A decision many students and families are dreading is getting closer.

Next month, the Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board is likely to vote on closing more schools.

In what could be called a “pregame,” the board’s Sept. 8 featured a no-action, high-attention discussion item:

“Phase II Design Advisory Team – Committee Record and Options Review.”

With former students and families of the recently-closed Pima and Echo Canyon elementary schools still adjusting to those changes, SUSD is charging ahead with a plan to close more schools.

Regarding potential closures and boundary changes, the district will hold a public hearing at 6 p.m. Tuesday, Sept. 22, at 6 p.m. in the Desert Mountain High School auditorium.

“The hearing provides another opportunity for members of our community to provide input regarding potential school closures and resulting attendance boundary changes,” according to SUSD Superintendent Scott Menzel.

At the Sept. 8 meeting, Menzel’s team provided three options – narrowed down from an original list of six plans:

A. Move Cheyenne Traditional K–8 to Copper Ridge; move Laguna Prep and Redfield to Cheyenne campus; potential Desert Canyon K–8 merger.

B. Merge Desert Canyon schools into K–8 at Copper Ridge; close Laguna Prep; repurpose Desert Canyon campuses and Laguna.

C. Close Copper Ridge K–8 and Laguna Prep; redistribute boundaries; possible Desert Canyon K–8 merger.

“Student impact” ranges: Option A, 2,126–2,232; Option B, 2,132–2,153; Option C, 773–872. 

The work of the committee was presented to the SUSD Governing Board “as it prepares to make a final decision in October” regarding closures/repurposing, according to Menzel.

Schools that may be impacted include: 

  • Anasazi Elementary School;

  • Copper Ridge School K-8;

  • Cheyenne Traditional School K-8;

  • Laguna Prep PS-5;

  • Redfield Elementary School PK-5;

  • Desert Canyon Elementary School PS-5;

  • Desert Canyon Middle School 6-8.

Near the beginning of a five-hour plus meeting, two dozen parents – including a few members of the Phase II committee – sounded off on the options. Many emotionally lobbied to keep their childrens’ schools open, with some complaining of the elimination of several of the original six options.

Redfield and Laguna Prep had the most supporters at this meeting.

Comments included:

“Choose a plan that stabilizes your northern schools for decades to come. We do not want to go through this process again. I also respectfully ask that you do your decision no later than October, because families and staff need to have enough time to plan for their children and their careers and their futures.”

“Every parent should fight for their school if they believe in it. But it’s not school vs. school.”

“I am struggling with the disbelief the Laguna families felt when they saw they were in six of the eight models for closure … the models were created with inconsistent data … The process used to create the models was flawed.”

“This process … is about what is best for all of our students.”

“I want to ask that our children remain at the heart of any decision.”

“We all fiercely love our schools. Great respect to the Phase II committee … but I believe there was a serious problem to the process that brought us here.”

“… make a fiscally-sound, long-term decision.”

“Options that may have kept Laguna open were removed from consideration … I’m asking the governing board to pause and use accurate information before making a final decision.”

“Keeping Laguna open is a smart financial decision for the district.”

“Change is uncomfortable – but it’s not tragic.”

At the end of the 40-minute public comments section, board member Mike Sharkey said:

“Thank you all for being here and speaking.”

Echoing the concerns from several Laguna Prep parents, board member Amy Carney stated: “I ask the superintendent to reevaluate option 6 with the proper data.”

More comments are certain to come at the Sept. 22 public hearing.