TWENTY-five years ago this month, myself and 19 others from civic society and political parties gave policing in the north a rebirth by joining the new Northern Ireland Policing Board to oversee the Patten reforms and the creation of the PSNI.
On a personal level, it was not easy. Most of my community were estranged from the partisan RUC.
To be clear, they were to us oppressors, tormentors, institutionally biased and prejudiced. To the wider nationalist community, the RUC was a force to be feared and distrusted – even before the outbreak of the Troubles.
I had worked for the late Seamus Mallon, the SDLP justice spokesperson, and had written literally hundreds of statements and letters about RUC abuses of process, infringement of rights and corrosive on-the-ground practices.
As a young person, I suffered the indignities of the indiscriminate stop-and-search tactics by many bigoted officers who could not see further than a surname, school uniform or home address.
Policing was the final part of the peace jigsaw and reform was essential for its survival.
In any normal society, the Patten proposals would have been regarded as moderate, reasonable and created to ensure a better police service was more representative and suitable for a society emerging from a prolonged conflict.
Unionists and loyalists reacted in a predictable way. To them, the RUC was their police service and an integral part of their culture – both of which were true.
They happily turned a blind eye to the real two-tier policing, the corruption of good police practices and the collusion with loyalist and, at times, republican paramilitaries.
But as Mallon often pointed out: “Fix policing and the politics will sort itself.”
The PSNI was created following recommendations by a review led by Chris Patten (Kirsty O’Connor/PA)
Against all the odds and the diversity and differences between the various board members, the Policing Board succeeded where many thought it would fail.
As usual, after the heavy lifting was done, Sinn Féin came to the table.
Despite the challenges and threats, becoming a member of the first policing board is something I have never regretted, as it gave me an insight into the nature of policing as well as a better understanding as to how unionists think.
Thanks are due to Sir Ronnie Flanagan and his change management team for preparing officers for a sea change, and to his successor Sir Hugh Orde who, to my mind, was the best Chief Constable until the present incumbent.
At that time, he was the right man with the right mindset to break the mono kitchen culture in Northern Ireland policing.
The late Sir Desmond Rea and his deputy – more co-chair – Denis Bradley made for a formidable team and truly were the odd couple of the Policing Board, but somehow it was a partnership which worked.
Policing still faces challenges, not least of which is the lack of 50:50 recruitment and the starvation of funds from both the NI Executive and the UK Treasury, but 25 years on it is in a much better place than at any time since the formation of Northern Ireland.
Alas, Sir Desmond did not live long enough to hear the plaudits last week.
Denis Bradley still keeps a watching brief on policing matters and his thoughts are shared through this paper. As usual, he has a thought-provoking and at times contrarian style to matters of the day.
Policing Board Chairman Desmond Rea with Vice Chairman Denis Bradley PICTURE: STEPHEN DAVISON
Some of today’s challenges for policing were evidenced by the crisis at Drumcree, which is a microcosm of society in general. It shows all too clearly how fragile political and community relations are in the north.
Just as I and others had to reconcile ourselves with taking personal and community responsibility for policing, reconciliation has never been meaningfully attempted in the north since the Good Friday Agreement. The lack of political and moral courage in this area has been abysmal.
Far from reconciling themselves to each other through the power-sharing arrangements at Stormont, the political parties resigned themselves to it as their least worst option.
Even the visuals of power-sharing don’t work. Ministerial questions in the Assembly are like a version of Punch and Judy. At least Mallon and Trimble, for all their own personal tensions, managed to have the confidence to take their ministerial questions by standing in front of the elected members of their respective coalition partners.
Now we have ministers who present themselves not as ministers for all but for their own side.
The reconciliation process should be top down in Northern Ireland as much as bottom up. The core principle of reconciliation is respect for difference and diversity and this has not been met by political leaders as they regularly use language about each other more suited to fishwives.
The bastardisation of the Good Friday Agreement in the St Andrew’s Accord turned the electoral pitch for the joint roles of first and deputy first minister into a schoolyard competition to see who could pee highest.
Reconciliation needs prioritised now. Southern voters watching Drumcree unfold will be naturally cautious about a race to embrace the north if it imports with it naked sectarianism and hatred.
Micheál Martin remains the adult in the room on the need to invest in reconciliation and in promoting better community relations, shared space and building infrastructure which actually makes bringing people together easier.
His approach is based on logic, not emotion or wishful thinking. The recent decision to launch a study group on the options for a new Ireland within the Department of the Taoiseach is less of a u-turn in the unity debate and more of a reasoned, thorough and serious attempt to rule nothing out or in for the future.
The other core pillar of reconciliation is the principle of consent and the taoiseach knows that won’t be easily won by rhetoric.
If you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article and would like to submit a
Letter to the Editor
to be considered for publication,
please click here.
Letters to the Editor are invited on any subject. They should be authenticated with a full name, address and a daytime telephone number.
Pen names are not allowed.

