal drag’ in action-where people end up paying more tax even though their real income hasn’t meaningfully increased.”

Impact of making State Pension tax-free

Experts have weighed in on the idea of making State Pension income tax-free, warning that while it might be a hit with voters, it could prove financially unsustainable without significant changes to the system.

An expert from Spencer Churchill cautioned: “While making the State Pension tax-exempt may seem like a simple solution, it would complicate the tax system and potentially cost the Treasury billions. A more balanced approach might be to increase the Personal Allowance for retirees or introduce a pensioner-specific tax band.”

Recent figures indicate that approximately 62% of the UK’s 13 million State Pension recipients are already contributing some form of tax during their retirement, often unaware they’ve surpassed the taxable income limit. There’s a call for better education to help retirees understand the tax implications of their pension income.

“There’s often confusion around when and why pensioners pay tax,” the spokesperson clarified. “It’s important to remember that income tax is only applied to earnings above £12,570. For many, it’s not the State Pension itself that triggers tax, but the combination of state and private pensions.”

The campaign for change gains momentum as the petition moves closer to the critical threshold of 10,000 signatures, requiring a government response. Should it garner 100,000 signatures, the issue could secure a Parliamentary debate.

Despite this, MPs recently debated and dismissed a similar proposition to raise the Personal Allowance to £20,000.

With an increasing number of elderly facing tax burdens, advocates and authorities are pushing the government to reconsider whether taxing the State Pension remains justifiable, especially in terms of equity and support during retirement.