flock COVER.jpg

Solar-powered Flock cameras track license plates of passing cars. This one is in front of Lowe’s along the Carefree/Cave Creek border.

(Tom Scanlon/Staff)

Cave Creek is flying with a growing flock of communities in grounding Flock Safety.

Phoenix and Scottsdale, meanwhile, have not announced any changes to their uses of the controversial automated license-plate readers.

While several Anthem intersections have city of Phoenix cameras, no known license-plate readers are in the community. Even so, there are dozens of Flock and other automated license-plate readers around Anthem.

Indeed, those who shop at one of two (or both) big-box hardware stores in the area likely have been “flocked.”

In front of the Home Depot in the Tramonto Marketplace, for instance, a solar-powered Flock camera silently – even surreptitiously – tracks license plates of passing cars.

Ten miles west off Carefree Highway, a Flock camera tracks cars in front of the Lowe’s Depot in Carefree along the Cave Creek border. 

Automated license plate readers – also known as ALPRs, or just LPRs – are AI-powered cameras that capture and analyze images of passing vehicles, storing details like your car’s location, date, and time.

With what seems to be an endless string of abuse allegations, as well as general concerns about privacy violations, the cameras are drawing increasing scrutiny.

On Aug. 26, the same day the far-larger Tempe pulled the plug on its Flock contract, the town of Cave Creek announced it “administratively terminated its agreement with Flock for the provision of license plate reading technology, effective immediately.”

The Town Council’s Sept. 1 meeting agenda featured “Termination of Flock contract for license plate reading system — Town Manager Grady Miller, Town Attorney Bill Sims, and Town Marshal Adam Stein.”

No details of Cave Creek’s Flock program were provided, however.

According to a press release, Cave Creek “originally sought to find a balance between improving law enforcement capabilities and protecting the privacy of residents. 

“However, it became clear that any local policy or safeguards could not extend beyond the town’s jurisdiction, as Flock’s networked design allows data to be shared and accessed by external law enforcement agencies.”

Cave Creek originally planned to discuss Flock at the Sept. 15 Town Council meeting.

But, according to the release, “in light of several high-profile abuse cases reported locally and nationally, as well as a recent theft of a Flock camera at 32nd Street and Carefree Highway, town staff determined it was in the best interest of the community to discontinue the system.”

After the theft, Cave Creek’s Flock cameras were removed “for safekeeping.”

Neighboring Scottsdale, meanwhile, continues operating its Valley-high 85 Flock cameras; the city of Phoenix uses a competing brand. 

Controversy over license-plate reading cameras reached a fevered pitch in the Valley.

Countering complaints about invasion of privacy, many police departments praise Flock for helping track criminals. But cases of abuse are stacking up.

First, Chandler canceled its Flock contract after a troubling audit.

Then, Surprise, Goodyear and Apache Junction announced their police officers were under investigation for allegedly misusing Flock data. (Surprise later announced an investigation showed its officer did nothing wrong.)

On Aug. 10, Tempe announced it was slamming the brakes on “all data sharing” from its 33 Flock cameras. According to a city press release, “This was in response to privacy concerns expressed by the community and the recent misuse of the system by two local law enforcement agencies.”

Two weeks later, Tempe pulled the trigger and fired Flock.

flock2.png

Cave Creek announced Town Manager Grady Miller canceled its contract with the controversial  company Flock.

(Town of Cave Creek)

Tempe tempest

According to the city’s Aug. 26 announcement:

“Tempe has turned off its Flock automated license plate reader system, will end its contract with the company and will not seek another provider.”

Concerns about invasion of privacy and potential for misuse outweighed benefits, according to Tempe leaders.

New Councilman Bobby Nichols crowed Tempe is “at the cutting edge of the fight against automated license plate reader technology.”

Though hardly the first to fire Flock, “we are the first city in Arizona to explicitly say we are not going to be seeking out a replacement ALPR company,” Nichols boasted.

Nichols recently resigned as Arizona’s assistant attorney general to focus on Tempe.

Less than two months after he took office, Nichols took a victory lap on fulfilling a campaign promise.

During his successful campaign, Nichols repeated a demand: “Tempe (must) terminate its contract with the unsafe surveillance company known as Flock Safety.”

After checking into his office at Tempe City Hall July 1, Nichols hammered at that goal. “I’ve been having a lot of meetings with the chief of police, with city management, with my council colleagues – and just regularly reminding them that this technology is creating more dangers than it is solving,” Nichols said.

For more than a year, since Flock first showed up on his radar, Nichols was convinced “this was a significant issue for Fourth Amendment rights, data security and personal privacy across the board.”

Though hardly as outspoken a Flock/ALPR critic as Nichols, Tempe Mayor Corey Woods shared his concerns – and listened to wails from the community.

Though he stressed the Tempe Police Department did not find any misuse of its Flock system, “when the public is seeing those situations happen in other communities across the Valley and across the country – they begin to get more concerned about balancing public safety versus privacy,” the Tempe mayor said.

The furor over Flock escalated over the last few weeks: “there have been more and more people that have heard stories about these situations that happen outside of Tempe and began to raise issues about the continued use of this technology.”

Meanwhile, some in Scottsdale pledged to take a hard look at its Flock contract.

“Based on resident input and my own concerns regarding Flock,” Scottsdale Mayor Lisa Borowsky said, “I have requested a presentation and discussion to be agendized in the near future.”

Recently reelected Councilwoman Solange Whitehead was more adamant about the license-plate readers.

“My top priority is to end Scottsdale’s contract with Flock,” Whitehead stated.

But the Scottsdale Police Department counters with several cases where its Real Time Crime Center technicians utilized Flock information to quickly respond to crimes.

Though “flock” or “flocked” is becoming a generic term, a la “airbnb” for any short-term rental, Phoenix does not have a contract with Flock.

flock 3.png

A Flock Safety camera tracks license plates in front of Fashion Square in Scottsdale.

(Tom Scanlon/Staff)

An amendment to the Phoenix-Motorola contract was unanimously approved by Phoenix City Council nine months ago – with some strong strings attached. 

The approval included “the stipulation that staff develops a written policy that specifies that Phoenix-generated ALPR data will only be used for local law enforcement purposes … and that the contract will explicitly state that the vendor is prohibited from selling or providing Phoenix generated data to data brokers or third parties.”

Phoenix Police Assistant Chief Brian Lee told the elected officials there are “132 fixed mounted devices throughout the Phoenix metropolitan area.”

Misuse allegations

According to a recent New York Times article, “Police officers can query Flock’s databases to track people in intimate detail without a warrant. Some have used them to stalk romantic partners. ICE agents have used them to hunt immigrants. 

“One Texas officer used them to track a woman across state lines who was suspected of having an abortion.”

On Aug. 26, hours after Cave Creek’s announcement, the flock of Flock trouble continued: The Huffington Post reported “a police officer in Kentucky was arrested Tuesday for allegedly misusing Flock cameras to stalk his ex-partner, with whom he shares a child, more than 2,000 times from January 1 to May 2, 2026.”