Presenters, judges and contestants in The Game of Wool. Photo: Channel 4
A controversial gameshow which was at the centre of a row over its “glib” treatment of Fair Isle Knitwear has become the focus of a university study.
Channel 4 was last year accused of sparking a Fair Isle fiasco amid arguments that traditional Shetland knitting had been misrepresented through its show Game of Wool.
Research from the University of Edinburgh has since focused on the spat, with one researcher arguing the programme’s handling of Fair Isle knitwear “illuminates several of the faultlines” modern Scotland negotiates on a daily basis.
“These include tensions between the Central Belt and the Highlands and Islands, desparities in the way in which cultural value is recognised and protected, and the way in which place and heritage can be misrepresented and blurred in order to appeal to wider sensibilities,” the Edinburgh University Press Scottish Affairs findings state.
The paper accuses the programme of appealing to viewer “conceptions of remote islandness, and wifies knitting for their fishermen husbands”.
Written by Sarah Pedersen, Josie Steed and Claire Hannibal, it states “Game of Wool merely exacerbated misunderstandings of a craft that contributes millions of pounds to the modern Scotland”.
The paper has been highlighted by Osla Jamwal-Fraser of SAC Consulting in a recent Crofting Matters podcast.
She said the programme had sparked “a great furore” on how Shetland’s deep-rooted knitting traditions had been treated, and had also seen the Shetland Organisation for Knitters (Sok) find its way into the public eye.
“It was a great furore locally of how The Game of Wool had dealt with Fair Isle Knitwear, and the glibness it had been dealt with,” Mrs Jamwal-Fraser said.
She was speaking to Louise Grains of knitwear firm Jamiesons of Shetland and crofter and yarn producer Donna Smith, in a discussion centred around wool, and the success of Shetland Wool Week.
However, asked whether Fair Isle Knitting should enjoy be assigned official protection measures similar to those enjoyed by Harris Tweed, Mrs Grains said that would be very “difficult” to implement.
“It’s difficult to quantify exactly what we mean by Fair Isle Knitting, and that’s where the problem starts,” she said.
“Any dotted pattern could be classified as Fair Isle patterns. There’s not an exact record. Different people invent new ones all the time.
“Does it have to be from Fair Isle, because that’s an actual location? We’ve run into this in the past with folk saying it needs to be protected, but nobody can agree how you would argue what constitutes Fair Isle.”
Last year Helen Barwick, of Shetland Stitch Club, wrote an open letter to Channel 4 accusing it of showing a “blatant disregard” for the knitting tradition in Shetland.
“I think some acknowledgement and an apology might be in order,” she stated. “Maybe listen to your researchers before the next series, and reconsider the aims of the show.
“Maybe have guest judges for each challenge, who are experts in their fields? Maybe even consider commissioning a documentary about real Fair Isle knitting? I’d watch it.”
The letter, which went online, was viewed more than 100,000 times and received widespread praise from folk the length and breadth of the country.
Responding to the criticism, the show said in a statement to The Shetland Times: “Game of Wool is an entertainment series, and it is our intention that it can be enjoyed by both knitters and non-knitters alike.
“Channel 4 and Hello Halo hold Fair Isle knitting in the highest regard and the challenge in episode one of Game of Wool: Britain’s Best Knitter asked the amateur knitters to reimagine a Fair Isle knit.
“The contestants were tasked with creating a garment with a modern twist on the Fair Isle tradition that acknowledged and celebrated the techniques.
“Each contestant produced wonderful tank tops with their own personal stories knitted into their designs.
“We hope the series encourages many to pick up their needles and cast on.
“Fans of the show can find out more about the history and tradition of Fair isle knitting, and other behind the scenes content from Game of Wool on YouTube.”
Do you want to respond to this article? If so, click here to submit your thoughts and they may be published in print.