The face of Homo sapiens is flat. Reduced prognathism is one hallmark of the entire Homo genus, differentiating it from earlier hominins and the other great apes with low brows and protruding jaws. Another distinguishing trait is enlarged skulls and brains compared with the apes and archaic hominins predating the Homo genus, such as the australopithecines.

Preferred Google

Yet another distinguishing trait is increasing incidence of gum disease as we progress in hominin evolution from small archaic types such as australopithecines, to larger advanced creatures such as Homo habilis and Homo erectus.

The members of the Homo genus exhibited a pattern of alveolar bone loss – evidently stemming from cyclic episodes of chronic periodontal diseases. The earlier, archaic australopithecines did have some alveolar bone loss, but significantly less.

All this is not coincidence, posit Ugo Ripamonti, Laura Roden and Jakobus Hoffman in a paper in the Journal of Craniofacial Surgery, presenting a novel idea connecting periodontitis and resultant bone loss with evolution of the in Homo species.

Alveolar bone loss is the gradual deterioration or resorption of bone in the upper or lower jaw that holds the teeth. The most common cause, in humans and animals alike, is plaque building up around the roots of the teeth, giving bacteria a happy home and causing localized inflammation. This is painful. If I am a prehistoric hominin and my teeth fall out, I starve and die. The burning question they address is this: Could this very malady which makes it harder to eat partly underlie the emergence of our great big skull and brain?

Cast of the Homo habilis skullCast of the Homo habilis skullClose

Cast of the Homo habilis skull Credit: Gunnar Creutz

Cast of the Homo habilis skull Credit: Gunnar CreutzRelated ArticlesOral bacteria, mon amour

The earlier the hominin, the healthier their jawbones were, the team found based on analysis of 71 gnathic fossils from two types of australopithecines (archaic) and two members of the Homo genus, habilis and erectus (advanced – which some call “the extreme ape”).

The team found no difference in periodontal disease incidence between the two types of australopithecines, africanus and robustus. But they found a significant difference in gum disease propensity between the australopithecines and the members of the Homo genus, thereby proving a trajectory that has been theorized for about half a century.

Homo erectus and Homo habilis both exhibited crateriform lesions (bony lesions looking like craters) and furcation defects (loss of the tooth-holding bone tissue), while the australopithecines did not.

Note that as the jaws and teeth grew smaller from australopithecines 5.3 million years ago to Homo 2.6 million years ago, the Homo genus not only suffered more from gum disease – their chewing power was diminished. So was their masticatory muscle mass, the team explains.

In hominins, masticatory muscles stretch between the lower jaw and various structures of the cranium. The stronger the muscle, the stronger the bite and chewing power and the more massive the skull structures to which the muscle connects have to be.

Thus the most archaic of hominins exhibited heavy jaws connecting to brow ridges and the sagittal crest – a protrusion of bone running along the top of the skull.

The early Paranthropus hominins, robustus and boisei and aethiopicus all had impressive sagittal crests, as did Australopithecus garhi and possibly the more gracile afarensis, though there is argument over that last one’s cranial accoutrements. Africanus didn’t need a sagittal crest to anchor its chewing muscles, it seems. By the time we reach Homo erectus, it had at most a vestigial crest called a “sagittal keel,” though brow ridges remained.

Skull of Paranthropus boiseiSkull of Paranthropus boiseiClose

Skull of Paranthropus boisei with magnificent sagittal crest and cheeks Credit: Bjørn Christian Tørrissen

Skull of Paranthropus boisei with magnificent sagittal crest and cheeks Credit: Bjørn Christian Tørrissen

Flattening the face and weakening chewing power over a couple of million years was caused by random mutation, as always. These changes were accompanied by adaptation and change in diet – let’s not fixate on which came first, the chicken or the egg.

What did they eat? Archaic hominins such as Paranthropus and the australopithecines were about the size of today’s chimpanzees and had small brains about the size of an orange. Unlike the omnivorous chimp, they are believed to have been vegetarian, eating leaves, roots, seeds and nuts, which are hard and tough. They needed to chew powerfully, which means, they needed powerful muscles firmly anchored to the sagittal crest and brow. That also explains the sagittal crest and face shape of the gorilla.

By the time we reach Homo erectus and habilis, they certainly ate of the plant and the seed but were also eating meat, fat and marrow. Clearly they could get by with smaller teeth and lesser mandible protrusion, weaker chewing muscles and less “space” on the cranium to anchor these chewing muscles. They might even get along with some of their teeth falling out.

Homo habilis - forensic facial reconstructionHomo habilis - forensic facial reconstructionClose

Forensic facial reconstruction of the Homo habilis Credit: Cicero Moraes

Forensic facial reconstruction of the Homo habilis Credit: Cicero Moraes

We Homo sapiens, millions of years later, are characterized by flat faces, gracile jaws and no sagittal crest whatsoever. Our brows still beetle a little.

All this ties together with the new theory that the diminishment of the jaw and weakening of the chewing muscles, which didn’t need to anchor quite as strongly to the skull, removed a constraint obstructing the development of our skull and brain. They were, to put it otherwise, free to grow, and they did, the team posits.

But where does gum disease enter the story? When the teeth hurt, chewing is constrained.

“Periodontitis and alveolar bone loss firstly cause reduced masticatory power; and the random mutations setting smaller crowns dramatically lessened the masticatory forces,” Ripamonti explains. As the muscles weakened, the constraint on the top of our skulls was removed and ultimately, the brain could expand and we became the Homo genus.

Skull of an African Homo erectus womanSkull of an African Homo erectus womanClose

Skull of an African Homo erectus woman Credit: Emőke Dénes

Skull of an African Homo erectus woman Credit: Emőke Dénes

They are not saying that developing a gracile jaw and flat face lie behind the emergence of our wonder-brain. These were likely co-evolving biomechanical developments.

In conversation with Haaretz, Ripamonti stresses the random (casual) nature of mutation. Note that we are not saying any of these other species with greater masticatory power were our direct ancestors. We don’t know who our ancestors were. Let’s say our oldest ancestors split from the chimp line about 7 million years ago. From that point on, we know almost nothing for sure. But we have some theories and now Ripamonti and his team may have revealed the secret role played not only by expanding our diet to foods we didn’t need to chew as hard – but also by oral bacteria.

Haaretz Podcast | How the midterms will affect U.S. policy towards Israel