The main way people benefit from a growing economy is through job creation. The prevalence of higher-paid jobs (the jobs that pay a salary in the top 20 per cent nationally) is key to this. Higher-paid jobs – largely in tradable industries like tech, finance, and communication – are the foundation for the success of a local economy. If a city does not have many higher-paid jobs, it rarely has many jobs at all. This is because higher-paid jobs create the demand for goods and services that supports the wider economy.
Centre for Cities recent briefing – Good growth: What, where, how? – maps the geography of the country’s higher-paid jobs. It finds that in the UK, 73 per cent of higher-paid jobs are located in cities. And over the last decade cities provided nine in every 10 new higher-paid jobs.
This is because cities provide businesses with the benefits of agglomeration: they offer large pools of skilled workers to employ, proximity to other businesses to work with and learn from, and access to lots of consumers to sell to. This helps businesses become more productive (generate higher revenues per unit of input) – which means they can employ more people and pay them a higher wage.
Britain’s 10 biggest cities account for three per cent of land but 73 per cent of its higher-paid jobs
Big cities offer particularly significant agglomeration benefits because of their scale. Figure 1 shows that in the UK they collectively account for 73 per cent of urban Britain’s higher-paid jobs. They do this while accounting for just 60 per cent of Britain’s urban population.
Figure 1: Urban Britain’s higher-paid jobs tend to locate in its big cities
But, Figure 1 also shows that London is driving most of this. The capital accounts for 30 per cent of Britain’s urban population and 52 per cent its higher-paid jobs. The next nine big cities also account for 30 per cent of the population but just 21 per cent of urban Britain’s higher paid jobs.
Outside London, most big cities are significantly underperforming relative to their size. Because of their scale, this has significant implications on the national economy. It also has implications for their wider regions, as residents living outside of big cities often rely on the jobs they create.
If big cities outside London performed at the national average, Britain would have 100,000 new higher-paid jobs
Figure 2 shows that seven of the country’s 10 biggest cities have fewer higher-paid jobs per 100 residents than the national level. If they were all at least at the national level, then Britain would have 100,000 new higher-paid jobs – that’s equivalent to adding a new Leeds and Liverpool to the British economy.
Figure 2: Britain’s big cities often have fewer higher-paid jobs per resident than the national level
To do this government policy needs to focus on helping big cities drive prosperity. Interventions focused on transport and skills are key here:
- A city can have a large population but few highly qualified residents, limiting the number of skilled workers it has to offer businesses.
In London just six per cent of residents have no formal qualifications. In Manchester it is 9 per cent and in Birmingham it is 11 per cent. Similarly, in London 60 per cent of residents have a higher level qualification (university degree equivalent). In Manchester it is 44 per cent and in Birmingham it is 40 per cent.
- A city can also have a large population but a very limited transport network, reducing the number of hireable people living within commutable distance.
In London the average neighbourhood has a transport connectivity score (from the Department of Transport) of 80/100. In Manchester it is 68/100 and in Birmingham it is 66/100. Outside London, all of Britain’s big cities have a far smaller share of residents that can access the city centre within 30 minutes relative to peer cities abroad.
Local government, particularly metro mayors, are best placed to support Britain’s underperforming big cities
In Greater Manchester, and across the country, mayoral led bus franchising and public transport integration is improving transport connectivity and growing the effective size of big city labour markets.
Similarly, skills interventions delivered by mayors are helping to improve access to qualifications. This is increasing the supply of skilled labour within cities, supporting businesses while helping to get people into work.
To achieve good growth in every postcode, cities across the country need to be firing on all cylinders. Because of their scale and relative underperformance, big cities are particularly important. The upcoming ‘rewiring the state’ White Paper must design the next stage of devolution to build on the progress metro mayors have already started to make and support them in going further.