Authors Jenan Matari and Nora Lester Murad have filed a lawsuit after the ‘Read Palestine Week’ event was cancelled December of last year

The Los Angeles Public Library was scheduled to hold an event for Read Palestine Week on December 6, 2025, where authors Jenan Matari and Nora Lester Murad were set to have a discussion with young readers regarding their literary works and Palestinian livelihood.

According to a social media post from Matari, the event was abruptly cancelled three days prior to the date. Both authors received emails from the LAPL saying the event would not take place without offering an explanation.

Almost a year later, the city of Los Angeles is now facing a lawsuit alleging violations of the First Amendment due to the cancellation of the event.  

Matari, a Palestinian-American author, and Murad, a Jewish-American author, had a public discussion published today by the Literary Hub addressing the reasoning behind this lawsuit.

“Libraries are under attack not only by right-wing forces outside the library, but also by internal forces with nefarious political interests. Libraries are sites of censorship and also sites of resistance to censorship,” said Murad. “I don’t see the lawsuit as attacking the library. I see it as defending the integrity and credibility of libraries.”

The cancellation of the event immediately caused controversy, with both authors calling out the LAPL over their decision.

According to an investigation published by the Los Angeles Public Press in February of this year, a staff member at the LAPL told the library through an email that both authors had “strong terrorist ties” and “virulently antisemitic views.”

Both Matari and Murad have been public about their opposition to Israel’s war efforts in Palestine, which the United Nations categorizes as a genocide and have taken the lives of 70,000 Palestinians according to official numbers, with independent experts saying the number could be much higher.

Staff at the LAPL signed a solidarity letter asking their employer to apologize and reschedule the event. “We, the undersigned Los Angeles Public Library staff, stand in solidarity with Palestinians and other marginalized communities facing intimidation and cultural suppression,” the statement read.

Multiple advocacy groups such as the Middle East Studies Association made statements regarding their concerns with the decision and what it represented. The National Coalition Against Censorship wrote an extensive letter to the LAPL citing concerns over censorship

In a letter from LAPL librarian John Szabo responding to staff, he stated that “Cancellation of the program was necessary to uphold the Library’s commitment to an inclusive environment free of hate, discrimination, and harassment.”

There are few details on the lawsuit itself, as it has not been made available to the public yet. However, it is worth noting that because the LAPL is a public entity, it is subject to being sued over First Amendment violations.

While there are no specific details on the lawsuit, Murad said during their discussion that “[Los Angeles Public Library] never responded to our multiple requests for a conflict resolution meeting, a provision that was in our author speaker contracts,” alluding to a breach-of-contract accusation.

Matari and Murad were going to present books that centered Palestinian experiences. Matari’s Everything Grows in Jiddo’s Garden and Murad’s Ida in the Middle both featured a Palestinian girl as the protagonist.

Because of the context of the books and the authors’ public stance on Israel, both authors believe the motive behind cancelling the event was not content-neutral, which could be a potential violation of the First Amendment and grounds for the lawsuit.

“It seems that we Palestinians are always negotiating for our right to exist,” said Matari.

During the conversation, Murad alluded to a potential claim of libel when discussing the cancellation.

“The talk they cancelled would have been so important. You and I have such good conversations with each other. They really robbed the children of being able to experience that,” said Matari.

“They really did. And because they have now smeared us with slanderous falsehoods, other young readers may also not have the opportunity,” Murad responded.

The Los Angeles Public Library has not commented publicly on the cancellation of the event, the letters signed by staff and other organizations, or the lawsuit itself.