Markets overwhelmingly expect the Federal Reserve to raise interest rates this week for the first time in more than three years — but the decision is likely to be a closer call than investors’ bets suggest.
“The probabilities in the market seem higher than I would necessarily assign at this point,” Loretta Mester, former president of the Cleveland Fed, said in an interview. Mester pointed to recent arguments by key members of the Fed’s rate-setting committee, New York Fed president John Williams and Fed Governor Chris Waller, suggesting that neither is convinced a rate hike is appropriate.
However, key inflation data released Friday boosted market expectations for a hike. The Consumer Price Index (CPI) for August showed monthly prices rose 0.3%, higher than the expected 0.2%, crossing a symbolic line in the sand drawn by a handful of Fed officials. Since Friday, traders have been pricing in between 85% and 90% odds that the Fed will raise 25 basis points.
… While the latest CPI data has made Adam Posen, president of the Peterson Institute for International Economics, less certain of a pause, he still thinks the central bank is more likely than not to hold rates steady.
“Ideally, the Fed should never be making up their minds based on one last-minute piece of data,” Posen said. “This is why when you say ‘I don’t want to do forecasts,’ it’s self-defeating. Otherwise, you’re just reacting to a backward-looking, inherently noisy reading.”