Mr. Smith went to Maricopa County Superior Court.

David Smith, a former Scottsdale Budget Review Commission chair, treasurer and city councilman, is suing the city – and demanding it stop collecting some $25 million per year of “preserve taxes.”

According to “Smith v. Scottsdale,” filed Aug. 17:

“The 2004 Preserve Sales Tax of 0.15% should have been sunset as of July 1, 2025, when the preserve fund’s cash of $160 million was $10 million greater than all preserve debt.”

In the lawsuit, Smith calls for “a declaration from this court that further collection of the 2004 Preserve Sales Tax is illegal.”

Smith also asks the city pay the bills of his attorney, Tim LaSota.

“The goal,” Smith told the Progress, “is to compel Council to respect the 2018 vote of citizens and show fiscal responsibility.”

The city did not respond to a request for comment.

Carla, a current member of the BRC – Smith stepped down as chair last year – and “Preserve pioneer,” blasted the lawsuit as “nonsense.”

The lawsuit outlines the history of a series of preserve tax votes, including the 2004 vote “authorizing the city of Scottsdale to impose and collect a special transaction privilege and use (sales) tax to provide funds to be used to acquire land and construct improvements to the McDowell Sonoran Preserve in Scottsdale.”

Scottsdale voters later approved Proposition 420, “which significantly restricted the uses of preserve tax funds,” Smith said.

According to his lawsuit:

“The City Charter as amended by Proposition 420 prohibits the appropriation or spending of preserve funds ‘for any purpose other than the acquisition of preserve land, the building of new trails…or the servicing of (preserve debt) … The only exceptions to these funding restrictions are: funding prior improvements, funding new trails, funding expansion of trailhead parking and funding trail heads that were under construction at the time.”

He insists the Preserve Sales Tax should have ended last year.

“There were then and still are no ‘new trails’ approved, scheduled or anticipated for funding, nor were there any identified expansions of trail head parking facilities nor is there any anticipated ‘acquisition of preserve land’ possible …”

Carla calls that a load of javelina droppings.

“(Smith) ignores the fact that there is still land eligible to be purchased for addition to our Preserve, which the City’s Preserve Commission is currently evaluating,” Carla insisted.

“And when it comes to the Rio Verde Wildlife Crossing and Trail, he ignores a whole subsection of the City Charter.”

But, according to the Smith suit, last year the city “unnecessarily raised $25 million in sales taxes for which there were no identified, lawfully allowable expenditures. 

“Continuation of the 2004 Preserve Sales Tax of 0.15% to its scheduled termination in 2034 will unnecessarily raise more than $200 million.”

Carla’s conclusion: 

“It’s a shame that taxpayer dollars will have to be wasted fighting this.”