Italy’s prime minister said that her government has always been in favor of the deal,
as long as there are sufficient guarantees for farmers

  • By Sam McNeil and Giada Zampano
    / AP, BRUSSELS

Italy on Friday gave crucial support to plans by the EU to seal a huge free-trade deal with five South American nations neighboring Venezuela that has been negotiated for more than 25 years.

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni was long seen as the key vote in the campaign by European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen to rally support for the trade deal with the Mercosur nations of Brazil, Argentina, Bolivia, Paraguay and Uruguay.

Von der Leyen said the successful vote sends “a strong signal” of the EU’s economic clout and stability “in the face of an increasingly hostile and transactional world.”

Photo: EPA

She said she would travel to Paraguay soon, where Mercosur nations are meeting next week.

The European Parliament would vote on it before it enters into force.

“At a time when trade and dependencies are being weaponized, and the dangerous, transactional nature of the reality we live in becomes increasingly stark, this historic trade deal is further proof that Europe charts its own course and stands as a reliable partner,” Von der Leyen said.

Rome confirmed its support for the deal on Friday, with Italian Minister of Foreign Affairs Antonio Tajani hailing it as “good news for Italy.”

“This agreement is destined to boost our exports, with the goal of reaching 700 billion euros [US$814 billion] in exports,” Tajani wrote on X.

Meloni said she never had “any ideological objections” to the Mercosur agreement.

“We have always said we will be in favor of it when there are sufficient guarantees for our farmers,” she told a news conference on Friday. “The agreement’s potential is good, but not at the expense of the excellence of our products.”

German Chancellor Friedrich Merz said that the agreement “is a milestone in European trade policy and an important signal of our strategic sovereignty and ability to act.”

“With this agreement, we are strengthening our economy and trade relations with our partners in South America — which is good for Germany and for Europe,” Merz said in a statement.

The deal would create one of the world’s largest free-trade zones, covering about 780 million people from Uruguay to Romania and one-quarter of the globe’s GDP.

It also gives Brussels a diplomatic win at a time of economic upheaval, providing a stark counterpoint to the gunboat diplomacy of Washington and the coercive export controls of Beijing.

“Given [US President Donald] Trump’s policies of isolating the US from the rest of the world, it is an imperative for the EU to lead trade integration policies at the global level and to look for partners elsewhere,” said Antonio Fatas, a macroeconomist at the French business school INSEAD.

On the other side of the Atlantic, Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva celebrated the agreement. His country’s economy, worth between US$2.1 billion and US$2.3 billion last year, is by far the most robust of the South American trade bloc.

“This is a historic day for multilateralism,” Lula said on social media. “In an international scene of growing protectionism and unilateralism, the [EU-Mercosur] deal is a favorable sign for international trade to be a factor for economic growth, with benefits for both blocs.”

In the wake of Trumps’ tariff wars, Brussels has sought to curtail its dependency on the US market with trade deals forged across the world. The EU has struck deals with Japan and Indonesia, and is working on one with India.

A delay last month to the signing of the Mercosur deal had infuriated Lula and led experts to worry that a last-minute stumble would wreck the EU’s credibility.

“For Europeans, the finalization of free-trade agreements with new partners stands among the best responses to US tariffs, growing protectionism and trade tensions with China,” said Agathe Demarais, a senior fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations.

The current EU reliance on China for some critical raw materials could be broken by tapping into Mercosur’s deposits, Demarais said.

Opposition to the deal was led by France and Poland, with riled-up farmers flooding streets and blocking roads with tractors from Brussels to Athens. Austria, Hungary and Ireland also voted against it.

Irish Prime Minister Micheal Martin on Thursday said in Shanghai during a state visit to China that “we don’t have confidence that [Irish farmers] wouldn’t be undercut by that,” Irish public broadcaster RTE reported.

Martin and French President Emmanuel Macron said that internal negotiations sparked by the political furor surrounding the deal had led to reforms that better protect European farmers.

However, such reforms were not enough to overcome domestic political pressure, they said.

Macron wrote on X on Thursday that three of France’s key demands were now being met: New safeguards to an “emergency brake” of imports if they are found to undercut EU prices by 5 percent or more; the mirroring of EU food safety regulations in the Mercosur bloc; and an increase of inspections of agrifood imports at EU ports and beyond.

Still, Macron said the potential economic gains of the Mercosur deal are limited and do not justify the risks it poses to EU agriculture.

His office said that the deal would only add 77 billion euros by 2040 — 0.5 percent of the EU’s GDP.

Green members of the European Parliament had vowed to take the commission to court over the deal.

They said the agreement would accelerate deforestation in the Amazon and weaken the EU’s climate targets.

Frances Verkamp, trade campaigner at Friends of the Earth Europe, described the deal as “toxic.”

Brussels is “playing a game of imperial dominance in global trade with China and the US that wins nothing for workers or consumers — and even less for nature and climate,” Verkamp said.