Last fall, with football season revving up, two groups with all the enthusiasm of fans gathered.
“Save our Pima!” one group chanted.
“Keep Echo Canyon open!” another cluster begged.
Unlike in football, both sides lost at this money game: The Scottsdale Unified School District Governing Board voted to close Pima and Echo Canyon elementary schools.
That saved around $2 million, but …
“Here we go again,” concerned Scottsdale parents are groaning, as SUSD hosts another unpleasant gathering – this one in the Desert Mountain High School auditorium at 6 p.m. Tuesday, Sept. 22.
Students and parents again are likely to demand their favorite schools remain open.
Following the first closures, a “Phase II” committee report that raises questions about “data timing and completeness” as well as suggesting the need for revisions will hardly comfort some school communities.
While this week’s meeting is “listen only,” with no action to be taken – the SUSD board is likely to vote on school closures in October.
With money dwindling, closing Pima and Echo Canyon simply was not enough, administrators say.
“The purpose of this meeting is to obtain public comment regarding potential school closures,” a Sept. 22 meeting announcement noted.
The villain, school administrators and board members argue, is not them – it’s too many empty desks.
“The district administration is proposing school closures,” the announcement continues, “due to declining enrollment …”
This time around, seven schools are potentially impacted: Anasazi Elementary School; Copper Ridge School; Cheyenne Traditional School; Desert Canyon Elementary School; Desert Canyon Middle School; Laguna Prep; and Redfield Elementary.
Three options have been proposed, each having different combinations but the same bottom line: three schools closing.
According to the district, enrollment at these schools declined 23% over the last decade.
Copper Ridge had a staggering two-thirds enrollment loss over the last 10 years, according to the district.
SUSD Superintendent Scott Menzel launched a committee to study the issue in the spring.
Mixing and matching school closure combinations, the committee pondered eight options, “with three advancing for deeper review,” according to Menzel.
The five elected members of the board – Amy Carney and Carine Werner, elected in 2022; and Donna Lewis, Matt Pittinsky and Mike Sharkey, elected last year – were presented with options A, B and C.
Each option revolves around at least one school closing.
The far-from-definitive committee report identifies “Three options advanced for deeper review.”
And, the Phase II summary notes:
“Each option reflects different implementation choices and tradeoffs.”
Parents’ pleas
After the report was unveiled, two dozen emotional parents and teachers spoke at the Sept. 8 meeting. Some complained Laguna Prep is being unfairly targeted in multiple options; others lobbied to keep Redfield open.
Carney echoed concerns from several Laguna Prep parents regarding an error in enrollment computation.
“I ask the superintendent to reevaluate option 6 with the proper data,” Carney said.
With Carney’s request and the parents’ pleas, could revisions be unveiled at the Sept. 22 meeting?
“There will not be any changes prior to the public hearing,” Menzel told the Progress.
He said SUSD’s legal advisor Jennifer MacLennan noted at the Sept. 8 meeting no changes can be made until the public hearing.
“After the hearing,” Menzeld continued, “the board could choose to modify an option, but not prior to the hearing given the notification requirements.”
The options:
-
Move Cheyenne Traditional K–8 to Copper Ridge; move Laguna Prep and Redfield to Cheyenne campus; potential Desert Canyon K–8 merger.
-
Merge Desert Canyon schools into K–8 at Copper Ridge; close Laguna Prep; repurpose Desert Canyon campuses and Laguna.
-
Close Copper Ridge K–8 and Laguna Prep; redistribute boundaries; possible Desert Canyon K–8 merger.
“Student impact” ranges: Option A, 2,126–2,232; Option B, 2,132–2,153; Option C, 773–872.
According to a summary of the Sept. 8 agenda item:
“The Phase II review considered financial viability and potential savings associated with each option, along with transition, transportation, facility, staffing, and student-retention considerations,” a website on the “Phase II” plan explains.
Potential savings, according to the report: Option A, $2.59 million; Option B, $2.68 million; Option C, $2.72 million.
A summary of the committee’s work:
“Option C showed the broadest support for stability, retention, and lower disruption.
“Option A was viewed as the strongest recruitment-oriented strategy.
“Option B reflected a smaller, consistent base of support.”
Under “areas of broad agreement,” the committee reached common ground that “enrollment, financial and facility
challenges are real. Students and the long-term health of SUSD
should remain central.”
But the report also flagged “core tension,” noting “perspectives differed on how to balance stability for current students against potential future growth and recruitment.
Students and parents who want their schools to remain open may be troubled by another note about the committee’s work:
“Participants raised concerns about data timing and completeness, opportunity to revise options, representation and whole-group dialogue.”
The last line of the report is hardly definitive:
“Should any boundary configurations, program opportunities, or revisions to Options A–C be explored further?”