When it comes to rugby, no one ever agrees on everything.
From heated debates to endless banter, player assessments aren’t just opinions—they’re powered by stats, pundit insights, and the arguments that keep the sport alive.
But let’s be honest: some players will always split opinion like a lineout throw gone astray. To some, they’re legends; to others, massively overrated. The result? Controversy, passion, and arguments for days.
So, buckle up. Here’s RUCK’s take on the top 10 most overrated rugby stars making headlines right now.
Join the RUCK’s WhatsApp community here and get the latest news sent straight to your messages.
10 Most Overrated Players in Rugby Ranked
10. Ange Capuozzo (Italy) – The young Italian fullback has gained a lot of attention for his electrifying play and highlight-reel moments, but some critics feel that his defensive frailties and occasional lack of consistency make him less of an all-around threat than the hype suggests.
9. Beauden Barrett (New Zealand) – Barrett is undoubtedly one of the best players in the world, but some believe his performances have been inconsistent, particularly at the Test level in recent years. They argue that while he excels in Super Rugby, his form for the All Blacks has fluctuated.
8. Maro Itoje (England) – While Itoje is seen as a world-class lock and one of England’s key players, there are critics who believe that his influence is sometimes overstated, especially when England is struggling as a team.
7. Sam Cane (New Zealand) – As captain of the All Blacks, Cane faces high expectations. Some fans feel his leadership and performances haven’t lived up to the level of his predecessors, like Richie McCaw, making him a target for criticism.
Like this:
Like Loading…