Caleb Flynn found guilty on all charges in wife’s death

Karin JohnsonWLWT Digital StaffTIPP CITY, Ohio —

Caleb Flynn, the former pastor and “American Idol” contestant, has been found guilty on all charges in the killing of his wife.

Flynn’s wife Ashley was found dead in their Tipp City home in February.

Guilty verdict

A jury found Flynn guilty on all charges and gun specifications: aggravated murder, three counts of murder, two counts of felonious assault and three counts of tampering with evidence.

Watch the verdict as it’s read here

The jury deliberated for a little over two hours before returning a verdict.

Sentencing set

Sentencing has been set for Oct. 5 at 3 p.m.

Defense attorneys speak

“We’re disappointed. I fully anticipate a notice of appeal filed,” Defense Attorney Patrick Mulligan said, saying he anticipates the decision will be “fully tested.”

Mulligan said they will file an appeal of the verdict on the basis of lack of sufficient evidence.

When asked about Caleb’s reaction, Mulligan said “he was upset.”

When asked if they would have done anything differently, Mulligan replied no.

Prosecutors Speak

In the hours after the trial concluded, prosecutors in the case thanked Ashley’s family for their trust in law enforcement and in the process.

Prosecutors also read a statement from Ashley’s family, which said the verdict brought justice and accountability, but added that no verdict will be able to bring her back for her loved ones.

The following statement was read by Prosecuting Attorney Paul Watkins on behalf of Ashley’s family:

“Today’s verdict brings justice and accountability for Ashley’s death, and our family is deeply grateful to everyone who helped bring us to this moment.

However, no verdict can bring Ashley back, give the girls back their mother, or erase the pain our family has endured. The cruelty of what happened to Ashley—and the things we have been forced to hear and relive—has at times felt unbearable.

But through all of it, we’ve held tightly to this truth: Ashley’s life will not be defined by the way it ended. She’ll be remembered for the way she lived.

Ashley loved Jesus with her whole heart. Her faith wasn’t something she simply spoke about; it was how she lived. She loved people well, found joy beyond her circumstances, prayed boldly for her family, and wanted her life to point people to Jesus.

Most of all, she loved being a mom. She prayed over her girls, taught them to love God, and showed them what it looked like to live with faith, kindness, joy, and grace.

We refuse to let the evil that ended Ashley’s life have the final word in her story. Our faith does not erase our grief, but it carries us through it. We know Ashley is home with the Lord she loved and served.

As this chapter closes, our prayer is that Ashley’s story does not end with a verdict. We pray that it continues through her girls, our family, and every person touched by the way she lived.

If you want to honor Ashley, love people well. Pray boldly for your family. Choose joy, and point people to Jesus.

We are deeply grateful to the jury for its care and service; the Miami County Prosecutor’s Office; the Tipp City Police Department; the FBI; BCI; and every investigator and advocate who worked tirelessly to seek the truth.

Thank you to everyone who has prayed for, loved, and supported our family. We ask for privacy now as we continue healing and loving Ashley’s girls the way she would want them to be loved.

Please remember Ashley not for how she died, but for how beautifully she lived.”

Trial recap

WLWT’s Karin Johnson has been covering the entire trial. See latest updates here:

During closings, the prosecution broke down the charges Caleb is facing, discussed what the state must prove, described a potential motive, Flynn’s cell phone activity, asking the jury to find him guilty on all counts.

The defense challenged the evidence presented and Flynn’s former mistress Alleigha Botner’s testimony.

Mulligan claimed Flynn’s affair does not equal a murder, while questioning Botner’s actions and motive.

The judge then read lengthy jury instructions before the jury went into the deliberation room. The bailiff did note the jury received lunch first, so deliberations didn’t likely begin until around 1:15 p.m.

During the trial, the state called dozens of witnesses, from special agents to experts to family members.

The defense did not call a single witness.

Jurors heard most from Flynn’s former mistress, Alleigha Botner, who took the stand for two days and read dozens of the more than 100,000 text messages that the two exchanged

Prosecutors say Flynn and Botner exchanged more than 107,000 messages. On the stand, Botner read messages spanning months in which both expressed hatred toward Ashley and discussed a future together.

At one point, Botner became emotional while reading a July exchange.

“I just wish I didn’t say this,” Botner said before telling the jury she had written, “I want to kill her, Caleb.”

When a prosecutor asked who sent that message, Botner answered, “Me.”

Flynn responded, according to Botner, “That makes two of us.”

Botner testified that the couple often referred to Ashley using an insulting nickname. In one message, Flynn allegedly wrote that Ashley had “ruined and taken everything” from him and that he could not stand the sight or mention of her.

The messages also showed Botner repeatedly pressuring Flynn to leave his wife. She set several deadlines, at times threatening to end their relationship if he did not follow through.

The state also called investigators and members of Ashley’s family to the stand, all providing different pieces of evidence for their case.

While no witnesses were called, the defense did spend time on the last day of testimony emphasizing missing physical evidence, challenging the lead investigator about evidence that was either not found or not collected.

Detective Sgt. Mike Morgan acknowledged that investigators did not find Ashley’s blood on Flynn or his clothing. He also testified that investigators did not obtain results from blood-spatter evidence and never recovered the gun used in the shooting.

Morgan confirmed that Flynn was not tested for gunshot residue.

“There was never a gunshot residue test done in this particular case, correct?” a defense attorney asked.

“Correct,” Morgan responded.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE:

Both sides rest in Caleb Flynn murder trial after testimony focuses on digital evidence

Caleb Flynn trial: Victim’s family recounts night of wife’s killing, learning of alleged affair

Caleb Flynn trial: AI-generated songs written for ex-mistress played in courtroom

‘Wish I didn’t say this’: Ex-mistress gets emotional reading texts on stand in Caleb Flynn trial

Former mistress takes stand for second day of testimony in Caleb Flynn trial

Jurors hear texts from Ashley Flynn’s phone, watch Caleb Flynn’s police interviews