Flock talk continues …

The new hot-button issue around Scottsdale: Flock Safety’s automated license-plate camera system. 

The city has 85 Flock cameras in operation 24/7. Tempe recently canceled its Flock contract for 33 cameras; the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office has 17 Flock cameras

As a Sept. 20 Progress story illustrated, this is hardly just a Scottsdale thing, as “Flock fury” is raging around the country.

More than three years after the Scottsdale Police Department started using Flock, Scottsdale City Council will hear a presentation and discuss the system at its Oct. 6 meeting.

Just getting the item on an agenda was somewhat dramatic.

The agenda item for City Council’s Sept. 22 meeting seemed harmless enough:

“At the request of Mayor (Lisa) Borowsky, direct the City Manager to agendize for the Oct. 20, 2026 regular Council meeting a presentation, discussion, and possible direction to staff regarding

the continued use of Flock technology by the Scottsdale Police Department.”

Councilman Adam Kwasman asked for “a 60-day window.”

Borowsky rejected that, noting City Council received an Aug. 27 memo from Police Chief Joe LeDuc on Flock.

“I’m a little tired of waiting on some of these issues,” Borowsky said. “I’m candidly very frustrated.”

Like other agenda items, this one was open for public comment.

Leading off the public comments section on the topic was Eric Fowler, chair of the Maricopa County Libertarian Party.

He repeated the concerns he shared last year, noting, “11 communities from Sedona to Chandler to Tempe have already cut Flock loose.”

He claimed “22% of all Flock searches in the entire state of Arizona … The city is even paying extra money to keep our driving history for about six months, when Flock’s own default is now seven days.”

Lottie Kimball of the Scottsdale Police Department and Fraternal Order of Police sharply countered that.

“Whatever label is used, police officers rely on ALPR every day,” she said. 

“It helps locate violent offenders, find missing and endangered people, recover stolen vehicles, connect crimes and give officers critical information when minutes matter.”

The agenda report included eight emails, all variations on the theme: unFlock Scottsdale.

Adrian Lopez wrote, “I recently learned about Scottsdale’s Flock Al license plate reader program and I am writing to express

opposition to it.

“I do not want the city surveilling me to this extent. I am a home owner and will happily sell if this isn’t removed over the following year.”

Andy Greenberg called Flock “an extreme invasion of privacy and creates a surveillance state.”

Elizabeth Mann said she wanted Flock removed: “I would like to also add that l am against replacing them with the same product

just with another company.”

Amelia Mulvahill’s take: “While these cameras are often marketed as simple tools to fight crime, they actually create a system

of mass surveillance.”

 

Coming soon

After a motion to move the discussion up two weeks, City Council voted unanimously to put Flock on the Oct. 6 meeting.

Regarding the timing, Councilman Barry Graham said, “I support looking at this sooner than later.”

He raised the idea of “long-term safeguards.”

As the Sept. 20 Progress story noted, the city’s $1.2 million contract signed in 2023 has a five-year “initial term” with a two-year “renewal term.”

The only way to cancel the Flock contract appears to be for Scottsdale City Council to “fail to appropriate sufficient funds … to pay for future goods/services from Flock” during the city’s “annual budget adoption.”

As City Council approved the 2026-27 budget in June, the city could be on the hook for Flock until at least June 30, 2027.